SHARE
COPY LINK

PHOTOGRAPHY

Italian stripped of World Press Photo award

An Italian photographer has been stripped of a prestigious World Press Photo award after lying about the location of the image shot in Belgium.

Italian stripped of World Press Photo award
World Press Photo said Giovanni Troilo had broken the rules governing the awards. Photo: Robin Utrecht/ANP/AFP

Giovanni Troilo on Wednesday lost his first prize in the contemporary issues category following an investigation into his photo series, entitled La Ville Noir – The Dark Heart of Europe.

In his submission Troilo claimed all ten of the winning photographs were taken in Charleroi, a Belgian city known in the past for its crime and prostitution, but further investigation revealed one of the shots was taken in Brussels.

The photographer admitted falsifying information about the photograph in question, of a painter and live models, prompting the World Press Photo foundation to disqualify the work.

An investigation into Troilo’s images came after a complaint from Charleroi’s mayor, who said the series was a “serious distortion of reality” about his city.

Among the mayor’s complaints was that one of the images, of an overweight man at home, demonstrated “neurotic obesity”. The subject, Philippe G, however said he was proud of his body and happy to pose topless for Troilo.

Questions were also raised about an image depicting the photographer’s cousin having sex in a car.

Although Troilo’s relative had given the photographer permission to follow him and shoot the scene, World Press Photo said this did not amount to staging as the couple would have sex in public with or without the photographer being present.

After the initial complaints, World Press Photo on Sunday confirmed Toilo’s award and said there were “no grounds for doubting the photographer’s integrity in carrying out his work”.

Fresh information, however, prompted the foundation to reopen its investigation on Tuesday, revealing one of the images was not shot in Charleroi.

Discussing the decision to disqualify Troilo, Lars Boering, World Press Photo’s managing director, said in a statement that “a rule has now been broken and a line has been crossed”.

“The World Press Photo Contest must be based on trust in the photographers who enter their work and in their professional ethics. We have checks and controls in place, of course, but the contest simply does not work without trust.

“We now have a clear case of misleading information and this changes the way the story is perceived,” Boering said.

SEE ALSO: Top photo prize for Italy's sea rescue mission
 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

PHOTOGRAPHY

Danish photographer wins World Press Photo award

Danish photographer Mads Nissen has won the prestigious World Press Photo of the Year award.

Danish photographer wins World Press Photo award
See below for the full version of the award-winning photograph. Photo: Mads Nissen/Ritzau Scanpix

Nissen took the winning photograph on an assignment in Brazil in which he portrayed the impact of the coronavirus pandemic on life in some of the South American country’s hardest-hit areas.

The photograph shows Rosa Luzia Lunardi (85) and nurse Adriana Silva da Costa Souza at Viva Bem care home, São Paulo, Brazil, on August 5th 2020.

The two people holding are each other while wearing face masks and separated by a plastic sheet.

Nissen, who works as a staff photographer for newspaper Politiken, has now won the international award twice.

“To me, this is a story about hope and love in the most difficult times. When I learned about the crisis that was unfolding in Brazil and the poor leadership of president Bolsonaro who has been neglecting this virus from the very beginning, who’s been calling it ‘a small flu,’ I really felt an urge to do something about it,” Nissen commented via the World Press Photo website.

World Press Photo jury member Kevin WY Lee said the “iconic image of COVID-19 memorializes the most extraordinary moment of our lives, everywhere.”

“I read vulnerability, loved ones, loss and separation, demise, but, importantly, also survival—all rolled into one graphic image. If you look at the image long enough, you’ll see wings: a symbol of flight and hope,” Lee said via the award’s website.

Photo: Mads Nissen/Ritzau Scanpix

The annual World Press Photo contests reward visual journalism and digital storytelling.

SHOW COMMENTS