SHARE
COPY LINK

SEX WORK

Prostitution around Europe: Which country has it right?

As France looks set to introduce steep fines of up to €1,500 for those caught buying sex The Local looks at the law around prostitution in other countries around Europe. Which one has it right when it comes to how to deal with what is often described as "the world's oldest profession".

Prostitution around Europe: Which country has it right?
Students play the roles of prostitutes at a protest in German city of Hanover to draw attention to the fact that many must work as prostitutes to fund their studies. Photo: Nigel Treblin/AFP

French lawmakers are to debate a prostitution law on Friday that would penalize clients instead of sex workers.

Here is the situation in other European Union countries:

Punishing clients:

  • SWEDEN

Sweden pioneered the punishment of those who pay for sex in 1999, with six-month prison terms and a fine based on the client's income. It remains to be seen whether the law can be enforced owing to a rise in use of the Internet to procure sex.

  • NORWAY 

Norway followed Sweden's example in 2009. A six-month prison term can be raised to one year if the nature of the sex act is "particularly degrading". Sex workers initially faded from view in Oslo but are gradually returning.

  • ICELAND                      

Those who pay for sex can go to prison for a year if the sex worker is an adult, or for two years if the prostitute is a minor. No prison terms have been handed down so far by courts in those three countries.

  • BRITAIN

Pimping and soliciting are both illegal. Clients of prostitutes forced into sex work are prosecuted, even if the client was unaware of any coercion. But prostitution is not a violation if the sex worker is self-employed, owns the site where sex takes place and does not create a public nuisance.

  • SLOVAKIA

Seeking sex from a prostitute is punished by up to 10 years in prison, but prostitution itself is not forbidden and "massage parlours" are tolerated.

  • SPAIN

Barcelona levies fines of up to 3,000 euros ($4,050) for clients, and from €300-750 euros for prostitutes working on the street. Madrid has proposed fines of €750-3,000 for clients. Prostitution itself is tolerated in Spain, and La Junquera, a town on the border with France, has an active sex industry.

Organizing prostition:

  • DENMARK

Prostitution was legalized in 1999. Sex workers must declare their earnings and pay taxes. In 2012, experts concluded that adopting the Swedish model would probably not lead to a decline in prostitution.

  • GERMANY

Prostitution has been regulated since 2002. Voluntary sex workers can be either independent or salaried and get unemployment insurance and medical coverage. Brothels exist but it is illegal to pimp someone out against their will.

  •  NETHERLANDS

Voluntary prostitution by adults was legalized in 2000, along with pimping of willing workers. Sex workers in established brothels receive salaries and have work contracts, social protection, unemployment insurance and pensions.

  • SWITZERLAND

Prostitution is allowed unless it is forced. Sex workers must be at least  16. In August, Zurich launched a sex "drive-in", a new addition to the sector.

  • GREECE

Prostitution is authorised in registered, regulated brothels.

  • BELGIUM

Sex workers can register as independent workers and brothels are authorised in some cities. A special 'Eros Centre' with bedrooms, parking for clients, and an on-site medical centre and police station is planned for 2016 near Liege.

 Other European countries:

Some forbid prostitution but do not punish clients, as in Finland and Romania.

Others tolerate it but prosecute pimping and solicitation, such as in Estonia, Italy, Poland and Portugal.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

BROTHEL

Mandatory contact tracing in Zurich brothels stirs controversy

A lawyer for the Zurich sex industry is taking legal action against new tracing rules being implemented for prostitutes working in the Swiss canton.

Mandatory contact tracing in Zurich brothels stirs controversy
A prostitute walks by 'sex boxes' which Zurich set for their safety. Photo by AFP

Starting on October 1st, Zurich has mandated stricter protection rules in the brothels.

Sex workers must now not only collect their customers’ ID and contact details, but also check on the spot whether the cell phone numbers provided by the clients are correct.

But Valentin Landmann, a legal counsel for Zurich’s sex work industry, filed an appeal against the new regulations, claiming they “violate the principle of equality”.

“These conditions are more extreme than in any other profession involving physical contact”, he told SRF television in an interview.

Landmann added that stricter measures are not necessary in the sex trade.

“The normal protection concepts are already being observed. So far, there have been no coronavirus cases in legal companies”.

However, Zurich authorities see it differently.

The cantonal director of security Mario Fehr told SRF that the new measures are necessary to ensure effective contact tracing, so that clients can be informed in case a coronavirus infection occurs in the brothel.

He added that if establishments fail to adhere to the requirements “we will close these businesses”.

READ MORE: Five things about Switzerland that may surprise foreign residents 

Prostitution is legal in Switzerland and considered as a ‘regular’ service industry, with the same rights and obligations as other sectors, including declaring income and paying taxes.

In May, the brothels implemented safety rules for workers and clients to reduce the risk of Covid-19 infections. 

The measures include ventilation in rooms, the use of gloves, condoms and disinfectants, and washing of sheets after each client. 

Also, sessions should be kept to a maximum of 15 minutes, and kissing – which was already rare before the measures came into place – is strongly discouraged.
 

SHOW COMMENTS