SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

HOUSING

EXPLAINED: What is Switzerland’s referendum on affordable housing all about?

One of two questions to be put to Swiss voters on February 9th asks whether the law should be changed to provide for more affordable housing across Switzerland. Here’s what you need to know.

EXPLAINED: What is Switzerland’s referendum on affordable housing all about?
Photo: NICHOLAS RATZENBOECK / AFP

Cost of living concerns are front and centre for many of our readers. Central to these concerns is housing affordability. 

READ MORE: Everything you need to know about the cost of living in Switzerland

Renting is common in Switzerland, with approximately three in five (60 percent) of households renting across the country. But whether renting or buying, simply having somewhere to live is getting more and more expensive in Switzerland – particularly in urban areas. 

Out of these concerns has risen a campaign to provide for more affordable housing, which has culminated in a referendum question on the issue on February 9th. 

The other question to be asked on February 9th is whether homophobia should be criminalised in Switzerland. 

EXPLAINED: The Swiss referendum that could criminalise homophobia 

But what is the referendum on affordable housing actually proposing? Will it make a difference to the cost of renting and buying? And will it do so all across the country? 

Here’s everything you need to know about the questions being asked. 

The affordable housing initiative

After being launched in 2015, the initiative got more than 100,000 signatures in order to push it to a vote. 

There are several pillars of the initiative, but the core component is that a minimum of 10 percent of all new housing built across the country should be owned by housing collectives or social housing bodies. 

What is social housing? Social housing, otherwise known as housing collectives, run housing projects on a non-profit basis. 

By doing so, housing has been shown to be between 15 and 25 percent cheaper than housing provided by property companies on a for-profit basis. 

The initiatives are to be put in place in all municipalities and cantons across the country. 

As part of the initiative, when the government or government entities sell off land, preference must be given to cantons for the land to be used for affordable housing. 

READ: EU migration to affordable housing: All you need to know about Switzerland's crucial spring referendums 

Furthermore, government grants made for building new infrastructure can only be awarded where they do not result in existing affordable housing being lost. 

Apartments in Geneva. Photo: Fabrice Coffrini/AFP

What are the parties saying – and what is the likely outcome?

The public’s opinion of the referendum appears to have shifted over time.

While members of the public were initially in favour of the new initiative by a relatively wide margin – with 60 percent indicating they would support the change in mid-January – polls have since indicated a slim majority for the opposing side. 

In a poll released on January 29th, 51 percent of Swiss voters said they opposed the affordable housing initiative – with 48 percent in favour. 

Advocates of the plan – including the Social Democrats and the Greens – have argued that it will bring down the cost of new and existing housing by reducing the pressures in the market while also removing the role played by property speculators. 

Current social housing makes up approximately five percent of the market. 

They also argue that forcing the government and government entities (such as railways or energy companies) to consider social housing when selling off land will further encourage a growth in social housing. 

Opponents argue that the 10 percent limit is too high and is therefore unachievable. They argue that investors will be spooked and too much additional bureaucracy will be created. 

The Swiss government also opposes the initiative, launching a counter proposal which would make an extra CHF250 million ($US258M) available for loans to housing cooperatives over the next decade. 

Pursuant to Swiss law, if the voters vote no on the initiative, this counter proposal will come into effect. 

 

p.p1 {margin: 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px; font: 12.0px Helvetica}
p.p2 {margin: 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px; font: 12.0px Helvetica; min-height: 14.0px}
p.p3 {margin: 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px; line-height: 14.0px; font: 12.0px Times; color: #0000e9; -webkit-text-stroke: #0000e9}
p.p4 {margin: 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px; line-height: 14.0px; font: 12.0px Times; color: #0000e9}
span.s1 {text-decoration: underline ; font-kerning: none}
span.s2 {text-decoration: underline ; font-kerning: none; -webkit-text-stroke: 0px #000000}

 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

HOUSING

‘Housing is a human right’: Rent activists step up pressure ahead of German elections

Housing campaigners from across Germany have banded together ahead of the September elections to demand an immediate rent freeze and affordable housing for all.

'Housing is a human right': Rent activists step up pressure ahead of German elections
People protesting for Deutsche Wohnen & Co. enteignen at a demo in Berlin on August 21st. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Christoph Soede

In a demonstration taking place in the German capital on September 11th, 2021, numerous campaign groups will take to the streets, among them the Berlin-based Expropriate Deutsche Wohnen & Co. campaign, the national Rent Freeze campaign and the Mannheim-based Action Alliance Against Desperation and Rent Madness. 

They are demanding a national rent freeze for the next six years to halt rising rents, along with a focus on building more affordable homes and the transfer of property from private landlords into state hands.

“With this rents demonstration, we’re protesting against the massive, persistent pressure that renters are facing in the whole of Germany,” campaigners said in a statement announcing the upcoming protest.

“Whether it’s Frankfurt, Dresden, Munich, Leipzig, Berlin, Hamburg or Cologne, rents are incessantly rising or have already reached unreasonable levels – und not just in the big cities.

