SHARE
COPY LINK

TRIAL

Spanish police give their version of Catalan referendum violence

Spanish security officials have defended their handling of a banned independence referendum in Catalonia, saying police had no choice but to use the kind of force captured in violent mages were flashed around the world in 2017.

Spanish police give their version of Catalan referendum violence
Police drag a man across the ground outside a polling station on the day of the illegal referendum. Photo: AFP

Taking the stand as witnesses at Spain's Supreme Court in Madrid, those responsible for the police operation that prevented some from voting in the October 1st, 2017 referendum gave their version of events in public for the first time.

Footage beamed around the world showed police dragging voters from polling stations by their hair, throwing people down stairs and striking them with batons, sparking shock and complaints from human rights groups.

ANALYSIS: Why the Catalan Republic is a big fat lie

A court order had instructed Catalonia's regional police, the Mossos d'Esquadra, to work with Spain's national police to stop the plebiscite, which was ruled illegal by Spain's Constitutional Court.

But security officials charged that the Mossos did not comply as their leaders sided with Catalonia's separatist government, leaving it to national police to seize ballot papers and boxes, leading to clashes in roughly 30 polling stations.

'Surreal' situation


Clashes outside a polling station in Sant Julia de Ramis,, on October 1st 2017. Photo: AFP

Diego Perez de los Cobos, a colonel at Spain's Civil Guard police force in charge of police operations that day, said the leadership of the Mossos went against the court order and set about facilitating the vote “rather than preventing it.”

He said that on “10 or 11” occasions, the Mossos “tried to physically obstruct the actions of our own forces”.

During security meetings ahead of the vote, Mossos head Josep Lluis Trapero sided “completely” with Catalonia's regional government which called the referendum, Spain's former secretary of state for security, Jose Antonio Nieto, told the court.

“The situation was surreal. We were sitting around a table to stop the referendum with those who organised it,” said Nieto, who was then the second-highest ranking official at Spain's interior ministry.

“Fairy trap”

Trapero faces a separate trial for rebellion.

Nine of the 12 Catalan separatist leaders on trial in the Supreme Court have also been charged with rebellion for their role in staging the referendum and a short-lived independence declaration that followed.

Public prosecutors are calling for them to be sentenced to up to 25 years in jail.

Catalan separatists argue their majority in the regional Catalan parliament gave them a democratic mandate to pursue independence.   

But prosecutors accuse the separatist leaders of violating the law and using crowds to block police on referendum day.   

National police who went to polling stations were met in some cases with “human walls” of people who were sometimes violent, Enric Millo, who was Madrid's representative in Catalonia during the 2017 crisis, told the court on Tuesday.

Police responded “proportionally”, he said.

ABOVE: Footage sent to the Local Spain of police action at a polling station.

Probe into police violence

While the world saw images of police striking would-be voters with their batons, they did not see images of injured officers, Millo added.   

According to the Spanish government, close to 100 police were hurt, none hospitalised.

Millo however said some officers suffered broken fingers or fractured legs.   

Some were hit with metal barriers or cobblestones, he added.   

Others fell in the “Fairy trap”, said Millo, in reference to a brand of dishwashing liquid which he said was spilled in the entrance of polling stations, causing officers to slip, fall before people hit their heads.

Nieto said police ended up pulling back as the security of people and agents was “at serious risk.”

Catalonia's separatist government says seven people were seriously injured that day, including one man who lost an eye due to a rubber bullet fired by police.

Under questioning from the defence, Nieto acknowledged that “dozens” of officers were under investigation for police violence during the referendum.   

Establishing whether or not separatists used violence is key to proving the charge of rebellion, which under Spanish law is defined as “rising up violently and publicly”.

The separatist leaders have always denied exercising any form of violence, insisting on the pacific nature of the independence movement.

By AFP's Diego Urdaneta 

READ ALSO: Catalan separarists' trial: What you need to know

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

REFERENDUM

Swiss decision to purchase US fighter jets could force second referendum

Switzerland's decision to purchase US-made fighter jets could be put to a referendum,

Swiss decision to purchase US fighter jets could force second referendum
Swiss fighter jets. Photo: JOE KLAMAR / AFP

Switzerland’s government on Wednesday backed the purchase of 36 F-35A fighter jets from Lockheed Martin to replace its fleet and five Patriot air defence units from fellow US manufacturer Raytheon.

Switzerland’s current air defence equipment will reach the end of its service life in 2030 and has been undergoing a long and hotly-contested search for replacements.

“The Federal Council is confident that these two systems are the most suitable for protecting the Swiss population from air threats in the future,” the government said in a statement.

‘No Trump fighter jets’: Swiss don’t want to buy American planes

The decision will now be put to the Swiss parliament — and also risks being challenged at the ballot box, with left-wingers and an anti-militarist group looking to garner enough signatures to trigger a public vote.

The F-35A was chosen ahead of the Airbus Eurofighter; the F/A-18 Super Hornet by Boeing; and French firm Dassault’s Rafale.

For the ground-based air defence (GBAD) system, Patriot was selected ahead of SAMP/T by France’s Eurosam.

“An evaluation has revealed that these two systems offer the highest overall benefit at the lowest overall cost,” the government statement said. Switzerland is famously neutral. However, its long-standing position is one of armed neutrality and the landlocked European country has mandatory conscription for men.

“A fleet of 36 aircraft would be large enough to cover Switzerland’s airspace protection needs over the longer term in a prolonged situation of heightened tensions,” the government said.

“The air force must be able to ensure that Swiss airspace cannot be used by foreign parties in a military conflict.” 

Long path to decision 

Switzerland began to seek replacements for its ageing fleet of fighter jets more than a decade ago, but the issue has become caught up in a political battle in the wealthy Alpine nation.

The Swiss government has long argued for the need to quickly replace its 30 or so F/A-18 Hornets, which will reach the end of their lifespan in 2030, and the F-5 Tigers, which have been in service for four decades and are not equipped for night flights.

In 2014, the country looked set to purchase 22 Gripen E fighter jets from Swedish group Saab, only to see the public vote against releasing the funds needed to go forward with the multi-billion-dollar deal.

Bern launched a new selection process four years later, and a referendum last year to release six billion Swiss francs ($6.5 billion) for the purchase of the fighters of the government’s choice squeezed through with 50.1 percent of voters in favour.

During the referendum campaign, the government warned that without a swift replacement for its fleet, “Switzerland will no longer be in a position to protect and even less defend its airspace by 2030”.

Currently, the fleet does not have the capacity to support ground troops for reconnaissance missions or to intervene against ground targets.

Meanwhile Switzerland’s current GBAD system is also old and lacks the capacity to meet the widening spectrum of modern threats.

The military currently relies on a range of Rapier and Stinger short-range missiles that have been in service since 1963.

SHOW COMMENTS