SHARE
COPY LINK

ROMA

Roma beggars not run by crime groups: report

There is no evidence that Romanian beggars in northern Europe are managed by organised crime groups, according to a new report from Norwegian social research foundation Fafo.

Roma beggars not run by crime groups: report
Gina Ionescu, a Roma woman, begging in Oslo in 2013. Photo: Marte Christensen/NTB Scanpix
Fafo interviewed 1,269 homeless Romanians in Oslo, Stockholm and Copenhagen last summer without finding any signs of criminal third parties. 
 
“We’re very certain that the beggars are not in any way part of organised crime,” Ann Britt Druve, one of the researchers behind the study. “They know each other and they travel in family networks and community networks. It’s not being organised by any third party.” 
 
As well as interviewing homeless Romanians on the streets with a set questionnaire, Fafo also arranged in-depth qualitative interviews, and visited Romania to carry out field surveys. 
 
“We don’t think that all of them would have been able to deceive us to such an extent,” Druve said. 
 
The Romanians, most of whom were ethnic Roma, normally travelled to Scandinavia in minibuses, often borrowing the money to finance their journey, either from family or from the minibus drivers. 
 
They typically earned around 200 Norwegian kroner each day, saving about half of that to send home to Romania. 
 
“Their families in Romania are extremely poor so this can make a lot of difference,” she said. 
 
It was not, however, enough money to attract the interest of organised crime groups, she believed. 
 
“This is not enough for a criminal network. It’s not worth the effort.” 
 
Drive started the interviews in Oslo early last summmer, before moving on to Stockholm, and finishing in Copenhagen in the autumn.

BEGGING

Switzerland condemned by rights court over fine for beggar

The European Court of Human Rights on Tuesday faulted Switzerland for imposing a heavy fine on a Romanian woman for begging and then detaining her when she couldn't pay.

Switzerland condemned by rights court over fine for beggar
Begging is against the law in Geneva. Photo by AFP

The ethnic Roma in her late twenties, was fined 500 Swiss francs (464 euros, $563 at current rates) for begging on the street in Geneva in January 2014.

When the woman, who is illiterate and has no job or welfare payments, failed to pay up, she was placed in temporary detention for five days.

The court found the penalties against the woman were out of proportion with Switzerland's aims of fighting organised crime and protecting passers-by, residents and business owners.

The woman had “the right, which is inherent in human dignity, to express her distress and try to meet her needs by begging”, the verdict said.

Switzerland had violated article 8 of the European Convention of Human Rights, which guarantees the protection of private and family life, it said, ordering the country to pay the woman 922 euros ($1,118) in moral damages. 

SHOW COMMENTS