SHARE
COPY LINK

WORLD WAR

The image that captured an Austrian region’s fateful choice

In the southern Austrian region of Carinthia, the anniversary of the end of World War I stirs memories of how borders shifted after the conflict, changing the lives of its inhabitants.

The image that captured an Austrian region's fateful choice
Carmen Kuster, poses with an image showing a family in traditional costume casting its vote into a ballot box emblazoned with Carinthia's coat of arms. Photo: AFP

As Carmen Kuster thinks back to her childhood in the village of Gallizien, close to the Slovenian border in the foothills of the Alps, one image stands out above all: an engraving “hanging in all schools and colleges” representing the plebiscite through which the region had to decide which country it would belong to.

In it, a family in traditional costume casts its vote into a ballot box emblazoned with Carinthia's coat of arms.

The end of the war brought about the collapse of the multi-ethnic Austro-Hungarian Empire, which had up until then held together large parts of central Europe and the Balkans under the banner of its Habsburg rulers.

The Empire's constituent nations began to form states — but the question of drawing borders between them was anything but straightforward.

“It had to be decided whether the region where I was born was to carry on being part of Austria or whether it would join the new Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes,” says 42-year-old Kuster, using the name for the predecessor state to Yugoslavia.

In southern Carinthia, with its mix of German and Slovene speakers, the border question was hotly debated.

“My great-grandfather was a supporter of staying within Austria, he was active in that movement,” Kuster says.

'Nationalist' distortion

The Treaty of Saint-Germain between the victorious Allies and Austria provided for a referendum to settle southern Carinthia's status, which duly took place on 10 October 1920.

Fifty-nine percent of voters chose to remain within Austria. 

“October 10 is a holiday in Carinthia. It's a big celebration,” she says.

“The night before there are fires lit on the mountains to mark it.”

Now living in Vienna but still very much attached to her native region, Kuster complains that the holiday has now been distorted “in a very nationalist way by the right”.

The numbers of people identifying as Slovenian in Carinthia have fallen from tens of thousands at the time of the vote to just a few thousand today.

The minority enjoys rights guaranteed by the constitution and 164 districts in the region use bilingual road signs.

AUCTION

Swiss donor hands Nazi artefacts to Israel warning of anti-Semitism

A wealthy Lebanese-Swiss businessman said Sunday he had bought Adolf Hitler's top hat and other Nazi artifacts to give them to Jewish groups and prevent them falling into the hands of a resurgent far-right.

Swiss donor hands Nazi artefacts to Israel warning of anti-Semitism
Photo: MATTHIAS BALK / DPA / AFP

Abdallah Chatila said he had felt compelled to take the objects off the market because of the rising anti-Semitism, populism and racism he was witnessing in Europe.

He spent about 600,000 euros ($660,000) for eight objects connected to Hitler, including the collapsible top hat, in a November 20 sale at a Munich auction house, originally planning to burn them all.

But he then decided to give them to the Keren Hayesod association, an Israeli fundraising group, which has resolved to hand them to Israel's Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial centre.

Chatila told a Jerusalem press conference it had been a “very easy” decision to purchase the items when he saw the “potentially lethal injustice that those artefacts would go to the wrong hands”. 

“I felt I had no choice but to actually try to help the cause,” he added.

“What happened in the last five years in Europe showed us that anti-Semitism, that populism, that racism is going stronger and stronger, and we are here to fight it and show people we're not scared.

“Today — with the fake news, with the media, with the power that people could have with the internet, with social media — somebody else could use that small window” of time to manipulate the public, he said.

He said he had worried the Nazi-era artefacts could be used by neo-Nazi groups or those seeking to stoke anti-Semitism and racism in Europe.

“That's why I felt I had to do it,” he said of his purchase.

The items, still in Munich, are to be eventually delivered to Yad Vashem, where they will be part of a collection of Nazi artefacts crucial to countering Holocaust denial, but not be put on regular display, said Avner Shalev, the institute's director.

Chatila also met with Israeli President Reuven Rivlin and visited Yad Vashem.

'Place for optimism'

Chatila was born in Beirut into a family of Christian jewellers and moved to Switzerland at the age of two.

Now among Switzerland's richest 300 people, he supports charities and causes, including many relating to Lebanon and Syrian refugees.

The auction was brought to Chatila's attention by the European Jewish Association, which has sought to sway public opinion against the trade in Nazi memorabilia.

Rabbi Mehachem Margolin, head of the association, said Chatila's surprise act had raised attention to such auctions.

He said it was a powerful statement against racism and xenophobia, especially coming from a non-Jew of Lebanese origin.

Lebanon and Israel remain technically at war and Lebanese people are banned from communication with Israelis.

“There is no question that a message that comes from you is 10 times, or 100 times stronger than a message that comes from us,” Margolin told Chatila.

The message was not only about solidarity among people, but also “how one person can make such a huge change,” Margolin said.

“There's a place for optimism.”

SHOW COMMENTS