SHARE
COPY LINK

TRANSPORT

French rail firm accused as high-speed train crash deaths reach court

The deaths of 11 people in a high-speed train accident in 2015 finally came to trial Monday, with French state rail operator SNCF and staff including the train driver in the dock.

French rail firm accused as high-speed train crash deaths reach court
The French national railway company SNCF is in the dock. Photo by Sameer Al-Doumy / AFP

Dozens of SNCF staff and members of their families were on a TGV train that derailed that year, as it took a curve at 265 kilometres per hour – far above the permitted 176kph.

As the final test run on a new high-speed line, the trip on November 14th, 2015 had been intended as a festive occasion.

Instead, the train fell into a canal linking the Marne and Rhine rivers at Eckwersheim, near Strasbourg in eastern France.

Out of 53 people aboard, the crash killed 11 people and left 42 injured, around 20 of them seriously.

The hearings at a Paris court are set to continue until May 16th.

The SNCF company and two subsidiaries face charges of causing death and injury by error, recklessness, negligence or failing to meet safety requirements. They face fines of up to €225,000.

The train driver, an SNCF manager who was giving acceleration and braking instructions, and an engineer face the same charges, risking fines of up to €45,000 and three years in jail.

Judges must decide who bears responsibility for the excessive speed and late braking identified as causes of the crash.

The crash came a day after attacks in Paris claimed by the Islamic State group that left 131 dead. For many of the relatives of the victims the attacks long overshadowed the crash.

“This trial will allow us to get past this tragedy of collective forgetting,” said lawyer Gerard Chemla, representing around 50 of the 89 plaintiffs.

He called on the defendants to show “honesty and courage”.

But the driver’s lawyer Philippe Sarda said his client “was a mere subordinate who had to carry out instructions” from his superiors, calling for his acquittal.

The train’s speed restrictions were disabled for the test trip, and investigators found failings at SNCF and subsidiary Systra, including not foreseeing derailment risks and falling short on staff training.

Systra’s choice to push the train to 330kph on the section of line where the accident happened was “dangerous, unnecessary and against recommendations,” they found.

The company “was not in charge of running” the train, its lawyer Philippe Goussens told AFP, adding Systra “committed no wrongdoing”.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

FRENCH HISTORY

In Pictures: 30 years ago France and the UK opened the Channel Tunnel

Monday May 6th marks the 30th anniversary of the opening of the Channel Tunnel, considered one of the greatest engineering feats of all time. Here are some of the most important moments in its history as well as some iconic pictures.

In Pictures: 30 years ago France and the UK opened the Channel Tunnel

One of the world’s longest undersea tunnels, the Eurotunnel has connected the UK to the rest of Europe for the last thirty years, with over one million freight trucks and nearly 10 million passengers passing through each year, according to Getlink, the company that owns and operates the tunnel.

Marking the 30th anniversary of the opening of the tunnel on Monday, French President Emmanuel Macron said: “Thirty years ago the Channel Tunnel finally linked the United Kingdom and France. This feat brought people closer together, gave new impetus to our trade and confirmed the strength of our political relationship.” 

People first began fantasising about a tunnel under the English Channel as early as 1802, but the dream did not become reality until nearly two centuries later.

A first project was launched in the 1970s, but was soon abandoned. Then in January 1986, Mitterrand and British leader Margaret Thatcher officially signed an agreement to kick-start construction.

A prodigious industrial adventure, the project mobilised 12,000 engineers, technicians and workers to create the world’s longest underwater tunnel over nearly 38 kilometres (24 miles) from northern France to southern England, earning it the “Global Engineering of the Century Award” by the International Federation of Consulting Engineers.

November 27, 1990 – Technicians work on the construction site of the Channel tunnel in Sangatte, northern France. 

(Photo by BORIS HORVAT / AFP)
 
Pictured below is the tunnel boring machine (TBM), at the Sangatta construction site in January 1988.

 (Photo by JEAN MEUNIER / AFP)

Difficult construction

Construction lasted six years, cost some 15 billion euros and saw workers dig three tunnels — one for each direction and one in the middle for service work.

Vehicles can only cross the tunnel on board a rail shuttle, “as it is very difficult to ventilate a tunnel (…) Over a length of 50 kilometres, it’s nearly impossible,” said Michel Levy of the Setec engineering group, who worked on the project.

The huge, 1,000-tonne tunnel boring machines that dug through the ground got off to a slow start on the French side due to difficult terrain and were slowed down by water infiltrations on the British side.

December 1st, 1990 – The two sides finally meet. French engineer Philippe Cozette (R) poses with a piece of chalk, shortly after the historic breakthrough in the Channel Tunnel.

(Photo by CHRISTOPHE BOUCHET / AFP)

Financial Problems

The building of the tunnel was overshadowed for years by financial problems that almost tore apart Eurotunnel, the company contracted to manage and operate it until 2086.

At the end of 1987, before work on the tunnel kicked off, hundreds of thousands of eager, small shareholders bought Eurotunnel shares in the belief that these were solid, safe investments.

But colossal debt, disappointing traffic and quarrels between shareholders and management nearly sank the company over the years.

May 6th, 1994 – French President François Mitterrand welcomes Queen Elizabeth II shortly before the inauguration of the Channel Tunnel, on May 6, 1994, in Coquelles, Pas de Calais.

(Photo by Jacques DEMARTHON / AFP)

French President François Mitterrand and Queen Elizabeth II cut the ribbon during the inauguration ceremony.

 (Photo by GERARD FOUET / AFP)

November 14th, 1994 – The train driver for the first TGV ‘Eurostar’ looks out the window as he prepares for departure from Paris Gare du Nord, on the opening day for services between Paris and the Waterloo International station in London, as well as Brussels-South railway station.

(Photo by PATRICK KOVARIK / AFP)

August 28th, 2009 – A British Queens’ Guard stands near a Eurostar train at the Gare du Nord station in Paris, after a ceremony for the boarding of British David Kemp, the 100.000.000th Eurostar passenger since the opening of the English Channel tunnel in 1994.

Kemp was symbolically decorated by the former SNCF president, Guillaume Pepy, as “Lord of Eurostar” and he received a ticket for unlimited travel for one year on the Eurostar lines.

(Photo by JACQUES DEMARTHON / AFP)

June 5th, 2014 – Britain’s Queen Elizabeth II unveiled a plaque commemorating the 20th anniversary of the Channel Tunnel.

At the time, the tunnel more than 330 million passengers and 65 million vehicles had gone through the tunnel since it opened to the public in 1994.

(Photo by HEATHCLIFF O’MALLEY / POOL / AFP)
 
 
SHOW COMMENTS