SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

WORKING IN SWITZERLAND

Why Switzerland can’t rely on foreign workers to fill its labour shortages

Switzerland has long depended on workers from European countries to fill the vacancies in its labour market. But this could change within the next few years.

Why Switzerland can't rely on foreign workers to fill its labour shortages
EU workers may be discouraged from coming to Switzerland in the future. Photo: Pixabay

For more than two decades, Switzerland has relied on people from the European Union and European Free Trade Association (EFTA) countries to cover its need for qualified skilled workers.

Currently, about 1.7 million workers from EU / EFTA (Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein and Switzerland) states are employed in Switzerland.

“Over the past 20 years, immigration from the EU has been essential to meet labour demand,” according to the State Secretariat for Economic Affairs (SECO).

In the future too, “further growth of the working-age population will continue to depend on immigration, even more so than currently,” SECO said. “The number of people leaving the employment market to retire tends to be higher than the number of incoming workers,” — a phenomenon which will further widen the deficit on the Swiss labour market, and where EU employees will be particularly needed.

READ ALSO: How EU immigrant workers have become ‘essential’ for Switzerland

However, it doesn’t look likely that the country can continue to rely on the foreign workforce indefinitely.

Why is this?

Demographic forecasts for Switzerland show that, by 2029, there will be a shortfall of 28,400 people in the labour market — a significant number in a small country like Switzerland.

In years past, workers from EU /EFTA countries were hired to fill this gap.

However, the demographic gap — that is, shortages created by retiring workers — is even greater in most European countries, according to economist Manuel Buchmann.  

“EU nations themselves need this skilled workforce and are willing to do a lot to ensure that their nationals don’t leave the country,”he said.  

“This is why it will become increasingly more difficult to bring people from the European Union to Switzerland,” he added. “This will inevitably impact Switzerland’s economy, which will probably shrink because of a shortage of workers.”

How will Switzerland compensate for this loss of foreign workforce?

One of the solutions Buchmann suggests is to encourage employees to work longer — that is, beyond their statuary retirement age of 65 for men and 64 for women (the retirement age for the latter will be raised gradually to 65 starting in 2025).

Another suggestion is to recruit more workforce from outside the EU / EFTA.

That may not be feasible, however.

That’s because Switzerland’s justice minister Elisabeth Baume-Schneider has asked the Federal Council to reduce the permit quotas the government makes available for people from third countries each year.

READ ALSO: Will Switzerland cut number of work permits for third country nationals?

In 2022 and 2023, the government issued 12,000 permits for people from outside the EU / EFTA, but Baume-Schneider is calling to have this quota lowered to 9,600 permits in 2024.

The Federal Council will decide in the next few weeks whether it wants to act on Baume-Schneider’s proposal and tighten the screws on the third-country immigration and if so, when.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

JOBS

Which professions in Switzerland are harder for foreigners to break into?

In many sectors of Switzerland’s economy, Swiss employees prevail over foreign ones — and vice-versa.

Which professions in Switzerland are harder for foreigners to break into?

In the past, the ‘division of labour’ in Switzerland was clear: foreign nationals held mostly manual (and therefore lower-paid) jobs, while the Swiss worked in managerial / executive and other middle and high positions.

Many sectors still follow these traditional roles, with some jobs held almost exclusively by Swiss citizens, and others by foreign nationals.

Which jobs are mostly held by the Swiss?

To find this out, the Basel-based consultancy firm, Demografik, surveyed professions with more than 10,000 employees.

It found that “about 60 percent of the country’s masons and flooring installers are foreign-born,” Neue Zürcher Zeitung (NZZ), reported.

The comparable figure among the country’s unskilled workers as a whole is even higher —  84 percent.

“Swiss nationals also make up only a third of kitchen assistants and cleaning staffers” — jobs typically held by immigrants with no higher education or vocational training.

On the other hand, Swiss citizens hold a number of jobs that are almost unattainable for unskilled foreign nationals, including police officers, teachers, lawyers, senior administrative staff, and social workers.

Only a small percentage of immigrants work in these professions.

However, they dominate fields such as service staff, chauffeurs, unskilled industrial workers, and construction — jobs where very few Swiss can be found.

Why is this?

“The proportion of foreign workers is highest in jobs that are generally considered unappealing – whether because of the low pay, high level of physical demands or irregular working hours,” said Demografik economist Lisa Triolo.

“Nevertheless, these professions are important for the functioning of the economy, because they are difficult to automate.”

Triolo also found that foreigners mainly work in areas where recruiting employees has been difficult.

“The longer the vacancy period in an occupational group, the higher the proportion of foreigners,” she pointed out.  “For example, construction is the sector in which companies take the longest to fill an open position.”

Is this survey objective?

It is, if you focus primarily on unskilled foreign workers, who basically take on jobs that the Swiss don’t want.

The picture is different, however, if you include skilled professionals into the mix.

Many of them hold the same positions, and earn equal or even higher wages, than their Swiss counterparts.

READ ALSO: In which jobs in Switzerland do foreign workers earn more than the Swiss? 

SHOW COMMENTS