SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

ECONOMY

EXPLAINED: How America’s banking crisis could hit consumers in Germany

The collapse of a number of US banks and the turmoil of Credit Suisse are raising fears of another financial crash. But is it really so similar to 2008 - and do customers in Germany have anything to worry about?

Frankfurt credit suisse
The Credit Suisse building in Frankfurt's banking quarter. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Helmut Fricke

What’s going on?

In recent days, the United States has been gripped by a major crisis in its banking sector. It started with the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank (SBV) – a Californian institution that primarily offered financial services to tech start-ups – which was facing financial difficulties thanks to steep rises in interest rates that cut the value of its investments. 

Much like in the financial crash of 2008, SVB had been investing in mortgage-backed securities that were vulnerable to a sudden rise in interest rates. To make matters worse, most of its customers had deposited more than $250,000 into their accounts – taking them over the threshold for their assets to be protected by the US financial regulation. This made SVB incredibly vulnerable to a potential run on credit – which is exactly what transpired this week. 

As the SVB tried to raise additional capital, word spread of its financial issues, prompting a run on the bank as depositors rushed to withdraw their money. 

“In their actual business, losses would probably not have been so great that the bank would necessarily have had to be led into bankruptcy,” explained Hans-Peter Burghof, an economist at Hohenheim University in Stuttgart. “My impression is that this is more a kind of coordination failure. If the large venture capital investors behind the investors had been coordinated, the bankruptcy could probably have been prevented.”

The ripple effect that followed the collapse €200 billion institution also spread to other banks, including the New York-based Signature Bank, which also went bankrupt this week. Shares in major banks also plummeted in value as panic spread through the sector. As of Thursday, President Joe Biden was still battling to contain the contagion and prevent a fire sale that causes more banks to collapse. 

What does this have to do with Europe?

In the days following the implosion of Silicon Valley Bank in the US, a major player in the European banking sector – Credit Suisse – was also wracked by liquidity issues.

On Tuesday, the Swiss bank admitted to “material weaknesses” in its financial reporting over the past year, which caused investors to fear that the bank would have trouble raising extra capital.

Credit Suisse

A sign of Credit Suisse bank is seen on the branch building in Geneva. Photo: Fabrice COFFRINI / AFP

In order to calm the markets and avoid a Lehman Brothers moment equivalent to events that sparked the financial crash of 2008, the Swiss National Bank has since announced plans to bail out Credit Suisse to the tune of more than €53 billion. 

But there are still fears that the issues with Credit Suisse and other banks could have wider consequences. 

Are we at the start of another financial crash?

Though bailouts of big banks seem reminiscent of the so-called “credit crunch” back in 2008, most economists aren’t currently expecting a repeat of a crisis on that scale. 

However, Andrew Kennigham, chief European economist at Capital Economists, believes the issues with Credit Suisse are a “much bigger problem for the global economy” than the mid-sized American banks that collapsed.

That’s because Credit Suisse has several subsidiaries outside Switzerland and also handles trades for hedge funds. “Credit Suisse is not just a Swiss problem, it’s a global problem,” Kenningham said, but he added that the Swiss bank’s problems were “well known, so they are not a complete shock to investors or policymakers”.

A lot depends on how customers – and, crucially, the markets – respond to news that major institutions like Suisse aren’t quite as financially healthy as they appeared to be.  

READ ALSO: The complete guide to opening a bank account in Germany

Could this affect my money?

That’s not clear at the moment – but it’s worth mentioning that your savings are generally safely stored at any regulated European bank. If you’ve deposited money into an account, you’ll be entitled to compensation for that money in the event that a bank collapses. If the bank can’t pay out the money itself, the compensation claim will be handled by the Federal Financial Supervision Authority (Bafin). 

According to Thomas Schlüter of the Association of German Banks, the state deposit insurance protects the credit balances of current accounts as well as registered savings bonds of up to €100,000 per depositor. In exceptional cases – i.e. if the deposit was related to a specific life event that took place no more than six months ago – banks will insure up to €500,000. This could be the sale of a privately used property, divorce, retirement, or termination of employment.

The skyline of Frankfurt am Main - featuring many international banks.

The skyline of Frankfurt am Main – featuring many international banks. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Boris Roessler

For people who have more money in the bank, there’s also the Deposit Protection Fund run by the German Banking Association and protecting funds of up to €3.268 million per investor. 

As a rule, bank customers don’t need to do anything to receive compensation. The compensation scheme receives the addresses and credit balances from the respective bank and will generally contact customers by themselves. According to Schlüter, the compensation is paid out relatively quickly and most people can expect to receive their money back within a week.

How can I check what’s going on with my bank? 

