Read news from:
Austria
SHARE
COPY LINK

COUNTRYSIDE

Where in France would you rather live, the city or countryside?

It’s not a 50-50 split for our readers, but even those voting for the winning side warn that not everything about their choice offers la vie en rose.

Published: 23 October 2018 09:22 CEST
Where in France would you rather live, the city or countryside?
Photo: AFP

Living in France is a dream for so many people around the globe that one could argue it’s become a bit of a cliché. 

That’s not to say such life goals are unfounded because France truly does offer quality of life, culture, natural beauty and a certain je ne sais quoi that are unparalleled.

There’s the sophistication of its café culture, museum-filled villes and the tranquillity and beau-vivre of la campagne. Which to choose? Which offers the most?

This of course is down to personal preference but 65 percent of our readers chose the French countryside over life in a French city (35 percent) in our recent poll.

Foreigners in l’Héxagone seem to have a similar appreciation for rural France as French people themselves, who in a recent Ifop poll voted overwhelmingly (81 percent) in favour of life in the countryside, which they associate with a higher quality of life, calm, nature and less pollution.

Similar compliments – “peaceful”, “friendly”, “charming” – were used by our English-speaking readers to describe la campagne.

However, a number of those who wrote in pointed out that there is such a thing as ‘too peaceful’.

“By countryside I meant a rural village,” argued Siobhan McCarthy.

“I like peace and quiet but our house is in a small village with a Bar Tabac and a boulangerie. Would have no interest in being isolated”.

*The 65-35 split in favour of countryside living in France is based on the average between different polls we conducted on both Facebook and Twitter, the latter's results seen above. In total, we received over 500 votes. 

Twitter user Adian 翻譯加載 shared a similar view: “countryside, but not the middle of nowhere, and still near a city. You guys have great cheap trains as well for easy commuting (when they're not on strike, that is.)”.

Aydin_Adam tweeted: “Everything shutting down at 7 PM would take some getting used to”.

So it may seem idyllic at first but sometimes the convenience of having amenities and a comprehensive transport network in urban areas are too important to let go of.

“It's a question of balancing pluses and minuses and except for some specific occupations it may be easier all around to live in a city,” argues André Blanbecque.

“Working or not though (ie retired), it all depends on what services you want or need to access and which you can do without on a regular basis. Some services in a city versus next to none in a rural environment”.

So what about the 35 percent of The Local’s respondents who said they’d always prefer life in the big city?

Anastasia Widiarsih speaks of “the convenience of being able to get around easily using public transport” but loves vacationing in the countryside.

George Miu adds that “culture is more accessible in a town situation and that “the countryside is for those that long to separate themselves from all and have a quiet experience – usually those that come from big cities”.

Maybe it is a case of the grass being greener on the other side for urban idealists.

In fact, that same Ifop survey found that 60 percent of young French people would prefer to live in la France profonde (deep France), compared to 45 percent of the rest of the population.

On the same note however, the French countryside was found to be synonymous with social and economic problems, 60 percent of respondents associating it with “poverty” and “unemployment”.

FIND OUT MORE: The trials and tribulations of moving to rural France 

So is it fair to say that moving to the countryside is only an option if you’re willing to sacrifice all work prospects, amenities and public transport options?

According to John Wands “if one looks carefully, it is not impossible to find a small town with good amenities. My wife and I live in Nere, about 16 miles from St. Jean de Angely. It has a small grocery, a butcher, a fine bakery, two hairdressers, one barber, two bars (one run by an Englishman), a dentist, and a walk-in clinic. Also a market once a week. Not a bad place!”

A number of other readers seem to concur that it’s all about finding a place that offers the best of both worlds, not slap bang in a city but not in no man’s land either.

“I voted ‘a city in France’ but I actually live 5 km outside of Aix-en-Provence (in the ‘country side’). So it’s a double win!,” wrote Angeline Eveleens.

Carole Mitchell also said: “Love the peace and quiet and the friendly community spirit in my village, the city is 30 minutes away so best of both worlds in my opinion”.

CHECK OUT: The 10 must-visit French villages you've never heard of

And Ellen Manuel explained how “our small town in the country is quiet, peaceful, friendly, and charming. It's an hour drive into Grenoble to purchase larger things, but for everyday groceries we have a grocery store, and Amazon Prime to deliver things instead of driving into the city.”

So it may just be that the secret to a happy life in France is neither in the city nor in the countryside, but rather in a village that’s a stone’s throw away from a bigger and well-serviced town.

As Edith Piaf would sing, “c'est ça la vie en rose!”. 

SEE ALSO: Why the French dream of living in rural France (but are unlikely to make the move) 


 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

HOUSING

Are Germans really fleeing the cities for an idyllic life in the countryside?

With cultural life in the major cities mothballed for over a year, ever more Germans seem to be deciding that they'd prefer a quite life in the countryside. But where are they moving to and which cities have seen the biggest impact?

Published: 26 March 2021 16:50 CET
Are Germans really fleeing the cities for an idyllic life in the countryside?
Döringstadt, a village in Bavaria. Photo: dpa | Nicolas Armer

For 200 years the trend has been going in one direction only – into the cities. 

