SHARE
COPY LINK

COSMETICS

Banned substances found in over 140 cosmetic products sold in France

French authorities have discovered over 140 cosmetic products containing banned substances after an inquiry was launched on the back of a blacklist containing 1,000 'worrying' items published by a leading consumer group.

Banned substances found in over 140 cosmetic products sold in France
Photo: AFP
The DGCCRF, which is in charge of clamping down on fraud in consumer products, launched the investigation in June following information from French consumer group UFC-Que Choisir. 
 
The Local has contacted the DGCCRF for a list of the more than 140 products. 
 
The DGCCRF have made moves to see them pulled from the shelves of stores in France.
 
“These products have been subject to an immediate withdrawal requirement,” the DGCCRF said. 
 
The investigation was specifically targeting products containing traces of irritants like MIT and paraben isobutylparaben, two substances banned since February 2017 and July 2015 respectively because of “allergic reactions they may cause”. 
 
The DGCCRF's investigation revealed that certain incriminated products no longer contained the banned substances but that, as the labeling had not been updated, they still appeared on them. 
 
As for the cosmetics actually containing the banned substances, the DGCCRF said some manufacturers were trying hard to shift their stocks.
 
Two manufacturers were accused of “continuing the use and marketing of these chemicals” after their ban and they will be referred to the justice system said the DGCCRF.

 
The original list from UFC-Que Choisir contained 23 cosmetic products said to contain banned substances on a list including a total of 1,017 cosmetic products containing “undesirable” substances.
 
The 23 most worrying products on the list included an eye treatment by L'Oréal Men, a sun cream for kids by Lovea and Vivelle hair gel, UFC-Que Choisir said should be pulled from the shelves immediately because they contain chemicals that are banned by law, including hormone-altering substances (known as endocrine disruptors).   
 
READ ALSO:
Photo: AFP
 
The price for breaking the laws around making and importing banned substances is high. Penalties include two years in prison and a fine of €30,000 that can be pushed up to €150,000 in some cases.
 
“We are very attentive to cosmetics every year,” the DGCCRF's Loïc Tanguy told AFP in June. Just last year the DGCCRF carried out checks on 8,000 products. 
 
“In addition to our own checks, we will take into account the information from UFC-Que Choisir,” he added. 

 
Other items on the original list from UFC-Que Choisir were by popular brands such as L'Oréal and Head&Shoulders and featured everything from perfumes, make-up products, shower gels, deodorants, toothpastes, creams and pretty much every product you could find in your bathroom. 
 
You can CLICK HERE for the full list from UFC-Que Choisir. 
 
The list of ingredients to watch out for also includes allergenics, and irritants like MIT, as well as antibacterial and antifungal agent Triclosan and colorless and odorless liquid, Cyclopentasiloxane. You can CLICK HERE for the full list of substances to avoid. 
 
UFC-Que Choisir recommended the public to not buy any of the 1,000 products on the list because of the “undesirable substances”. The products should not be used at all on at-risk individuals, such as babies, they say.
 
The group highlights the fact that without strict regulations for cosmetics products, the guidance provided on cosmetics labels just isn't enough. 
 
UFC-Que Choisir has urged the European Commission to publish a “bold definition of hormone-changing substances” including those suspected of being so. 

HEALTH

French public warned to avoid ‘toxic lip balms’

Lip balm users have been warned by a leading French consumer group about the dangers of smearing their lips with the product after their tests found that certain balms contained toxic substances.

French public warned to avoid 'toxic lip balms'
Photo: AFP

Half of the 21 products put to the test by UFC Que-choisir were discovered to have potentially harmful ingredients, including lip balms from large cosmetic brands Garnier, La Roche Posay, Carmex, and Le Petit Marseillais. 

The consumer group warned consumers to stay away from the balms which were found to have carcinogenic substances.

Others contained Mosh – mineral oil saturated hydrocarbons – which if swallowed, can make their way into the lymph nodes and liver and inflame them. 

“The level of Mosh (mineral oil saturated hydrocarbons) in these lip balms is extremely undesirable, on account of their toxicity when they are ingested,” the report said

READ ALSO:

 

But there is good news for anyone with chapped lips – the safest, most effective, and hydrating lip balm was found to the cheapest. 

Lidl’s “Cien” branded balm was the cheapest of the bunch priced at just 75 centimes. 

“The enormous price differences aren’t reflected in the results,” said representatives from UFC Que Choisir. 

The lip balms consumers were urged to avoid were:

  • Macadamia lip balm from Yves Rocher 

  • Trésors de miel nourishing lip balm from Garnier Ultra Doux 

  • Original classic care from Labello

  • Classic moisturising lip balm from Carmex 

  • Nultric transforming balm for dry lips from La Roche Posay

  • Homéostick from Boiron

  • Cold cream nourishing balm from Avène

  • Nutrition balm for dry lips from Le petit Marseillais

  • Hydrating lip balm from Aptonia

  • Hydrating lip balm from Uriage

Earlier this year, French authorities promised to investigate 1,000 cosmetic products found to contain illegal and undesirable substances after the consumer group published a similar report. 

By Anna Schaverien