SHARE
COPY LINK

FOOD AND DRINK

Top French court upholds ‘veggie burger’ label

France's top administrative court on Wednesday waded back into a battle over the labelling of veggie burgers, suspending a decree banning plant-based products from being described as meat.

Top French court upholds 'veggie burger' label
In this photo illustration, two meatless patties cook in a skillet, June 13, 2019 in New York, New York. (Photo by Drew Angerer / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / AFP)

The French government in February issued a decree to ban the term “steak” on the label of vegetarian products from May 1, saying it was reserved for meat alone.

A veggie burger is called a veggie “steak” in French.

The decree listed 21 terms usually used by butchers — including “escalope”, “ham”, “filet” and “prime rib” — that it said were not allowed for plant-based products.

The ruling was a response to a long-standing complaint by the meat industry that terms like “vegetarian ham” or “vegan sausage” were confusing for consumers.

It was based on a 2020 law before the nation’s top administrative court — called the State Council — suspended application of the decree in 2022 after a complaint from French companies selling plant-based food.

The State Council on Wednesday suspended a second decree to implement the same labelling law, saying there existed “a serious doubt over the legality of such a ban”.

It would remain suspended until the Court of Justice of the European Union responded to a query over whether the measure was legal under EU law, it said.

In 2020, the European Parliament rejected a move to ban the use of terms of animal origin for plant products — except when words like “yoghurt”, “cream” or “cheese” are applied to products without animal milk.

France issued its second decree as farmers protested against environmental rules and competition from cheap imports.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

ENVIRONMENT

Why Bordeaux wine is under threat in France this year

Winemakers in the famous French Bordeaux wine region fear the weather conditions this spring may lead to a disastrous harvest.

Why Bordeaux wine is under threat in France this year

It’s the second year in a row that mildew has threatened Bordeaux vines. Around 90 percent of vineyards were affected by mildew to some extent in 2023, according to the regional chamber of agriculture.

But this year, the fungus has appeared earlier than usual. “If the weather continues, it’s going to be a disaster,” one vineyard owner told regional newspaper Sud Ouest, as mildew threatens crops. “I’ve never seen mildew strike so early.”

In its latest plant bulletin, the Gironde Chamber of Agriculture underlines the “favourable climatic conditions for [mildew] development” and is pessimistic for the coming days, fearing an increase in potential risk.

In the end, the 2023 harvest was reasonable, helped by favourable August weather – though a heatwave towards the end of the month raised concerns over working conditions.

READ MORE: France to revise its Champagne-making area due to climate change

But last year’s outbreak and the weather so far in 2024 has brought the ‘mildew season’ forward in parts of the region. The Grand Libournais and Graves winegrowing areas are particularly affected, according to May’s Bulletin de Santé du Végétal for Nouvelle Aquitaine.

Winegrowers in the Blayais region, meanwhile, have noticed that mildew spread is erratic – but the expected return of rainy conditions in the early part of next week have prompted concerns that the fungus’s spread will only increase.

“There are abandoned plots, neighbours who haven’t pruned their vines or estates that have been unable to carry out an uprooting program because of the incessant rain,” one vineyard owner said.

Official figures suggest that some 2,000 hectares of vines are uncultivated in the Gironde alone. The Fédération Départementale des Syndicats d’Exploitants Agricoles insists that the real figure is much larger – with implications for the health of neighbouring cultivated vines.

SHOW COMMENTS