While in 1800 just five percent of people in what is now Germany lived in cities, by 2019 that proportion had jumped to 77 percent.

The reasons are pretty obvious. The jobs were in the city, while industrialisation of farming made manual labour in the countryside less necessary.

But the coronavirus pandemic has changed the equation. Suddenly employers have been forced to make use of technologies and infrastructure that have already been there for a while, but which they were reluctant to adopt.

Good Wifi connections and video conferencing have allowed workers to move into home office in an almost seamless fashion.

READ ALSO: What you need to know about Germany’s new working from home rules

With home office now proven to function for businesses, more people could be tempted to live away from the major cities all of which have been dealing with housing crises and soaring rents for at least a decade.

A survey the Local reported on in February showed that almost 30 percent of young professionals would consider moving to the countryside if they could stay in home office once the pandemic is over.

Stagnating cities

The statistics for 2020 show that at least for the pandemic year, the surge in the population sizes of major German cities was put on hold.

Berlin recorded a drop in its population for the first time since 2003 in the first half of 2020, although growth in the second half of the year meant that the population grew by about 400 people.

Some of this stagnation was caused by foreigners escaping back to their homelands. Some 1,700 Americans along returned to the USA.

But 11,000 Germans also left the capital last year.

SEE ALSO: ‘Life here is worth living’ – meet Germany’s countryside influencers

The population of Hamburg, which has been growing by between 10,000 and 20,000 a year for the past decade, also flatlined throughout most of 2020 before bouncing back in the last two months of the year.

It was a similar story in Munich. After years in which more people moved to the city than left it, that trend was reversed last year.

“This is an unusual development for Munich,” city authorities commented. “If you look at the migration balance of the past 10 years, its always been a plus of 10,000 or more – even if this trend has flattened out a little in recent years.

Berlin’s normally busy Alexanderplatz shopping district has been shut down for months. Photo: dpa | Annette Riedl

‘The process is accelerating’

Matthias Günther, an economist at the Eduard Pestel Institute in Hanover, is convinced that the pandemic and resultant move to home office have added fuel to a trend that had already slowly begun.

“Now it is accelerating,” he told the RedaktionsNetzwerk Deutschland. “There are various places that are suddenly seeing a demand that we didn’t have before.”

According to Günther, properties that have sat empty for decades are suddenly being sold.

“Many people can now imagine working three days a week from home and only travelling to the workplace on the other two days,” he says. That type of commute is overall less than a daily schlepp from an outlying district into the city centre.

Flight to the Speckgürtel

The observation that the inner cities are becoming less popular is one that estate agent Engel & Völkers has made too. 

But their research on 2020 has led them to conclude that the real boom is actually taking place in suburban areas outside cities rather than in remote rural settings.

Engel & Völkers performed a market market analysis of 700 German councils that lie just outside the limits of the major cities, and compared prices in 2020 with those from 2015.

They found a huge price increase in what Germans call the Speckgürtel, (literally the fat belt), or what we call suburbia, where prices have soared by 58 percent on average.

“During the pandemic people increasingly want to move to the countryside, but at the same time they don’t want to miss the advantages of urban life and the security of first-class medical care,” said Kai Enders, a member of the board at Engel & Völkers.

“Small towns around metropolitan areas are proving to be up-and-coming residential and investment locations.”

Good internet connections decisive

Broadband cables being laid in Mecklenburg. Photo: dpa-Zentralbild | Jens Büttner

Most experts agree that one of the most decisive factors for making a rural district attractive to young people is the modernity of its digital infrastructure.

Broadband is far from a given in many rural parts of Germany. Although the federal government has for years offered a huge pot of money for local councils to invest in broadband, not all have been far-sighted enough to make use of the offer. 

“Places that can’t offer broadband are basically out of the question as a place to live,” economist Matthias Günther told broadcaster NDR. “What do I get from the new freedom of home office if I can’t use it in my new place of residence?” 

READ MORE: Germany’s (dis)connectivity: Can the broadband Internet gap be bridged?

‘No sign of flight from the city’

Not all experts agree though that the pandemic has caused Germans to fall in love with bucolic bliss en masse.

A study by the Leibniz Institute for Economics published last week looked at the real estate market and came to the conclusion that there was no evidence that Germans were fleeing the cities.

“For years, house price increases have been driven primarily by metropolitan regions,” the report stated. “The pandemic has not changed this: the price development in the seven largest cities showed a positive trend almost throughout 2020.”

The only exception was Berlin, where house prices in the regions of Brandenburg surrounding the capital did rise even more sharply than in Berlin itself.

This difference was sometimes quite dramatic. In the district of Oberhavel to the north of the capital, prices shot up by an eye-watering 43 percent last year.

But the boffins at the Leibniz Institute caution that “it isn’t clear whether this is due to the pandemic.”

Berlin’s “overheated housing market” and the left-wing city government’s rent cap law are possible explanations for the sudden desirability of homes outside the city limits.

READ MORE: Berlin’s rental cap has ‘more than halved the size of market’

SHOW COMMENTS