SHARE
COPY LINK

HEALTH

Coronavirus: Switzerland weakens ‘unconstitutional’ shopping ban for over 65s

The southern Swiss canton of Ticino has said it will amend its ban on shopping for seniors, amid criticism it breaches the country's constitution.

Coronavirus: Switzerland weakens ‘unconstitutional’ shopping ban for over 65s
(Illustration) Elderly people in Ticino rely on food delivery services as they are not allowed to shop themselves. Photo: JEAN-FRANCOIS MONIER / AFP

Ticino has some of the most restrictive lockdown rules relating to the coronavirus of anywhere in Europe. 

Seniors in the Italian-speaking canton will now be allowed to shop before 10am in the morning. 

Although other shoppers cannot be banned from visiting shops during this time, the Ticino government has called upon the rest of the population to stay home during this time. 

Why 'crisis resistant' Switzerland is well placed to rebound from the coronavirus pandemic

Previously, anyone over the age of 65 was not allowed to shop due to the coronavirus lockdown, with anyone caught doing so punishable with a CHF100 fine. 

Besides leading to calls that the ban was discriminatory, there were reports of seniors travelling north to the canton of Uri in order to go shopping, leading to concerns that the virus could be spread more easily across the country.

Unconstitutional? 

As reported in the Neue Zürcher Zeitung, a group of Swiss constitutional lawyers have said that not only would the fines be unlikely to be upheld in court, but that the ban itself breached the Swiss Constitution. 

The Swiss Constitution bans age-based discrimination. 

The Federal Office of Justice told the NZZ that coronavirus lockdown restrictions are likely to be unconstitutional when they apply to one specific group, i.e. persons over a particular age. 

“Additional regulations of the cantons, such as a general or specific ban on going out or a ban on shopping for people over 65, are therefore not permitted.”

Ticino heavily affected by corona

As at Tuesday, April 14th, Switzerland has recorded more than 1,140 deaths from the virus and has a total infected count of 25,719 people. 

Ticino has been heavily impacted by the outbreak, counting more than 2,900 cases. 

The number of deaths in the canton crossed 200 on Wednesday, with the tally now at 258.  

This means that Ticino has just under one quarter of the country's total death toll, despite having just four percent of the population. 

 

 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

HEALTH INSURANCE

Could glasses and contact lenses soon be covered by Swiss health insurance?

The Swiss health system is ranked among the best in the world, but some essentials, like glasses, aren't automatically covered by health insurance. That could soon change, however

Could glasses and contact lenses soon be covered by Swiss health insurance?

Green Party Federal Councillor Katharina Prelicz-Huber revealed in an interview with newspaper 20 Minuten this week that the Federal Parliament had tabled a motion to include prescription glasses and contact lenses in Switzerland’s mandatory health insurance scheme. 

Prelicz-Huber stated: “The purpose of compulsory health insurance is to provide the services you need to get or stay healthy,”

The motion forms part of the legislation that will be voted on during the 2024 summer session of the Federal Council. 

Proposed changes 

According to Switzerland’s peak optician body, 4 in 5 Swiss wear glasses or contact lenses at some point. 

It’s no surprise that statistics repository, Statista, projects the Swiss eyewear industry to be worth €1.37 billion by 2028. 

Currently, glasses and contact lenses are covered for up to 180 francs for children until age eighteen, if they are proscribed by a doctor.

Adults can also claim money back for glasses and contact lenses – however, they must be suffering from one of a short list of specific conditions such as keratoconus – where the cornea is distorted – or severe myopia, otherwise known as near-sightedness.

They must also have been specifically prescribed them by a doctor or optometrist. 

Otherwise, supplemental optical insurance must be purchased in Switzerland to ensure you can recoup the cost. 

Under the Green Party proposal, glasses, contact lenses, and other visual aids would be covered, regardless of age. 

Rising premiums prompt opposition 

Not everybody agrees with the proposal. 

The right-wing SVP has already spoken out against it, with Federal Councillor Diana Gutjahr arguing: “If we seriously want to slow down the burdensome and constantly rising health costs for the benefit of the population, we [must] show the political will not to constantly expand the benefits of compulsory health insurance.”

A spokesman for the the health insurance advocacy group Santesuisse, Matthias Müller, echoed Gutjahr, claiming that insurance constitutes “financing for extraordinary events such as illness.”

“If almost everyone benefits from a certain service, it is no longer an insurance benefit.”

A date for the vote has yet to be announced. 

SHOW COMMENTS