SHARE
COPY LINK

IMMIGRATION

Refugees found clinging to coach in Bavaria shines light on German asylum policies

A couple of stowaways were caught riding under a bus after one fell onto the Autobahn in Bavaria. The story highlights how difficult the immigration journey, and legal process can be for immigrants hoping to seek asylum in Germany.

the motorway at dawn
A woman driving behind a bus was able to brake in time to avoid hitting a stowaway that fell onto the A99 motorway. Photo by Fabian Kleiser on Unsplash

Germany has seen a massive influx of refugees in recent years, due primarily to Russia’s war of aggression in Ukraine but also continued conflicts in parts of West Asia and Eastern Europe. 

A recent story has highlighted the often dangerous routes and lengths that asylum seekers go to in their bid to come to Germany, as the government has tightened policies on asylum seekers.

On Sunday, two refugees hid under a bus travelling through Bavaria and were only discovered after one of them fell onto the A99 motorway in the district of Ebersberg (east of Munich).

A woman driving behind the bus was able to brake quick enough to avoid hitting the man.

Alerted by the driver behind, the bus stopped shortly afterwards at Vaterstetten where a second man then emerged from under the bus.

The police reported on Sunday that the men involved were only slightly injured from the incident. Both men were taken to hospital. 

The two men are 26-year-old asylum seekers from Morocco. 

It was unclear how long they had ridden under the bus or how exactly they managed to do so. But authorities suggested they must have positioned themselves near the exhaust system, because they were covered in soot. 

How many asylum seekers come to Germany?

The story has shone a light on the often perilous situations asylum seekers coming to Germany find themselves in.

According to Germany’s statistical office (Destatis), at the end of 2022 more than 3 million people were registered as seeking asylum in the country – more than a million more than in 2021.

Of those, more than one million were Ukrainians. Additionally, the number of other foreign nationals seeking asylum amounted to more than two million for the first time.

The number of asylum seekers who are granted benefits, however, is substantially less. At the end of 2021, roughly 399,000 people in Germany received standard benefits in accordance with the Act on Benefits for Asylum Seekers (AsylbLG), according to Destatis. 

For migrants coming from northern Africa, the route to Europe involves crossing the Mediterranean Sea, which is known to be among the deadliest border crossings in the world.

When these migrants succeed in landing in a European country they are legally required to apply for asylum at their point of entry. But asylum applications are known to take a long time, and come with requirements that some migrants are unable to prove.

Many people decide to head to their destination country without registering. 

According to Bavarian government figures, in the first quarter of 2024 police detected more than 600 unauthorised entries or re-entries (people crossing the border illegally) at Bavaria’s state borders.

Immigration has become a heated political topic in Germany

According to the largest annual study on people’s perception of democracy (conducted by Alliance of Democracies), Germany has the highest proportion of voters who think focusing on reducing immigration should be politicians top priority, at 44 percent.

In response to these concerns, German leaders have initiated policy changes that appear to some like a reversal of the country’s previous willingness to accept asylum seekers.

One recent measure, passed by the Bundestag in April, will end cash benefits for asylum seekers in Germany and instead transfer these benefits to a card-based system. Lawmakers say the move is intended to prevent refugees from sending money out of the country, but critics contend that it will further disenfranchise people who are already in precarious situations.

READ ALSO: Why asylum seekers in Germany will soon have limited access to cash

In an interview with Der Spiegel in October 2023, Germany’s Chancellor Olaf Scholz said that the federal government is working hard to limit “irregular migration”. He cited a number of measures including stricter border controls. 

That interview, which was printed with the headline “We have to deport people more often and faster”, came as a shock to advocates of asylum protections. It appeared to some that Scholz had reversed his position, perhaps in response to polls that suggested right-wing parties’ tough immigration policies were winning votes.

A foundational part of the traffic-light coalition government’s plan included a streamlining of Germany’s immigration process. Scholz had called Germany “an immigration country” while speaking about plans to overhaul the citizenship application process.

While Germany’s well-known lack of skilled workers has compelled leaders to streamline the immigration process for some, the country’s willing acceptance of refugee immigrants which was championed by former Chancellor Angela Merkel since 2015, seems to be running out.

READ ALSO: The Syrian refugee who became mayor of a German village

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

GERMAN CITIZENSHIP

The changes to Germany’s immigration and citizenship rules in June 2024

With sweeping reforms to immigration and citizenship laws coming into force in June, we round up key points you need to know about.

The changes to Germany's immigration and citizenship rules in June 2024

Immigration law changes – Opportunity Card arrives

2024 is a major year for immigration law changes in Germany. 

