SHARE
COPY LINK

CRIME

Frenchwoman ‘insane’ when she stabbed Perth man

An Australian judge on Tuesday ruled a young Frenchwoman not guilty of the bizarre stabbing murder of an elderly man in his Perth home, finding she was insane at the time of the killing.

Valentina Marie Strabach, 22, pleaded not guilty to stabbing Murray Vernon Quartermaine more than 200 times with a pair of scissors in his home in Western Australia state in January 2011 due to her unsound mind.

“I conclude that… the accused was insane at the time of the killing of Mr Quartermaine and is not criminally responsible for her actions,” Supreme Court of Western Australia Commissioner Kevin Sleight said in his judgement.

Under questioning by police, Strabach, who had arrived in Australia only weeks before the killing, said she felt compelled to commit the murder because she held the delusional belief Quartermaine was a paedophile.

She said she met 79-year-old when she was lost, and he offered to give her a lift to where she was staying. She then asked to go to his home because she wanted to see if he was a child sex offender.

Once there, Strabach found a pair of scissors that she used to stab him repeatedly, leaving him with chest wounds, and perforating his lungs, bowel, liver and jugular.

She also amputated his genitalia and both his big toes.

Sleight said he was satisfied Strabach was suffering from a mental illness in the form of paranoid schizophrenia at the time of the murder, and she was influenced by hallucinations ordering her to kill him.

“It must be stressed that there was absolutely no basis for the accused concluding that Mr Quartermaine was a paedophile,” Sleight said.

“However, in her psychotic state the accused had developed a delusional obsession about paedophilia.”

The court was told that Strabach, reportedly a dual Australian-French citizen, had previously sought medical help in France and was prescribed strong medication, but stopped taking it as she was unable to function properly.

She will be detained at a mental health hospital in Perth until she is released by an order of the Western Australian governor.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

POLITICS

France to set up national prosecutor’s office for combatting organised crime

The French Minister of Justice wants to create a national prosecutor's office dedicated to fighting organised crime and plans to offer reduced sentences for "repentant" drug traffickers.

France to set up national prosecutor's office for combatting organised crime

Speaking to French Sunday newspaper Tribune Dimanche, Eric Dupond-Moretti said he also intends to offer “repentant” drug traffickers a change of identify.

This new public prosecutor’s office – PNACO – “will strengthen our judicial arsenal to better fight against crime at the high end of the spectrum,” Dupond-Moretti explained.

Former head of the national anti-terrorism prosecutor’s office Jean-François Ricard, appointed a few days ago as special advisor to the minister, will be responsible for consultations to shape the reform, the details of which will be presented in October, Dupond-Moretti said.

Inspired by the pentiti (repent) law in force in Italy, which is used to fight mafia crime, Dupond-Moretti also announced that he would create a “genuine statute” that rewards repentance.

“Legislation [in France] already exists in this area, but it is far too restrictive and therefore not very effective,” Dupond-Moretti explained.

In future, a judge will be able to grant special status to a repentant criminal who has “collaborated with justice” and “made sincere, complete and decisive statements to dismantle criminal networks”.

The sentence incurred by the person concerned would be reduced and, for their protection, they would be offered, “an official and definitive change of civil status”, a “totally new” measure, the minister said.

The Minister of Justice is also proposing that, in future, special assize courts, composed solely of professional magistrates, be entrusted not only with organised drug trafficking, as is already the case today, but also with settling scores between traffickers.

This will avoid pressure and threats on the citizen jurors who have to judge these killings, he said.

Finally, the minister plans to create a crime of “organised criminal association” in the French penal code. This will be punishable by 20 years of imprisonment.

Currently, those who import “cocaine from Colombia” risk half that sentence for “criminal association”, he said.

SHOW COMMENTS