SHARE
COPY LINK

HISTORY

Franco-era torture victim hopes to break Spain’s ‘wall of impunity’

Just months before the death of Spanish dictator Francisco Franco in 1975, Julio Pacheco Yepes says he was arrested and tortured by police for belonging to a left-wing underground movement that opposed the regime.

Franco-era torture victim hopes to break Spain's 'wall of impunity'
Franco's victim Julio Pacheco (R) poses with his wife Rosa Maria Garcia Alcon during an AFP interview in Madrid on September 13, 2023. Photo: PIERRE-PHILIPPE MARCOU/AFP.

Now, nearly five decades on, Pacheco Yepes is set — at a hearing that opens on Friday — to become the first victim of the Franco dictatorship to testify before a Spanish judge investigating allegations of torture.

“It could open a chink in the wall of impunity that we (victims) have hadto suffer for so long,” the 67-year-old told AFP at his home in Vallecas, a working-class district of southeastern Madrid, referring to the people who suffered repression during Franco’s 1939-75 rule.

“It is an important milestone. Keep in mind that this all happened nearly 50 years ago. Until now, nobody, no judge, has accepted a lawsuit or heard testimony in court. This is a first.”

Over the years, around a hundred lawsuits have been filed over alleged torture suffered during the Franco era, but none of them was ever admitted, according to associations representing victims.

Judges have argued that the amnesty law passed in 1977 during Spain’s transition to democracy made it impossible to prosecute crimes committed by political opponents of the regime or those perpetrated by “civil servants and public order agents” such as police.

But many Franco-era victims such as Pacheco Yepes and his wife Rosa Maria Garcia Alcon — who was also arrested in 1975 — argue that torture is a crime against humanity which cannot be covered by an amnesty and the statute of limitations.

‘A pact of silence’

“What was imposed (in Spain) was a pact of silence and it has taken many years” to break it, said Garcia Alcon, 66, who heads La Comuna victims’ association.

In August 1975, Pacheco Yepes and Garcia Alcon — teenagers who were going out together at the time — were both arrested for their involvement in the Revolutionary Anti-Fascist and Patriot Front (FRAP), a left-wing student movement opposed to Franco.

They were taken to the police headquarters in Madrid’s Puerta del Sol Square, which was used as a lockup and torture centre during the dictatorship.

They say various officers tortured them there for days before jailing them for “terrorism”.

In December 1975, a month after Franco’s death, the pair were released on bail. Several months later they were pardoned.

In 2018, Garcia Alcon filed a lawsuit against one of the two police officers she says tortured her but it was not admitted by the courts. She will also take the stand on Friday as a witness in the case brought by her husband.

She says one of the ways the police tortured him was to force him watch them hurting her.

‘Only truth can heal’

Pacheco Yepes filed his lawsuit against four of his alleged torturers in February, just months after Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez’s left-wing
government passed the democratic memory law honouring the victims of violence and persecution under Franco.

The law was opposed by the right, which said it would only re-open the wounds of Spain’s past.

Pacheco Yepes said it was difficult to gather the documentation to support his case, given the “total” unwillingness of public bodies such as the National Archive to “cooperate”.

While he would like to see his alleged torturers “sitting in the dock”, if the judge ultimately decides not to put them on trial, it will still serve as
an important reminder about “what Francoism was”, he says.

This is particularly important at a time when the far-right Vox party is gaining ground and there is “a strong current” of nostalgia about the Franco era, he says.

“The only way to fight this… is by showing how politically backwards (the Franco dictatorship) was,” he told AFP. “The only way to close wounds is with the truth… If you don’t, they will always bleed.”

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

DISCOVER SPAIN

The towns in Spain where it was illegal to die

When cemeteries were filling up in towns around southern Spain a few years ago, some mayors turned to extreme measures to keep their towns alive.

The towns in Spain where it was illegal to die

Ah, the Spaniards. To outsiders they can sometimes appear like chain-smoking, meat loving hedonists for whom a caña or glass of tinto is never out of the question. And yet, they outlive the majority of the world.

In fact, a 2021 study by the University of Washington’s Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation predicted that Spain would surpass Japan to boast the world’s longest life expectancy by 2040. According to Spain’s main stats body (INE), by 2050 Spaniards will be nearing a life expectancy of 90.

It’s hard to fully understand why Spaniards live so long, but scientists generally seem to have come to the consensus that it’s something to do with the combination of their Mediterranean diet (and weather too, no doubt), a good healthcare system, plenty of walking, a close-knit society, and a helpful serving of hedonism — in moderation, of course.

Genetics, a love of sport as well as the lack of serious social issues (in recent decades, anyway) and involvement in wars also likely played a role in making Spaniards live longer. Additionally, over the past decades Spain also managed to drastically reduce the number of deaths due to cardiovascular diseases.

Imagine if they cut down on drinking and smoking — Spaniards could no doubt live even longer. However there were, in the not so distant past, some towns in Spain that took life expectancy to another level and actually made it illegal to die.

READ ALSO: In which parts of Spain do people live longest?

Yes, you read that right: there were towns in Spain where it was made illegal to die.

In 1999 in the Andalusian province of Granada, the mayor of Lanjarón, José Rubio, issued an order banning his 3,870 residents from dying.

The reason? There was no room for anyone else in the cemetery. As you might imagine, this strange decree got a lot of attention, and even made the pages of the New York Times as the news went around the world. However, just a week later, a neighbour broke the rules and died.

The offender was a 91-year-old man (and rather awkwardly, a friend of the mayor) so they were forced to bury him in the already overflowing Lanjarón cemetery. Fortunately, there were no repercussions for the dead man or his family, nor for the rest of the locals who eventually ‘broke’ the ban on dying.

Then a few years later, in July 2002, Manuel Blas Gómez, the mayor in Darro (also in Granada) pulled a similar trick made a public order: “Prohibido morirse” (“It is forbidden to die”). He had only been mayor for a few months, and he took the decision to veto death in this town of 1,500 locals.

The bizarre order was made for similar reasons as in Lanjarón, namely that the town’s cemetery had no more usable land and although local government had found a plot of land to build a new one, the municipal coffers did not have the money needed for the construction works.

But it’s not only in Spain where dying has been outlawed. Both Cugnaux and Sarpourenx in France and Biritiba Mirim in Brazil have done the same in the past for the same reason — because their local cemeteries were full.

READ ALSO: Did you know…? There’s a town in Italy where it’s illegal to die

Since 2012 it’s been illegal to die in the Italian town of Falciano del Massico in Campania, about 30 miles north of Naples.

Mayor Giulio Cesare Fava banned the village’s residents from going “beyond the boundaries of earthly life, and… into the afterlife” after the town’s cemetery reached full capacity.

Again, as in Spain residents were ordered not to die at least until Falciano’s administrators had time to construct a new cemetery that could house their earthly remains.

SHOW COMMENTS