In November 2023, the government brought in the first phase of its new skilled worker law, with lower salary thresholds for Blue Card applicants and more flexibility for skilled workers to work in a range of professions.

In March 2024, Germany brought in more big changes to immigration rules, including quicker routes to permanent residence, amendments to make it easier for healthcare workers from outside the EU to move to Germany and relaxed family reunification rules. This was a controversial move because the new family rules only apply to workers coming to Germany after March and not those already here. 

READ ALSO: INTERVIEW – ‘Germany’s family reunion rules should be non-discriminatory’

In June 2024, another big change is coming. Germany is launching the ‘opportunity card’ visa, known as the Chancenkarte. 

This is a ‘jobseekers’ visa’ allowing eligible skilled workers from outside the EU to move to Germany for up to a year to look for a job. They are also able to work up to 20 hours a week while they do so. 

READ ALSO: How Germany’s opportunity card will allow easier entries for foreign workers from June

The general idea is that people must have completed at least two years of vocational training, or have a university degree from their country of origin relevant to the vocation, as well as language skills in German or English. 

Applicants whose qualifications aren’t officially recognised in Germany can still apply for the opportunity card if they achieve at least six points, which are granted for things like language skills, connections to Germany, professional experience and age. 

Potential applicants can find out more information and apply for the Opportunity Card at the German Consulate in their origin country, or at an immigration office (Ausländerbehörde) in Germany.

Those interested can also do a quick check to see if they qualify on this website.

A flight near Frankfurt airport.

A flight near Frankfurt airport. People looking to come to Germany can apply for the Chancenkarte. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Boris Roessler

Extension of West Balkans regulation

Another big change in June applies to the so-called West Balkans regulation. Under a clause that was meant to expire in 2023, people from the West Balkan countries of Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Kosovo, Montenegro, North Macedonia, and Serbia are able to enter the German job market in any non-regulated profession.

In June, this will be extended indefinitely, with a quota of 50,000 employment visas per year.

Germany’s new citizenship law comes into force – June 27th

The modernisation of German citizenship law enters into force on June 27th – a moment foreign residents in Germany have been waiting years for.

Here are the key points you need to know at a glance:

Required residency period reduced

The amount of time you need to have lived in Germany to apply for the standard route to naturalisation in Germany will be reduced from eight years to five years under the law change.

In case of special integration achievements and proof of fluent German (C1 level), applicants can choose the fast-track option to German citizenship which will require just three years of legal residence in Germany. The fast-track option is currently six years and requires B2 level German skills.

READ ALSO: Requirements, costs and permits – 6 essential articles for German citizenship

Language skills and citizenship tests

Having B1 level German remains the requirement for citizenship through the standard route. As previously mentioned, a level of C1 German will be needed for the fast-track route.

Another change under the new law is that applicants who came to former West Germany from the so-called ‘guest worker generation’ and contract workers who came to former East Germany will not have to take a language test to naturalise as German. The same is true for certain hardship cases, such as having a disability or age. 

READ ALSO: How good does your German have to be for the different paths to citizenship?

For those affected, no specific language requirement exists – but applicants must be able to communicate sufficiently with their case workers, unaided by a translator.

In general, doing a German citizenship test will still be required under the new rules — but certain people in the carve-out situations mentioned above are exempt from taking it. 

READ ALSO: How can over-60s get German citizenship under the new dual nationality law?

A German dictionary. Shelley has learned a new language in her time in Germany.

A German dictionary. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Oliver Berg

Dual citizenship allowed for all 

A headline change under the reforms is that people won’t have to give up their passport to become German. Dual or multiple nationalities will be allowed for all. Previously, only EU nationals were allowed to hold more than one citizenship when becoming German, or under certain exceptions. 

However, it’s worth noting that the rules of people’s origin country will need to be taken into account. For instance, if your home country does not allow people to hold dual nationalities, you may need to give up your passport. One example of this is Indian law, which does not allow for dual or multiple citizenships. 

Similarly, German citizens who live abroad won’t have to give up their German nationality if they want to naturalise in the country they live in — provided their new home allows it. 

Financial requirements 

The principle from the current law remains — anyone who wants to naturalise in German must be able to support themselves.

However, there are no clear rules on how much money someone needs to have or earn. This is assessed on a case-by-case basis and depends on several factors – for example – if you have dependents such as children or a spouse.

Having to rely too much on the welfare state will be an obstacle to getting citizenship, although it depends on the type of benefit and people’s individual situation. 

READ ALSO: How much do you need to earn to qualify for German citizenship?

SHOW COMMENTS