Europe's news in English

COPY LINK

CRIME

Gynaecologist ‘took 35,000 pics of patients’

A German gynaecologist has appeared in court accused of taking more than 35,000 photos of his patients on a secret camera - while he was examining them. He faces ten charges of sexual abuse and more than 1,400 counts of gross invasion of privacy.

Published: 5 September 2013 16:35 CEST

Gynaecologist 'took 35,000 pics of patients'

The accused in court. Photo: DPA

“I am ashamed,” the 58-year-old doctor told the court in Frankenthal near Mannheim in Rhineland-Palatinate on Thursday. He spoke of a dark side to him, being unable to explain his actions over three years in any other way.

The extraordinary case – the first of such a kind in Germany – came to light only in 2011 after the doctor’s medical assistants became suspicious, noticing that he always opened and closed a drawer before a patient came into his examination room.

The drawer was not normally used for anything – and was usually empty when the assistants looked inside – until one day one of them found a digital camera inside.

“That really shocked us,” one of the assistants told the court. She found a photo on the camera of a patient in examination position on the gynaecological chair. This prompted her to go to the police.

Officers found 36,146 such photos, as well as 62 videos, the Welt newspaper reported. He is being charged with more than 1,400 counts of gross invasion of privacy and ten of sexual abuse – accused of conducting vaginal examinations for his own sexual arousal rather than for medical reasons.

He told the court that he had not intended to offend, injure or damage anyone. The case continues.

DPA/The Local/hc

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.

Become a Member to leave a comment.

Klinik-Atlas: How to use Germany's new hospital comparison portal

Whether you’re a foreign resident or a local, it can be tricky to navigate hospital care in Germany.

Now the German government has launched a new nationwide ‘Klinik-Atlas’ aimed at making it easier for people to compare different services in hospitals.

If a patient needs care at a hospital or clinic, such as a knee operation, cancer treatment or to get their tonsils out, they can look through the state-run comparison portal to compare the services offered and their quality. The portal is intended to help patients make a decision on where they want to access care.

It was launched on Friday May 17th and so far includes details on 1,700 hospitals throughout the country.

Why has the Klinik-Atlas been launched?

The German government believed there was a need to get more information on hospitals out there to the public.

Health Minister Karl Lauterbach, of the Social Democrats (SPD), said comprehensive information on how to find good care is now more accessible to everyone with the new portal.

He said that transparency was needed in view of the 16 million hospital treatments that take place in Germany per year and the 500,000 new cancer patients per year alone. Most patients are unsure which clinic or hospital is best suited for their treatment, he added.

Compared to existing information portals, the Klinik-Atlas is particularly unique in the way it prepares data for patients, Lauterbach said: “With just a few clicks, they can compare clinics and find the best clinic in their area for the treatment they need.”

READ ALSO: Which of Germany’s hospitals are among the ‘world’s best’?

Patients can see and assess hospitals side by side instead of having to “hop from clinic to clinic”, added Lauterbach. He called it “clear guide” to help people sift through the maze of health care.

However, there’s been a mixed reception to the project, with hospitals raising some concerns.

How does it work exactly?

One thing to keep in mind is that the site, which is located at www.bundes-klinik-atlas.de, is only in German, but it is fairly simple to use.

– On the site you can see a map with all the clinics in your area, as well as the number of beds they have and treatments they offer. Each clinic is scored on the quality of its care. The score is based on the number of patients per nurse, taking into account the severity of the cases. Lower values equate better scores in this case.

A sign at a Charité Campus points to the Central Emergency Department.

A sign at the Berlin Charité points to the Central Emergency Department. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Sebastian Gollnow

– You can also enter your place of residence and an illness or a very specific treatment in the portal. The system offers search suggestions if you don’t know the specialised term. According to the ministry, 28,000 treatment and 13,000 disease definitions are stored.

– There is a kind of speedometer display to help patients categorise their cases. The ‘faster’ you go, so to speak, i.e. the further the needle moves to the right, the better. For the time being, there are two speedometers – for the number of annual cases of a treatment and for the number of nursing staff in the hospital. The speedometers have five coloured elements to which the needle can point – from ‘very few’ to ‘very many’ cases, for example.

What else can you find out?

A comparison shows that there are “huge differences within a very small area”, said Lauterbach. For example, there are 48 hospitals in Berlin and the surrounding area that perform bowel cancer operations, but only 18 of them are certified as specialist centres.

In the case of severe bowel disease in children, there are clinics that perform more than 70 operations a year, while others only perform four.

It is not the case that large clinics are automatically always ‘the winners’. There are also small clinics that are extremely specialised.

The portal is to receive its first update in a few weeks’ time and will then include complication rates for treatments. Figures on the number of specialised doctors will follow.

The information will be updated regularly, according to the Institute for Quality and Transparency in Healthcare, which is coordinating the implementation. At the moment the data is lagging, featuring case numbers from 2022. The information comes from several sources, including clinics and health insurance company invoices.

READ ALSO: How could Germany solve its worsening GP crisis?

How’s the reaction so far?

According to the ministry, there were more than five million hits in the first three hours of the comparison launching, with some page views also experiencing a brief hitch due to the volume of traffic.

But not everyone is for it. The German Hospital Federation said the portal does not provide patients with any additional information and even adds more bureaucracy to hospitals’ workloads. The hospital sector recently expanded its own online overview portal. The ‘Deutschen Krankenhaus Verzeichnis’ or ‘German Hospital Directory’, which has existed since 2002, was updated to include more search functions.

The German Patient Protection Foundation said that people want to know about the range of services and quality. “But the ‘hospital atlas’ lacks crucial information,” said CEO Eugen Brysch. “The quality of patient management in the clinic is not recorded.”

The German Social Association welcomed the comparison site, but added: “It remains to be seen how great the added value for patients really is.”

READ ALSO: How Germany is planning to save its ailing hospitals

Url copied to clipboard!