SHARE
COPY LINK

TAXIS

Uber to appeal Geneva ban on its car ride app

Uber, the mobile app company that allows you to order a car ride from your smartphone, is appealing a ban on its activities in the canton of Geneva.

Uber to appeal Geneva ban on its car ride app
Photo: Uber

The cantonal government issued an order at the end of March for the controversial California-based company to cease its operations because they do not comply with regulations for taxis, the ATS news agency reported on Monday.

The order was confirmed by a spokesman for Pierre Maudet, the cantonal cabinet minister responsible for taxis in Geneva, following a report from the Tribune de Genève newspaper.

The commerce department of the canton considers that Uber is acting like a taxi dispatcher and should therefore respect the Genevan law for taxis.

It maintains the company has been aware of the rules of the business since it started offering its services in Geneva in September 2014 but has decided to ignore them, ATS said.

Uber's app links customers customers with professional drivers operating with private-hire licences.

Recently, Geneva tax drivers have mounted the barricades to demand that the canton take measures against Uber, complaining that the industry is suffering from unfair competition.

But the canton could not issue an order earlier because of an administrative procedure it had to follow.

“We are not a dispatch centre for taxis but a technology business that develops IT applications that allow, in a specific market, bringing together supply and demand,” Thomas Meister, a spokesman for Uber in Western Europe, is quoted as saying by ATS.

For Uber, the ban decreed by the canton of Geneva is the equivalent of outlawing emails under the pretext that they infringe on the law for the post office.

The company is planning to appeal the decision through an administrative court, ATS said.

Uber believes it can make inroads in Geneva, which has some of the highest cab fares in Europe, as well as other Swiss cities such as Zurich, Basel and Lausanne.

But the company has faced resistance in other European countries, such as Germany, which banned its low-cost Uber Pop service after German taxi drivers took it to court for violating transport laws.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

COST OF LIVING

Uber poised for Swiss expansion

Long plagued by legal issues and driver shortages, ride sharing service Uber is set to expand into more of Switzerland’s French-speaking towns.

Uber poised for Swiss expansion
Photo by Humphrey Muleba on Unsplash

Long plagued by legal issues and driver shortages, ride sharing service Uber is set to expand into more of Switzerland’s French-speaking towns. 

The ride sharing service announced on Wednesday it would expand into the predominantly French-speaking towns of Fribourg, Sion and Yverdon. 

A spokesman for the American service told Swiss media outlet Watson the expansion was fuelled by demand. 

In Sion and Fribourg, while rides can be booked via the app, they will be carried out by taxis in order to comply with local regulations. 

“Our launch will enable taxi drivers to increase the use of their vehicles, win new customers and thus generate more sales thanks to our technology,” said Jean-Pascal Aribot, Director of Uber Switzerland. 

Uber currently operates freely in the German-speaking cities of Basel, Bern, Lucerne, Winterthur and Zurich. 

Legal issues and driver shortages

Uber’s expansion in Switzerland has been slower than in some neighbouring countries.  

Drivers have complained that Switzerland’s high cost of living makes it more difficult to make ends meet, while the company has also been plagued by frequent legal issues. 

The service is currently banned in Geneva due to concerns about payments for drivers, although the ban has been suspended regarding an appeal. 

Geneva classifies Uber as an employer, meaning that drivers should be entitled to benefits including paid holidays, sick leave and pensions. 

The company disputes this and says its drivers are independent contractors. 

In February, voters in Zurich approved a plan to place more restrictions on Uber in the canton. 

The new restrictions include that drivers need to register with cantonal authorities and place obvious signs on their vehicles to distinguish them from regular cars.

The vote, which took place only in the canton of Zurich as part of the February 9 round of referendums, sought to bring regulation for Uber and other ride-sharing services in line with taxis and other limousine services. 

A total of 51.6 percent of voters approved the initiative, while 42.4 percent were opposed. 

The initiative also ‘cantonalised’ taxi regulation, meaning that the municipalities of Zurich will no longer set conditions for taxi companies. Unlike previously, taxis are now allowed to use ranks anywhere in the canton. 

SHOW COMMENTS