SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

POLITICS IN SWEDEN

Why did Sweden’s Greens launch their doomed no-confidence vote?

Sweden's environment minister, Romina Pourmokhtari, emerged unscathed from last week's failed no-confidence vote. The Local asked politics professor Nicholas Aylott what the Green Party were thinking.

Why did Sweden's Greens launch their doomed no-confidence vote?
The green party's new spokesperson Daniel Helldén speaks in parliament during last week's no-confidence vote in environment minister Romina Pourmokhtari. Photo: Christine Olsson/TT

When Pourmokhtari, at 28 Sweden’s youngest-ever minister, released her long-awaiting climate plan in December, the Green Party and the Centre Party’s announcement that they would table a no-confidence vote quickly stole the headlines. 

But when the vote actually happened last week, it fell almost embarrassingly short of the parliamentary majority required, only managing to muster a meagre fifth of MPs. 

Rather than weaken her, Pourmokhtari argued the process had shown what strong backing she had.  

“I feel much stronger after this vote,” she said after the vote. “I now know that we have a clear mandate in the chamber for the climate policy we have put in place.” 

One commentator even said that the vote had increased her chances of becoming the Liberal Party’s next leader. 

As the Social Democrats opted not to back the motion, Sweden’s left-wing opposition, on the other hand, ended up looking weak and disunited. 

So what were the three parties who backed the vote hoping to achieve? 

“It was a political gesture designed to press on what is coming to be regarded by some as one of the current government’s weakest fronts, and that is its environmental policy,” Nicholas Aylott, associate professor in politics at Södertörn University, told The Local, in the Sweden in Focus podcast

The climate plan announced just before Christmas had, Aylott said, been criticised by PM Nilsson, the head of the right-wing Timbro thinktank, as well as in the leader pages of the right-wing Svenska Dagbladet newspaper. 

The idea behind launching a no-confidence vote, he argued, was to highlight weakness of the government’s environmental policy.

The Green Party’s new leader Daniel Helldén published an article in Expressen on the eve of the vote, in which he accused Pourmokhtari of being repeatedly dishonest and of breaking Sweden’s Climate Law. 

Aylott argued the vote had been an opportunity for Helldén to boost his profile.   

“I think the attractions of raising this issue up the political agenda by moving this vote of no confidence in parliament, were fairly obvious for the Greens and the Left Party, particularly for the Greens, who have a new leader who wants to enhance his profile,” he said.

“He’s not so well known among many voters and he will obviously see any opportunity to get himself in the headlines and news bulletins as an attractive one.” 

Aylott argued it was unclear the extent to which the gesture had backfired. 

“Whether the vote… can be regarded as a successful move, despite its inevitable defeat, is now open to question, I think, mainly because the Social Democrats opted to abstain,” he said.

“I think this must have been a bit of a disappointment for the Left and the Greens and the Centre Party. I think the effect that it’s had – as several commentators have already pointed out – is that it simply underlines the disunity of the left.” 

“You could say that [the no-confidence] vote in parliament simply underlined the difficulties of rallying all four of these opposition parties behind a common position, even on something that should be one of their strong points and the opposition’s weak points, which is environmental policy.” 

Listen to the episode of The Local’s Sweden in Focus podcast here:

Or you can listen on these platforms:

Alternatively, you can search for Sweden in Focus wherever you listen to podcasts. 

Politics in Sweden is a weekly column looking at the big talking points and issues in Swedish politics. Members of The Local Sweden can sign up to receive an email alert when the column is published. Just click on this “newsletters” option or visit the menu bar.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

POLITICS

Over a thousand people join protest against Stockholm attack

Over a thousand people joined a demonstration in Gubbängen, southern Stockholm, on Saturday, protesting Wednesday's attack by far-right extremists on a lecture organised by the Left and Green parties.

Over a thousand people join protest against Stockholm attack

The demonstration, which was organised by the Left Party and the Green Party together with Expo, an anti-extremist magazine, was held outside the Moment theatre, where masked assailants attacked a lecture organised by the two parties on Wednesday. 

In the attack, the assailants – described as Nazis by Expo – let off smoke grenades and assaulted several people, three of whom were hospitalised. 

“Let’s say it how it is: this was a terror attack and that is something we can never accept,” said Amanda Lind, who is expected to be voted in as the joint leader of the Green Party on Sunday. 

She said that those who had attended the lecture had hoped to swap ideas about how to combat racism. 

“Instead they had to experience smoke bombs, assault and were forced to think ‘have they got weapons’?. The goal of this attack was to use violence to generate fear and silence people,” she said.  

EXPLAINED: What we know about the attack on a Swedish anti-fascist meeting

More than a thousand people gathered to protest the attack on a theatre in Gubbängen, Stockholm. Photo: Oscar Olsson/TT

Nooshi Dadgostar, leader of the Left Party, said that that society needed to stand up against this type of extreme-right violence. 

“We’re here today to show that which should be obvious: we will not give up, we will stand up for ourselves, and we shall never be silenced by racist violence,” said said.

Sofia Zwahlen, one of the protesters at the demonstration, told the DN newspaper that it felt positive that so many had turned up to show their opposition to the attacks. 

“It feels extremely good that there’s been this reaction, that we are coming together. I’m always a little worried about going to this sort of demonstration. But this feels safe.”

SHOW COMMENTS