SHARE
COPY LINK

SI

Woman battles pharma giant over ‘danger pill’

A woman who suffered what she believes were life-threatening side-effects from a contraceptive pill is now suing pharmaceuticals giant Bayer in what could become a landmark case.

Woman battles pharma giant over 'danger pill'
Felicitas Rohrer poses with a package of the contraceptive medication Yasminelle. Photo: DPA

The accusations against Bayer's contraceptive pills Yasminelle and Yaz, based on drospirenone, are not new and the company has already paid out nearly $2 billion (€1.8 billion) to around 10,000 women in out-of-court settlements in the United States to avoid long and costly trials.

But Rohrer's case, which opens on Thursday, is highly symbolic in the company's home country of Germany, where Bayer, maker of Aspirin, stands as a beacon for the domestic chemicals and pharmaceuticals sectors.

Rohrer is suing the company for €200,000 euros in damages and interest.
But “the money cannot compensate for what I and other women have gone through,” she told AFP.

“What I really hope for is justice,” she said in her home in Willstaett, not far from the French-German border, adding that her hope is for Yasminelle to be withdrawn from the market.

At the age of 31, and following a pulmonary embolism – a blockage of the lung's main artery – Rohrer now has to take an anti-coagulant that significantly reduces her chances of having a baby.

She suffers from shortness of breath and is forced to wear anti-embolism compression stockings on car journeys of any length.

She studied to become a vet but now works as a journalist because she is not allowed to carry any heavy loads.

It was in June 2009 that Rohrer, hitherto a perfectly healthy young woman, suddenly collapsed. Her heart stopped for 20 minutes. And in an emergency operation, doctors found massive blood clots clogging her heart.

Increased risk

“The doctors couldn't believe that a 25-year-old woman could suffer from a pulmonary embolism,” she said.

And the doctors clearly pointed the finger at the pill.

The self-help group Rohrer has since set up has collected testimony from around 250 women who suffered similar side effects.

She is the first person in Germany to sue Bayer over the drug, accusing the company of not informing patients sufficiently about the risks associated with Yasminelle.

The trial opens on Thursday in a court in Waldshut-Tiengen near the Swiss border.

Bayer – which sold 768 million euros worth of the Yasmin group of contraceptive pills in 2014, compared with total overall group sales of 42 billion euros – rejects the accusations as “unjustified”.

It insists the pills have a “positive” risk-benefit profile and are approved by every national drug agency.

So far, the courts have agreed, notably in a case brought against Bayer in Switzerland.

Nevertheless, a number of studies have suggested that contraceptive pills using drospirenone and other progestins double the risk of clotting blood vessels compared with earlier generations of contraceptive pills.

In France, where Bayer has already been the target of a number of other high-profile cases, health insurers have halted reimbursements for the pills, hitting group sales there.

A German medical journal claims that there has been a drop in the number of women admitted to hospital with pulmonary embolism in France.

'Lack of information'

Taking the pills “increases the risks and women should be aware of that,” said Yana Vinogradova, a scientist at Nottingham University in Britain.

Nevertheless, “the risks remain low, lower than those connected to pregnancy,” she added.

One of the leading public health insurers in Germany, Techniker Krankenkasse, expressed alarm in a recent report about the “predominance of high-risk pills” on the market.

“There is a lack of information on the part of the doctors and the pharmaceuticals industry,” said Gerd Glaeske, pharmacologist and co-author of the report.

He said he viewed the lawsuit filed by Rohrer as “an important symbol”.

All the more so, because Yasmin, with its anti water-retention effects, means patients are less likely to gain weight, Glaeske said.

It is “the first pill that has a very clear marketing angle on beauty and well-being,” opening the way for boasts that contraceptive pills are effective in fighting acne, for example, he argued.

In the meantime, in the United States, Bayer is also the target of a growing number of lawsuits against another of its contraceptive products, the implant Essure, which women complain has caused them pain and severe bleeding.

MONSANTO

French police to probe alleged Monsanto lists on opinion-makers

France has opened a preliminary enquiry into allegations that US pesticides maker Monsanto had information illegally collected on the views and pliability of hundreds of high-profile figures and media outlets.

French police to probe alleged Monsanto lists on opinion-makers
Activists from the 'Attac' protest group scale the offices of Bayer -which recently acquired Monsanto- in La Garenne Colombes near the financial district of La Defence on the outskirts of Paris. Photo
Paris judicial police will carry out the probe following a complaint by the daily Le Monde and one of its journalists, whose names appear on the list, the Paris prosecutor's office said.
 
Two anti-pesticide NGOs — Foodwatch and Generations Futures — are also preparing to lodge legal complaints over the alleged lists.
 
The investigators will look into the possible “collection of personal information by fraudulent, unfair or illicit means”.
   
US giant Monsanto allegedly had public relations agency FleishmanHillard draw up the files on the opinions of the targeted people and media bodies on the controversial weedkiller glyphosate and on genetically modified crops as 
well as their propensity to be influenced in their opinions.
 
 
Figuring on the list are politicians, scientists and journalists — including four from AFP (Agence France-Presse). Information was collected on their views on pesticides and on Monsanto as well as their leisure pursuits, addresses and phone numbers, according to the France 2 public television channel.
   
Some of the names were listed under categories such as “priority targets” and “potential allies to recruit”, according to reports.
   
France's former environment minister Segolene Royal, whose name was said to appear on the lists, said the allegation “says a lot about the methods of lobbyists… they carry out spying, infiltration, seek to influence, sometimes financially I imagine”, adding that other companies are likely to indulge in similar practices.
   
A spokesman for FleishmanHillard told AFP: “FleishmanHillard and our staff are committed to compliance with applicable laws and we are committed to the highest standards of ethical conduct. 
   
“We continue to take that responsibility very seriously and will carefully examine the questions raised by certain media outlets about the lists of stakeholders that included publicly available information.”
   
Glyphosate developer Monsanto was convicted in the United States in 2018 and 2019 of not taking necessary steps to warn of the potential risks of Roundup — their weedkiller containing the chemical, which two California juries found caused cancer in two users.
   
German pharmaceutical firm Bayer, which bought Monsanto last year, announced last month that over 13,000 lawsuits related to the weedkiller have been launched in the US. 
SHOW COMMENTS