SHARE
COPY LINK

IMMIGRATION

Foreigner’s Italian ‘not good enough’ for oath

An Indian woman has been barred from completing the process towards gaining Italian citizenship by a mayor who argued that her language skills are not up to scratch, despite her living in the country for 15 years.

Foreigner's Italian 'not good enough' for oath
The Indian woman has until Sunday to take the oath, after which her citizenship application will be void. Passport photo: Shutterstock

Rani Pushpa, 56, was blocked from citizenship by the mayor of Cairate, in northern Italy, who stopped her from swearing the oath of allegiance by arguing her Italian was not good enough.

The oath was to be Pushpa's last step towards gaining citizenship, after getting all the necessary approval from the Italian authorities.

Mayor Paolo Mazzucchelli, from the anti-immigration Northern League party, instead advised her to take a language course.

An Indian citizen, Pushpa has lived in Italy for 15 years and said she struggles with learning the country’s language.

“I’ve already been a number of times to ask to swear the oath, but I wasn’t allowed. Now I’ve spent two months in an Italian school, and my language skills are getting better,” she was quoted in Corriere della Sera as saying.

Pushpa now has until Sunday to swear the oath of allegiance, after which her citizenship application will be void.

Her lawyer accused Mazzucchelli of failing to perform his official duties and said the case would be taken to court if Puspha was not allowed to swear the oath imminently.

Pushpa’s husband Kuman, who is already an Italian citizen, said he wanted his and his wife’s “rights to be respected.”

But Mazzucchelli said that there was “no discrimination” in his decision to block Pushpa from citizenship, arguing that he performs weekly citizenship tests for people who speak Italian.

“A person that swears the oath to obtain Italian citizenship must know how to speak Italian. As foreseen in law, they must know how to read the constitution.

“Mrs Pushpa was still not ready. I therefore suggested, during a friendly meeting in which her daughter and son-in-law were present, to enrol in an Italian course. If she is ready to recite the phrase in Italian, there’s no opposition on my part,” he said.

Mazzucchelli’s Northern League has being gaining popularity in recent months, with party leader Matteo Salvini campaigning on a firmly anti-immigration stance.

At a rally in Rome on Saturday, Salvini listed stopping immigration as one of the party’s three priorities, along with scrapping the euro and getting back “monetary sovereignty”.

“There is no more room for anyone else with the unemployment rates we have today. And finally, Italians first," Salvini said.

READ MORE: Italian anti-immigrant party stages Rome rally
 

For members

ITALIAN CITIZENSHIP

How ancestry detectives help Americans and Brits find their Italian roots

Whether it's for a citizenship application or just to satisfy curiosity, tracking down long-lost Italian ancestors can be a difficult task. Reporter Silvia Marchetti finds out exactly what one Sicilian family tree researcher's work involves.

How ancestry detectives help Americans and Brits find their Italian roots

Fabio Cardile from Palermo has a very peculiar job. For 25 years he’s been working as a family tree researcher for American and European clients interested in discovering their Italian origins.

They have an Italian background and an Italian-sounding last name, but have no idea who their ancestors were and, in most cases, don’t even know from where they migrated. 

“I started doing these investigations first by dedicating myself to researching the origin of my own last name, Cardile, where exactly my family came from,” 44-year-old Cardile tells The Local.

“Then this passion turned into a job, and now I have clients from abroad contacting me and hiring me to dig into their family history and unearth information on their ancestral backgrounds.”

He was the one who discovered the origin of the last name of American actor John Travolta, and he also carried out research on the origins of Jill Biden’s Sicilian heritage. 

In all cases, these are stories of Italian immigrants who left their homes decades, if not centuries ago, to find a brighter future in the US or in Europe, including the UK, France and Germany. 

“In the hardest cases all clients are able to give me is their last name and I need to trace back in time the origin of it and the location in Italy where still nowadays there are similar-sounding names.”

READ ALSO: An expert guide to getting Italian citizenship via ancestry

What makes his job particularly tough is that most immigrants, when they landed in their country of destination, changed their surname by adapting it linguistically to the community they had moved to.

“It was very common for immigrants in the past to make their names sound American or English in order to adapt, be accepted by the local community and find a job more easily. They did not want to stand out from the crowd as Italians and be discriminated against in any way,” says Cardile.

Fabio Cardile has worked as a family tree researcher for 25 years. Photo: Fabio Cardile

Cardile’s job is very complex. He starts his investigations by digging into state records, as well local parish and graveyard archives, for ancient documents to support the ancestry claims of his foreign clients, who are pushed by a nostalgic need to reconnect with their forsaken roots.

He starts off with some online tools: four basic websites (gens.info; familysearch.org; ancestry.it; antenati.cultura.gov.it) where he can start looking for the geographic origin of last names by just typing them into a search bar – but as three of these sites are only in Italian, his foreign clients need his help.

On some of these websites, particularly the one run by the Culture Ministry, he finds state archives concerning birth certificates, death certificates, wedding certificates, or divorce certificates with specific dates and names, which allow him to start drawing up a family tree. 

READ ALSO: Five surprising things to know about applying for Italian citizenship via ancestry

“Obviously, the more information people give me on where their ancestors might have hailed from, the easier it is for me to find the location and narrow down the search,” he says. 

Cardile works across Italy, not just focusing on Sicily where most Italian emigrants left in the 1800-1900s. 

State archives go back until the 1860s, when the Italian kingdom was formed, and in some cases, all the way back to the Renaissance, he says. Initial research starts at around €300 then Cardile’s fee rises if he needs to travel around Italy for further investigation.

When he has unearthed specific information on the probable origins of a family, he makes a trip to the local parishes, churches and graveyards which in a pre-unified Italy were the only places where birth and other family-related certificates could be found. This is where he may discover the original names of ancestors, who they were, when they got married, if they had children and who these could be, so he can more precisely define the family tree. 

READ ALSO:  What a law from 1912 means for your claim for Italian citizenship via ancestry

“When you get to digging into centuries-old religious documents, the hard part about dealing with churches and parishes is you need to interface with the priest or the chief of the local parish community, jump through hoops and tons of bureaucracy to get their permission to lay your hands on, and analyse, old documents”. 

“Then, most of these documents are written in Latin, so you either need the priest as translator, or to know Latin yourself”. 

After so many years of ancestry investigations Cardile has learned to read it and continues to hone his Latin language skills.

Find out more about putting together an application for Italian citizenship via ancestry in The Local’s Italian citizenship section.

SHOW COMMENTS