SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

POLITICS

How the Spanish far left’s criticism of Israel is creating a dilemma for Sánchez

Repeated criticism of Israel by far-left party Podemos, a member of Spain's government, has created a political dilemma for acting Socialist Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez and complicated his talks to form a new government.

How the Spanish far left's criticism of Israel is creating a dilemma for Sánchez
Pedro Sánchez visiting his country's contingent with the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon in 2022. Photo: AFP PHOTO / MEDIA OFFICE OF THE UNIFIL'S SPANISH CONTINGENT

The head of Podemos, Social Rights Minister Ione Belarra, said Saturday that Israel’s response to Hamas’s attacks on October 7th amounted to “genocide” and called for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to be prosecuted by the International Criminal Court for war crimes.

She has also called on Madrid to cut diplomatic ties with Israel and impose sanctions on the country’s officials.

Israel declared war on Hamas after the Islamist group’s fighters broke through the heavily fortified Gaza border on October 7th, killing over 1,400 people, mostly civilians, and taking about 200 people hostage.

Israel responded with relentless air strikes on Gaza that have killed more than 3,470 people, mainly civilians, according to the Hamas controlled health ministry, and imposed a crippling siege on the Palestinian enclave that has left inhabitants with dwindling supplies of food, water and fuel.

Podemos’s position has strained Spain’s ties with Israel, with the country’s embassy condemning the view as “absolutely immoral” in a statement which Madrid deemed an “unfriendly gesture”.

READ MORE: Israeli Embassy accuses Spanish government of ‘aligning with terrorism’

Sánchez’s Socialists have governed in a coalition with Podemos since 2020, and the two parties have often clashed over foreign policy. Podemos for example opposes sending military aid to Ukraine.

But the row over Israel comes at a delicate time for Sánchez. A national election in July left no party close to an absolute majority and the Socialist premier needs the support of several smaller parties to stay in power.

Among the groups whose backing he will need is Sumar, a new alliance of far-left parties which includes Podemos.

Sánchez has until November 27th to secure a parliamentary majority to govern, otherwise new elections will be triggered for January.

Podemos’s Ione Belarra has called on Spain’s Socialists to break diplomatic ties with Israel. (Photo by OSCAR DEL POZO / AFP)
 

‘Cacophony’

The “cacophony” over Israel is “embarrassing” because it comes at a time when the left needs to “show its unity,” Paloma Román, politics professor at Madrid’s Complutense University, told AFP.

Podemos has been “somewhat sidelined” by Sumar, and it has adopted a hard tone on Israel to “stand out and so we don’t forget that it is different from Sumar,” she added.

Sumar is led by popular Labour Minister Yolanda Díaz, who is close to Sánchez and has adopted a more nuanced tone on Israel.

Sánchez, in office since 2018, has condemned “completely and without any hesitation, the Hamas terrorist attack in Israel”.

READ ALSO: How war in Israel could affect Spain

At the same time he has said “Israel has the right to defend itself but always within the limits of international humanitarian law”.

Foreign Minister José Manuel Albares said Tuesday that there are always “different opinions” in any government, but when it comes to foreign affairs only he and Sánchez speak in the name of Spain.

“The position of the government of Spain at the moment is very clear,” he added before repeating Sánchez’s condemnation of Hamas and support of Israel’s “right to defend itself” within the rules imposed by international law.

But former Podemos leader Pablo Iglesias, one of the founders of the party who remains influential, warned Wednesday that Sánchez must remember that to be reinstated, he must negotiate the main points of his foreign policy with the political forces he depends upon.

READ ALSO: Spain looks to avoid diplomatic spat by ‘working’ with Israel

Member comments

  1. So glad Belarra stood up in solidarity for the Uighurs and the Tibetans while the Chinese herded them into concentration camps, imposed forced labor, and destroyed their sovereignty. Oh wait, you mean she didn’t? Why not? Not trendy?

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

POLITICS

What will Spain’s PM do next after resignation threat?

Sánchez's shock threat of resignation after a dubious corruption probe into his wife has kicked off a period of political uncertainty. What card will the Spanish PM play next according to the experts, or is he truly planning to step down?

What will Spain's PM do next after resignation threat?

Pedro Sánchez, in office since 2018, wrote in a four-page letter posted on social media on Wednesday that he would suspend public duties while he “reflects” on whether he wants to continue leading the government.

The Socialist leader denounced “the seriousness of the attacks” against him and his wife, saying it was part of a campaign of “harassment” waged by the right and far right who “do not accept the election results”.

READ ALSO: Who is Begoña Gómez? Spanish PM’s partner thrust into spotlight

Sánchez, an expert in political survival who has made a career out of taking political gambles, said he would announce his decision on Monday.

Some analysts said he could decide to stay on, with this move aimed at rallying support and regaining the initiative in the face of the right-wing opposition at a time of extreme polarisation in Spanish politics.

“Sánchez is a political animal,” said Oriol Bartomeus, a political scientist at the Autonomous University of Barcelona, adding “he has decided to go on the attack” to try to “change the rules of the debate”.

Paloma Román, a political scientist at Madrid’s Complutense University, said Sánchez had “slammed his fist on the table” as part of a “strategy aimed at putting the spotlight where he wants it”.

Sánchez could file a confidence motion in parliament to show that he and his minority government are still supported by a majority of lawmakers in parliament.

Catalan separatist leader Carles Puigdemont, whose JxCat party is an unpredictable ally of the government, has urged Sánchez to pick this option.

READ ALSO: What happens and who takes over if Spain’s Prime Minister resigns?

For the confidence motion to succeed, Sánchez would just need the backing of a simple majority in the assembly and most of the parties which prop up his minority government have already shown their unconditional support.

Catalan separatist party ERC said it would vote in favour of a confidence motion while hard-left party Podemos, which has clashed with Sánchez in the past, blasted attacks by “the political, media and judicial right” on the prime minister and the left in general.

While the conservative opposition has accused Sánchez of playing the victim to rally support, analysts said the possibility that he will resign cannot be completely ruled out.

“Sánchez’s closest advisers and the leadership of the Socialist party will probably spend the coming days trying to convince him to stay,” said Teneo analyst Antonio Barroso.

“The fact that the prime minister allegedly did not consult any of his advisers when drafting the letter suggests personal reasons might be his main motivation. This makes Sánchez’s decision particularly hard to predict.”

If Sánchez does step down, the Socialist party could propose that parliament appoint someone else as head of the government, with Budget Minister María Jesús Montero, who also serves as deputy prime minister, touted as a likely contender.

But Barroso said it “would probably be hard for Montero to cobble together a majority” in Spain’s highly fractured parliament.

Sánchez could instead resign and call snap elections but he would not be able to do so before May 29 since a year must pass between consecutive dissolutions of parliament.

With the Socialists trailing the main opposition conservative Popular Party in opinion polls, this is a risky strategy, although analysts said Sánchez may bet that leftist voters will be galvanised by the controversy sparked by his resignation.

READ ALSO: Spanish prosecutors question credibility of corruption probe against PM’s wife

SHOW COMMENTS