SHARE
COPY LINK

CASH

Cashless society faces backlash from losers

Sweden is possibly the nearest thing the world has to a cashless society, but some Swedes are worried about the effects on rural areas, pensioners - and personal integrity.

Cashless society faces backlash from losers
What are the downsides of a cashless society? Photo: Per Larsson/TT

Buy a magazine from a homeless person in Stockholm, and it’s increasingly likely that they will let you pay by card. It’s perhaps the most extreme sign of the transition to a cash-free society, which has arguably gone further in Sweden than anywhere else. Those who face losing out used the Almedalen political forum on Gotland this week to launch a campaign to halt the move to plastic.

Björn Eriksson, a former head of Sweden’s national police and now head of Säkerhetsbranschen, a lobbying group for the security industry, is cynical about the banks’ motivations: “It’s in banks’ interests to reduce use of cash. They take fees for card payments, not cash payments,” he says.

According to a report by the Swedish Federation of Trade last year, four out of five purchases in Sweden are made by credit or debit card, compared to just one in four in cash-loving Italy. Increasingly, technology such as iZettle allows small businesses to take card payments via smartphones. 

While the banks, most retailers and many consumers have welcomed the move away from cash, there are concerns that many people are falling between the cracks. Björn Eriksson now leads an alliance of the security industry (which is seeing a falling demand for cash transport), pensioners’ groups and small business lobbyists, which claims that a society dependent on cards particularly hurts small businesses and pensioners. 

There’s also the question of privacy. While Eriksson cheerfully admits that his industry has a vested interest in keeping cash, he insists that the disappearance of cash raises big integrity issues, as banks are able to build a very detailed picture of customers’ consumption patterns:

“Swedes see the banks almost as state-run organizations rather than the private companies that they are,” he says. “Foreigners ask me how Swedes can have such faith in the banks,” he says.

READ ALSO: Small businesses seek help in cashless Sweden

There are more practical issues too. People in rural areas also lose out, as cash machines (ATMs) that are under-used risk being removed – a move that particularly affects rural pensioners.

Sweden’s fifth smallest bank – Mjöbäcks Sparbank – recently resorted to paying customers in the small town of Överlida to make cash withdrawals to encourage them to use the cash machine. CEO Tomas Andrén said cash must continue to exist, but added that with cash use falling by 8-10 percent a year it was becoming harder to maintain cash machines in rural areas.

Meanwhile, many bank branches refuse to handle cash altogether. In a situation repeated across Sweden, two of the main bank chains in Gotland’s largest town, Visby, refuse to handle cash, citing security concerns.

“I’ve heard of people keeping cash in their microwaves because banks won’t accept it,” Eriksson says.

Yet despite all these concerns, the prospect of Sweden reversing its move away from cash is remote. Jan Ericsson, an MP for the centre-right Moderates who sits on the Riksdag’s finance committee says “we can’t stop the move away from cash.”

“The Riksdag has looked at forcing banks to take cash, but it transpired that this risked leading to them closing their branches in small towns.”

COST OF LIVING

Could coronavirus end Austria’s love affair with cash?

Along with the rest of German-speaking Europe, cash payments have remained stubbornly popular in Austria. But with card payments on the rise due to the pandemic, could that be set to change permanently?

Could coronavirus end Austria’s love affair with cash?
Austria loves cash, but will the pandemic change all that? Photo: ALEX HALADA / AFP

Unlike Scandinavia, the Benelux countries or the British Isles, German-speaking Europe remains keen on cash. 

For a number of historical reasons, cash is still king in Austria, Germany and much of Switzerland – or at least until the onset of the coronavirus pandemic. 

Austria loves cash so much that it tried to make a right to cash payments part of the constitution in 2019. 

READ MORE: Austria's love of cash in poll campaign spotlight 

While the effort ultimately failed, it showed just how much Austria loves that cold, hard stuff. 

A pre-pandemic study showed that Austria are the kings of cash, with 83 percent of Austrians using cash regularly, compared with 75 percent of Germans and 71 percent of Swiss. 

This is compared with card leaders such as Sweden, where cash is expected to disappear completely by 2030. 

The number of domestic card payments increased by 20 percent in 2020 in Austria, rising from 900 million payments to 1.1 billion, according to Payment Services Austria (PSA). 

In the same period, foreign card transactions also increased in Austria in 2020, crossing the 1.2 billion mark for the first time. 

Contactless and mobile payments are also experiencing a dramatic rise in Austria. 

Similar trends have been observed in Germany and Switzerland, leading many to ask whether the shift is set to become permanent. 

Money, cash, woes?

Concerns over the cleanliness of cash and a desire to avoid trips to the ATM have been flagged as a major reason for the change. 

The number of cash withdrawals from ATMs in Austria fell significantly, from 137 million to 100 million in 2020. 

Contactless payments increased by 34 percent in 2020 compared to 2019, according to PSA. 

READ MORE: Could coronavirus end the Swiss love affair with cash? 

In March 2020, Austria also made it easier to pay with contactless cards by increasing the maximum amount to be paid without entering a pin from €25 to €50. 

Retailers pushed for the change in a bid to reduce the risk of coronavirus transmission and the limit looks to remain in place for the foreseeable future. 

According to the PSA, the card is here to stay, even when and if life returns to normal after the pandemic. 

Harald Flatscher, Managing Director of PSA, said “the steady upward trend also shows how much the use of the card has become part of people's everyday lives.”

A permanent shift to card?

There are however signs that the trends might be temporary. 

While 2020 saw an increase in card payments, it actually saw a decrease in the amount spent overall, which could amount to a temporary trend. 

Another big change is the lack of tourist traffic, making it hard to determine if any shift is actually permanent.  

READ MORE: Will the coronavirus pandemic speed up the end of cash in Germany? 

Writing in Austria’s Der Standard on Wednesday, January 27th, Muzayen Al-Youssef outlined the concerns of many Austrians when pointing to the traceability of card. 

“Transparency also has consequences. Think, for example, of so-called credit scoring, in which the creditworthiness of a customer is calculated based on the available data,” he said.

“If you drink too much alcohol, in extreme cases you could suddenly no longer finance your own apartment.

“Does a bank really always have to know when – and, by the way, where – its customers bought sex toys, alcohol or cigarettes?”

 

SHOW COMMENTS