SHARE
COPY LINK

HEALTH

Italy had more than 11,000 unexplained ‘excess deaths’ in March

Italy recorded almost 50 percent more fatalities in March than usual, according to new official data showing that the real coronavirus death toll could be far higher than the 29,000 reported.

Italy had more than 11,000 unexplained 'excess deaths' in March
A funeral in Piedmont, north-west Italy, in April 2020. Photo: Marco Bertorello/AFP

The new data suggest that the death toll could be nearly double the official figure.

Italy's civil protection services attributed 12,428 fatalities to the virus by the end of March. But the state statistics agency Istat and the ISS public health institute said that another nearly 11,700 extra deaths needed to be accounted for in that span.

READ ALSO: What's the problem with Italy's official coronavirus numbers?

The number was derived by comparing Italy's total number of deaths between late February and the end of March to the statistical average for that period in the preceding five years.

From the day the first death from the new coronavirus was reported on February 20th until March 31st, the number of deaths across Italy rose from an average of 65,592 over 2015-19 to 90,946 in 2020, figures released on Monday showed.

Italy's official figures mostly count hospital deaths. Few of the elderly in care homes have been tested, and the number of deaths from the virus in the community is unknown.

The new data showed that 25,354 more people died across the country in those 40 days than the average for the same period between 2015 and 2019, an increase of 49.4 percent.

Over the 37 worst-affected provinces in the north and centre of Italy, deaths from all causes more than doubled compared to the 2015-2019 average.

In the hardest-hit province of Bergamo, there were more than six times as many deaths compared to the same period in previous years, with an increase of 568 percent. In Cremona deaths rose by 391 percent, in Lodi by 371 percent, in Brescia by 291 percent, in Piacenza by 264 percent and in Parma by 208 percent.

MAPS: Which parts of Italy have the fewest coronavirus cases?


Doctors visit a suspected Covid-19 patient in Bergamo, Lombardy. Photo: Piero Cruciatti/AFP

The data showed that 13,691, or 54 percent, of the 25,354 extra fatalities nationwide “are Covid-19 diagnosed deaths” included in Italy's official virus toll. That leaves 11,663 so-called excess deaths unexplained.

The most notable rise in mortality was among men aged 70-79, among which group deaths increased by about 2.3 times between February 20th to March 31st compared to the average for that period. Among men aged 80-89, it increased by nearly 2.2 times.

Istat and the ISS said in a joint statement that there were three possible explanations for the additional fatalities. One was that these people were never tested for the virus but actually had it when they passed away.

There is also “an indirect effect of the virus”, in which Covid-19 exacerbates an existing condition, such as kidney or other organ dysfunction, the statement said.

The third cause is the consequence “of an excessive stress on the healthcare system, especially in the more affected areas” of Italy, said the statement.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

BREXIT

‘We are desperate’: Why the UK must help Britons with Italian healthcare charges

A 74-year-old British woman has explained the "frustration and fear" Britons in Italy are facing when trying to access healthcare and appealed to the UK government for help.

'We are desperate': Why the UK must help Britons with Italian healthcare charges

Pat Eggleton, a teacher and writer from the UK, appealed to the UK’s Foreign Secretary David Cameron in the letter sent April 9th about the “desperate” situation faced by UK citizens entitled to free healthcare in Italy – but unable to access it.

British nationals residing in Italy before Brexit, and covered by the Withdrawal Agreement (WA), are in many cases being told by Italian health authorities that they must pay steep new fees at a minimum of 2,000 a year – even though they are exempt from paying at all.

READ ALSO: ‘Life or death situation’: Brits facing high Italian healthcare costs amid rule change uncertainty

In her open letter seen by The Local, Ms. Eggleton, who has lived in Italy since 2005, highlighted that the current minimum is a huge jump from the previous €387, and said that the sum was “difficult, or even impossible, for some to find when there had been no prior notification and there is no option to pay in instalments.”

“A great deal of undeserved worry, frustration and even fear has ensued,” she wrote.

“Some of our group have serious, ongoing health conditions. All we require is for one sentence from the Italian government confirming that Withdrawal Agreement beneficiaries do not have to pay for healthcare access to be circulated to all regional health authorities.

“We implore you to act before this becomes even more serious. As someone put it, “This is a matter not only of money, but of health.” 

Ms Eggleton’s letter came exactly one month after the British government confirmed that all WA agreement beneficiaries are exempt from paying the 2,000 fee, provided they were living in Italy before January 1st 2021.

But there were no details available at the time from the Italian government setting out how the rules would be implemented or communicated to local health authorities around Italy.

Since then, there has been no further information released by the Italian government on any official platform. 

One Withdrawal Agreement beneficiary, Graham Beresford, told The Local last week how he was having trouble accessing healthcare, even though he has a right to it.

Mr. Beresford suffers from blood cancer and needs access to the Italian healthcare system to obtain his medication. 

“Every time I go to my ASL (local health unit) office, I always feel like I’m dismissed,” Graham said. “I told the ASL worker I need medication for my cancer and she replied lots of people come in here with sob stories.

“There genuinely seems to be no compassion whatsoever.”

The Local has written to the Italian health ministry for comment.

SHOW COMMENTS