Europe's news in English

COPY LINK

RACISM

Three men awarded damages after club’s racist door policy

Three young men with a migration background who were turned away from a club in Vienna because of their appearance have been awarded €600 each in compensation.

Published: 20 January 2016 06:55 CET

Three men awarded damages after club's racist door policy

The litigation association ruled that the three men were discriminated against on grounds of race. Five of their friends, who were also turned away after they complained about the bouncer, received €350 in compensation (the first conviction in Austria for indirect discrimination).

The three men failed to get into a club on Vienna's Gürtel ring road because the bouncer said they looked like “people who cause problems.” He let three of their male friends in, saying they looked Austrian. Two young women were already waiting inside the club for them. After they all complained to the bouncer, they were all told to leave.

The case took three years to come to the conclusion that the three men were rejected because of their ‘foreign’ appearance. Their friends were awarded damages on the grounds of discrimination by association.

Their lawyer, Andrea Ludwig, said she was pleased with the decision in principle but criticised the fact that the sums awarded were “very low”. She said that a discriminatory door policy is prohibited in Austria by the Equal Treatment Act but remains widespread practice.

'Some people lost everything': Austria compensates victims of anti-gay laws

Austrian consultant Michael Woditschka well remembers the fateful day when he was summoned by police over his relationship with a teenage boy and subsequently convicted in court.

The 44-year-old is one of about 11,000 gay people who until two decades ago faced prosecution in Austria but are, since February, now eligible for financial compensation.

Even though Austria decriminalised homosexuality in 1971, certain discriminatory provisions remained in force until the early 2000s.

Woditschka says he will accept the money offered as compensation to him by the Austrian state, which has officially apologised for convicting him of homosexuality in 1999.

But the compensation “won’t erase what happened”, he told AFP, recalling the humiliation he endured as a 19-year-old.

“I was searching for my own identity and all of a sudden I found myself being treated like a sex offender at the police station, forced to describe my sex life in full detail,” said Woditschka.

Woditschka was on a list of acquaintances his former partner, then 16, had to provide to authorities after being arrested for having sex in a car with another man.

After a humiliating court hearing, which forced him to disclose every detail of their relationship and was closely watched by the press, Woditschka was fined for “same-sex fornication with a minor”.

“The whole of Austria suddenly knew that I was gay – when, with whom and how,” he said.

Austrian consultant Michael Woditschka, 44, points to a document sentencing him to pay 350 Euros, in his apartment in Vienna, Austria on March 7, 2024.

Austrian consultant Michael Woditschka, 44, points to a document sentencing him to pay 350 Euros, in his apartment in Vienna, Austria on March 7, 2024. (Photo by Joe Klamar / AFP)

‘Social death’

Under Adolf Hitler’s Nazi rule, Austria as part of the German Third Reich had persecuted homosexuals to death.

Despite the decriminalisation of homosexuality in the early 1970s, thousands of gays and bisexuals continued to be convicted under newly introduced sections of Austria’s penal code.

READ ALSO: Austria to compensate gay people convicted under discriminatory laws

A ban on male homosexual prostitution remained in place until 1989 although heterosexual prostitution was legal.

Until 2002, the age of consent for sexual contact between men was 18 – compared to 14 for heterosexuals.

“Even if you were handed a suspended sentence, you were usually remanded in custody and then everyone knew,” explained Andreas Brunner, 62, an expert on LGBTQ history and co-director of the QWIEN archive centre.

“For many it was a social death,” Brunner said.

Convictions were registered on people’s criminal records, in turn triggering a ban on certain professions.

The ruling conservative party did not amend the legislation, even though it was contrary to European law, Brunner said.

Instead, the party argued, with the support of the Catholic Church, that it was necessary to “protect young men from homosexuals”, he explained.

A decision by the European Court of Human Rights in 2002 obliged the Austrian government to end the years of discrimination.

Since then, Austria’s highest court has ruled on several cases of discrimination against sexual and gender minorities.

In 2019 it allowed same-sex couples to marry and adopt children.

‘Reopening wounds’

When she outlined the compensation programme set up last year, Justice Minister Alma Zadic said it was of “immense importance that we… finally take responsibility for this part of our history”.

In 2017, the German parliament voted to quash the convictions of 50,000 gay men sentenced for homosexuality under a Nazi-era law which remained in force after the war, and to offer compensation.

Earlier this month, French lawmakers approved a bill to compensate LGBTQ people convicted under discriminatory laws between 1942 and 1982.

Austria has now set up a compensation fund of €33 million.

Since February, LGBTQ people who were investigated under the now-repealed laws are eligible to receive €500.

Those who were convicted will have their convictions quashed.

They will be compensated to the tune of €3,000 – or more if they suffered health, economic or professional woes as a result.

Woditschka said he welcomes the initiative but it was “insufficient”.

“Some people have lost everything,” he said.

He said he would have appreciated it more if the authorities had “written to us directly” instead of asking those affected “to provide evidence ourselves” first.

“Many people will say that it’s not worth reopening the wounds” for what is considered to be just a tiny amount of money, he said.

By Blaise GAUQUELIN

Url copied to clipboard!