If you’re concerned about the financial health of your bank, there are a few relatively simple ways to find out more without having to trawl through complex financial statements.

One option is to check their credit rating and keep an eye out for any recent downgrades – which may not be a good sign. It’s also worth making sure your bank is fully covered by financial regulations that protect your money in the event of a crash.

Experts are cautioning customers not to read too much into daily fluctuations in the stock market, however. While seeing your bank’s share price plummet isn’t a particularly nice feeling, it may not reflect the actual stability of your bank.

In fact, Matt Miskin, co-chief investment strategist at John Hancock Investment Management, pointed out on Bloomberg that many traders are simply pricing in the cost of additional regulation when buying shares in banks right now.

READ ALSO: Why 2023 will be a better year to grow your savings in Germany

A customer withdraws cash from a German ATM.

A customer withdraws cash from a German ATM. Photo: picture alliance/dpa/dpa-Zentralbild | Fernando Gutierrez-Juarez

In addition, there are some early signs that the economic landscape could be brightening a little, as the European Central Bank (ECB) revised down its forecasts for inflation this year and next.

Consumer prices are now expected to reach 5.3 percent in 2023 and 2.9 percent in 2024. It had previously forecast 6.3 percent for this year and 3.4 percent for 2024. 

This could be good news as central banks have been hiking interest rates in recent months to try and combat inflation – a situation that has hit the reserves of banks like Silicon Valley. 

“The problem is the same in the US, Europe, but also in other countries,” economist Burghof told NTV on Thursday.

“We simply have a period of increased vulnerability for the financial system as a whole due to the policies of the central banks, which have kept interest rates down for too long and now have to raise them drastically because inflation is getting out of hand.

“That will pass. But as long as this phase lasts, you have to be very, very vigilant that nothing gets out of hand.”

READ ALSO: How to protect your savings against inflation in Germany

Member comments

  1. You said near the beginning of the article: “Much like in the financial crash of 2008, SVB had been investing in mortgage-backed securities”. This is not correct.

    Instead, SVB invested a large portion of their deposits into long term US government bonds. Due to a recent rise in interest rates by the US Federal Reserve to try to tame inflation, those bonds have gone down in value dramatically – and when SVB needed to sell them to increase cash on hand, they lost $1.8b on the sale.

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

POLITICS

Germany’s biggest companies campaign against far right parties ahead of the EU elections

Germany's biggest companies said Tuesday they have formed an alliance to campaign against extremism ahead of key EU Parliament elections, when the far right is projected to make strong gains.

Germany's biggest companies campaign against far right parties ahead of the EU elections

The alliance of 30 companies includes blue-chip groups like BMW, BASF and Deutsche Bank, a well as family-owned businesses and start-ups.

“Exclusion, extremism and populism pose threats to Germany as a business location and to our prosperity,” said the alliance in a statement.

“In their first joint campaign, the companies are calling on their combined 1.7 million employees to take part in the upcoming European elections and engaging in numerous activities to highlight the importance of European unity for prosperity, growth and jobs,” it added.

The unusual action by the industrial giants came as latest opinion polls show the far-right AfD obtaining about 15 percent of the EU vote next month in Germany, tied in second place with the Greens after the conservative CDU-CSU alliance.

A series of recent scandals, including the arrest of a researcher working for an AfD MEP, have sent the party’s popularity sliding since the turn of the year, even though it remains just ahead of Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s Social Democrats.

Already struggling with severe shortages in skilled workers, many German enterprises fear gains by the far right could further erode the attractiveness of Europe’s biggest economy to migrant labour.

READ ALSO: INTERVIEW – Why racism is prompting a skilled worker exodus from eastern Germany

The alliance estimates that fast-ageing Germany currently already has 1.73 million unfilled positions, while an additional 200,000 to 400,000 workers would be necessary annually in coming years.

bmw worker

, chief executive of the Dussmann Group, noted that 68,000 people from over 100 nations work in the family business.

“For many of them, their work with us, for example in cleaning buildings or geriatric care, is their entry into the primary labour market and therefore the key to successful integration. Hate and exclusion have no place here,” he said.

Siemens Energy chief executive Christian Bruch warned that “isolationism, extremism, and xenophobia are poison for German exports and jobs here in Germany – we must therefore not give space to the fearmongers and fall for their supposedly simple solutions”.

The alliance said it is planning a social media campaign to underline the call against extremism and urged other companies to join its initiative.

READ ALSO: A fight for the youth vote – Are German politicians social media savvy enough?

It added that the campaign will continue after the EU elections, with three eastern German states to vote for regional parliaments in September.

In all three — Brandenburg, Thuringia and Saxony — the far-right AfD party is leading surveys.

SHOW COMMENTS