SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

DANISH CITIZENSHIP

‘I’m doing everything right to get Danish citizenship and it’s not enough’

Malak Ahmad came to Denmark when she was eight, speaks fluent Danish, mainly has Danish friends, and is studying to be a teacher. But at 21, she might still have seven more years to wait before she can become a citizen.

'I'm doing everything right to get Danish citizenship and it's not enough'
Malak Ahmad, a board member for the campaign group Fair Statsborgarskab came to Denmark when she was eight and may not be able to get citizenship until she is 28. Photo: Private

Her father, like her a stateless Palestinian, came to Denmark three years before his wife and children, and that was long enough for him to decide that rather than live in an area with a large immigrant population, his family would be better off among Danes. 

So when she came to Denmark, it was straight to Glesborg, a coastal village with a population of 600 an hour north of Aarhus. 

“The life there and the environment was much better than in a ‘ghetto area’ and the village was welcoming and sweet, so we felt at home,” she remembers. “We were the only ones who weren’t Danes, and that made us feel like Danes, because everything we did was what normal Danish people did. I only made Danish friends and I talked Danish all the time, so my Danish is just like a Dane’s.” 

It was only when she got older that she realised the disadvantages she faced as a stateless person, with nothing but a grey Danish alien passport to use for travel. 

“It’s very frustrating because I’m doing everything right and I’m following the rules. I’m working, I’m in education, I’m helping with my organisation, and still it’s not enough. I still can’t get a Danish passport. I still can’t call myself a Dane.” 

READ ALSO: 

She has permanent residency, so has no problems working or studying in Denmark. 

But to become eligible to apply for citizenship, under the rules she will need to work at least 36 hours a week for four years. This means that as she will be at university training to be a teacher for the next three years, she will probably have to wait seven more years before she can apply. 

“I had to choose between education and work and I chose my future, to get an education and then to work,” she says. 

For her younger sister, the situation is easier. She does not have to work full-time for four years to become eligible, as she arrived in Denmark when she was seven years old, a year ahead of the eight year mark, after which applicants need to meet the full-time work criterion. 

Malak can travel all around the European Union with her Alien passport, visiting relatives in Sweden and Germany, but as soon as she wants to go anywhere else, it is difficult. 

“I can travel to countries, but I have to apply for a visa, and it’s very hard because I have to wait. So if I want to go on a quick vacation, let’s say to England, then I have to apply for a visa and it can take up to three months before I get an answer, so if I just want to go on a weekend trip or a week’s vacation, it’s impossible.” 

If she became a citizen it would change the way she feels about her life in Denmark she says. 

“It will mean that I can vote, that I can actually have an influence on what happens in that country where I live,” she said. “Right now I feel like I have a hole in me, which says: ‘You are not enough. No country wants you and that is why you are stateless.’ If I get Danish citizenship, I will finally have somewhere I can call home.”

Now she’s a student, she has decided to start campaigning on the issue, in March joining the board of Fair Statsborgerskab, the campaign group formed in 2020 to push for changes to Denmark’s strict citizenship laws and fairer application of them.

Her friend, Farid Sahel, who was on the board, convinced her to join and she is now working with social media communication for the organisation. 

For her, the biggest unfair treatment she wants to challenge is the the way all new citizenships awarded each year are sifted through by the Danish Parliament’s Naturalisation Committee, which is chaired by Mikkel Bjørn, an MP for the far-right Danish People’s Party, which has broad powers to grant or deny citizenships . 

“I have heard that as soon as they hear the name Mohammed or Fatima, or any other name that’s not, like from Holland or Sweden. They say no,” she says. “If I could change anything right now, I think it would be to make all those laws the same as, let’s say, America. It should just be a law where you have to fulfil criteria.” 

But the group is also raising the profile of the issue, last week holding a protest outside the Danish Parliament to coincide with Citizenship Day, the day when new Danish citizens are celebrated. 

READ ALSO: Danish-born non-citizens call for change to country’s citizenship rules

Ahmad says that the older she gets, the more conscious she is of the anti-immigrant racism which exists in Denmark. 

“When I was a little girl, I didn’t notice it, because I didn’t get what people were saying or I didn’t see how it was racism. But now I am 21 years old. If people treat me differently from my friends, that is my Danish friends, and we do exactly the same things, then it’s because of racism, because I have a different skin tone and I come from other countries.”

But it doesn’t make her like Denmark any less. 

“Right now, I see Denmark as a great country. I see it as a country where I can be happy and I can live with my family and my Danish best friends and I can work here,” she says. “And if I can be a Dane, then I will see myself as a part of the Danish people.” 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

DANISH CITIZENSHIP

EXPLAINED: Can children of Danes regain citizenship after EU Court verdict?

Children of Danes who have lost their Danish citizenship because they turned 22 without applying to retain it may now get a second chance following an EU ruling, the country's immigration ministry has said.

EXPLAINED: Can children of Danes regain citizenship after EU Court verdict?

According to the ministry, children of Danes who turned 22 on or after November 1st 1993, but failed to apply to have their Danish citizenship made permanent before the deadline of their 22nd birthday, will now be able to apply to have their application reopened in some cases. 

For the case to reopened, the removal of citizenship will have to have “had effects in relation to EU law”.

For this to be the case, the removal of Danish citizenship will, firsly, also generally have to deprive the person of EU citizenship, and as a result impact “a family or employment connection to an EU member state other than Denmark”, which has been established before the age of 22. 

The ministry will also, in all cases where the loss of Danish citizenship at the age of 22 also means a loss of EU citizenship, from now on automatically consider whether the effects in relation to EU law of the loss of EU citizenship are proportional to the reason for removing citizenship (normally the lack of a demonstrated connection to Denmark). 

What is the reason for the change? 

The EU Court of Justice ruled last September that a Danish law allowing citizenship to be revoked from people born abroad to one Danish parent who have never lived in the country, if they reach the age of 22 without applying to retain it, was acceptable.

The case concerned the daughter of a Danish mother and an American father who has held, since her birth in the United States, Danish and American citizenship. After reaching the age of 22, she applied to retain Danish nationality, but the national authorities told her that she had lost it when she turned 22.

The EU court ruled that anyone facing such a decision “must be given the opportunity to lodge, within a reasonable period, an application for the retroactive retention or recovery of the nationality”.

The decision was a development from a previous ruling from 2019, in which the court had ruled that any decisions to remove Danish citizenship should consider the consequences of a loss of EU citizenship as well as of national citizenship, in cases where EU citizenship was dependent on Danish citizenship.  

The ministry, it ruled, must ensure that any loss of EU citizenship was “in accordance with the the fundamental rights laid down in the EU charter of human rights, including the right to privacy and family life”. 

The ministry in 2019, however, interpreted this as only applying in cases where the application to retain citizenship was submitted before the deadline of the person’s 22nd birthday. 

What are the rules around citizenship for Danes born abroad?

When a child has a Danish parent, they are automatically given Danish citizenship at birth, with some exceptions.

They they have until they are 22 to apply to retain their citizenship, with citizenship normally only granted if the child can demonstrate a strong connection to Denmark, by, for instance, residing in Denmark for at least one year before turning 22 or living in another Nordic country for seven years. 

What do you have to do to regain Danish citizenship? 

You need to submit a request the ministry to resume their application, including documents demonstrating that the revocation of Danish citizenship has had an impact in relation to EU law, by, for instance harming the person’s relationships with family or their work in an EU member state other than Denmark.  

The ministry will not consider any ties to another EU country that arose after the applicant’s 22nd birthday.

SHOW COMMENTS