SHARE
COPY LINK

CRIME

Spanish church’s audit finds fewer cases of abuse than commission

Spain's Catholic Church said Thursday that an audit it had ordered into child sexual abuse by priests had found significantly fewer cases than an independent commission appointed by parliament.

Spanish church's audit finds fewer cases of abuse than commission
A priest prays during a mass in Guadalajara in Castilla La Mancha in 2020. Photo: JAVIER SORIANO/AFP.

At least 2,056 minors were victims of sexual abuse, according to an audit based on lawsuits filed against members of the clergy. It was however “obvious that the number is higher”, said the Spanish Episcopal Conference, which groups Spain’s leading bishops. The audit was prepared by the law firm Cremades & Calvo-Sotelo.

The figures from the audit are far lower than those cited in the independent commission published in October. It found that more than 200,000 were estimated to have been sexually abused in Spain by the Roman Catholic clergy since 1940.

That report did not however give a specific figure.

Instead, it extrapolated from a poll of over 8,000 people, which found that 0.6 percent of Spain’s adult population of around 39 million people had said they had suffered sexual abuse by members of the clergy during childhood.

That percentage rose to 1.13 percent — or more 400,000 people — when the questions included abuse by lay members.

Cardinal Juan Jose Omella, head of the Spanish Episcopal Conference, cast doubt at the time on the “dubious reliability” of those figures. He said the Church was aware of 1,125 cases of sexual abuse.

In February 2022, the Church tasked private law firm Cremades & Calvo-Sotelo with the audit — the first time that it had ordered an investigation into the issue. The brief covered past and present sexual abuse by clergy, teachers and others.

But one victim’s association dismissed the church audit as a “smokescreen”.

The Church has said it will publish the full audit, which it received on Saturday at a later date. But it said Thursday that the audit listed a total of 1,383 complaints
without saying how many members of the clergy had allegedly committed sexual crimes.

The victims were mainly men, and the sexual violence was committed mainly in schools and seminaries by priests or teachers, it added.

Unlike in other nations including France, Ireland and the United States, clerical abuse allegations are only now gaining traction in Spain.

A traditionally Catholic country, it has become increasingly secular.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

CRIME

Spanish court shelves Shakira tax fraud case

A court in Spain said Thursday it has shelved a probe into another alleged tax fraud by Colombian pop star Shakira, putting an end to her legal woes in the country where she once lived.

Spanish court shelves Shakira tax fraud case

Prosecutors had opened the case in July, accusing her of using a network of companies, some of them based in tax havens, to cheat the tax office out of €6.6 million ($7.09 million) in 2018, including interest and adjustments. A month later, the so-called Queen of Latin Pop paid €6.6 million to settle the debt.

But on Wednesday prosecutors recommended that the probe be dropped due to “insufficient evidence” and the court investigating the case agreed.

While the court said the “Hips Don’t Lie” singer had committed “irregularities” in her 2018 tax return, it added that “irregularities are not enough to constitute a (criminal) offence against the tax authorities”.

It added that Shakira did not have “the intent to defraud the tax authorities”.

In a separate case, Shakira in November struck a last-minute settlement with prosecutors on the opening day of her trial over a separate tax fraud charge involving income she earned between 2012 and 2014.

In that case prosecutors had sought a jail sentence of over eight years for the singer. They accused her of defrauding the tax authorities of €14.5 million in a case that centred on how much time she was living in Spain.

Shakira denied the charges, saying she only moved to Spain full time in 2015.

By the time the case came to trial, she had already paid €17.45 million to settle her outstanding tax debt, prosecutors said at the time.

‘Emotional toll’

On the day it opened, that trial — which had been due to run for three weeks and hear from some 120 witnesses — was quickly concluded after she agreed to pay a fine of nearly 7.8 million euros.

At the time she explained she had settled “with the best interest of my kids at heart” because she needed “to move past the stress and emotional toll of the last several years” and focus on her career.

Shakira, 47, now lives in Miami with her two sons after splitting from Barcelona star defender Gerard Pique.

He was himself convicted of tax fraud in 2016 and ordered to pay €2.1 million in fines and arrears. Spain’s Supreme Court in 2021 annulled his conviction.

Last year, Shakira’s superstar Argentine producer Bizarrap won the Latin Grammy for song of the year with a track taking a swipe at Pique — who has since retired from football — in which she accuses him of leaving her with a “debt to the tax office”.

“People on my team tried to convince me to change the lyrics, but I’m not a UN diplomat. I am an artist and, above all, a woman,” Shakira told Spanish celebrity magazine ¡Hola!

Spain has in recent years cracked down on celebrities, including football stars such as Argentina’s Lionel Messi and Portugal’s Cristiano Ronaldo, for unpaid taxes.

Both players were found guilty of evasion and received prison sentences that were waived for first-time offenders.

SHOW COMMENTS