“In many places, the availability of affordable living space has sunk dramatically for those entering a new housing contract. Homelessness is rising further and with it, the number of people who live on the streets without any shelter at all.” 

Sharp rise in rents

Of all the cities in Germany, Berlin has by far the fastest rising rents: a recent study by housing portal Immowelt found that asking rents in the capital have soared by more than 40 percent over the past five years alone.

READ ALSO: COMPARE: The cities in Germany with the fastest-rising rents

However, the same study also found that middle-sized German cities like Heidelberg and Kaiserslautern were experiencing significant rent hikes over the same period, while the country’s priciest cities like Munich and Stuttgart continued to see rents go up – though not quite as steeply as in previous years.


Not just Berlin: Medium-sized cities such as Heidelberg have seen steep rises in rents over the past half a decade. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Uwe Anspach

As Germany prepares to head to the polls on September 26th in both the federal and a number of state elections, the campaign is aiming to step up pressure on the next government to embark on a “radical change of course” in the country’s housing policy. 

READ ALSO: Election 2021: How do Germany’s political parties want to tackle rising rents?

In Berlin, people with German citizenship will also be given a vote in a referendum on whether the state government should buy out thousands of flats owned by for-profit landlords with 3,000 or more properties – including Vonovia and Deutsche Wohnen – in order to better control rents and living standards.

“On September 26th, Berliners have a unique, historical chance to stand up against the selling off of our cities,” Rouzbeh Tehari, spokesman for the Expropriate Deutsche Wohnen & Co. campaign, told The Local.

“The referendum to nationalise large property firms offers the opportunity to remove hundreds of thousands of apartments from capitalist speculation and manage them as social housing.”

READ ALSO: Berlin to vote on radical bid to combat housing crisis

Even if the referendum passes, however, the campaign expects to face a fierce battle with the newly elected Berlin Senate to see the policy put into law. 

“We won’t stop after the vote,” Tehari explained. “We know we’re facing strong opposition and it will be difficult to get it implemented.” 


A ‘yes’ poster for the referendum being put up in Berlin. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Christophe Gateau

Either way, the success of the campaign – which managed to collect well over the 170,000 petition signatures needed to call a referendum – will have sent a strong message to the venture capitalists that speculating on Berlin housing is a “high risk” strategy, he said.  

A national rent cap?

The national Rent Freeze campaign, one of the key activist groups involved in Saturday’s demo, is calling for a new six-year rental cap – but says it must be done on a national level.

Earlier this year, attempts to impose a six-year rent freeze in Munich and Berlin were both rejected by Germany’s Constitutional Court on the basis that such as move couldn’t be done on a state or regional level.

In the case of Berlin, the rent cap had been in place since 2018, but was removed after the court found the law to be unconstitutional.

A tweet from the ‘Prevent Forced Evictions’ campaign ahead of the demo on Saturday reads: “According to a new study, a national rent cap is possible. The only thing missing is the political will.” 

At the time, renters were dealt a double blow as the court ruled that landlords also had the right to reclaim back-dated rent for the entire duration of the cap – leading some tenants to be presented with bills amounting to thousands of euros. 

READ ALSO: 

But the national Rent Freeze campaign, which started in Bavaria, has now amassed support from around 140 other organisations and activist groups, and is gaining momentum ahead of the elections.

“Many tenants are desperate,” said Matthias Weinzierl of the Rent Freeze campaign. “They’re legitimately afraid of losing their homes because rents continue to rise and Covid-19 hasn’t changed a thing. 

“That’s why we’re calling for a national six-year rent freeze now, which must be brought in directly after the new government has been elected. Such a rent freeze would be an acute help for tenants – and it’s also urgently needed.” 

‘Existential threat’

The date of the demo is the national Day of the Homeless, and was selected to highlight what campaigners see as the real threat of the housing crisis.

“In many places, high rents are becoming a genuine poverty risk and loss of housing is becoming an existential threat,” said Ulrich Schneider, CEO of the Parity Welfare Association, which is also supporting the demo.


People sleeping rough in Berlin in February 2021. Campaigners believe the housing crisis and homelessness are closely linked. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Kay Nietfeld

“It’s completely unreasonable to force single parents, people with disabilities or those in need of care, for example, to give up their homes and lose their entire social environment.” 

The protest on Saturday has also received support from the National Working Group for Help for the Homeless (BAGWH), who have linked unaffordable rents to a rise in the number of employed people losing their homes. 

In one recent study, BAGWH found that 15 percent of people classified as ‘homeless’ are currently employed – suggesting that rents in Germany are now outstripping wages, especially for lower earners.

Commenting on the findings, Werena Rosenke, CEO of BAGWH, said that the figures were “proof of the precarious living conditions in which many people find themselves in this country and the trends that are emerging in our society”. 

Any new government elected after September 26th must face this issue head on, she added. 

SHOW COMMENTS