SHARE
COPY LINK

HEALTH CARE

‘It’s not too late to fix Spain’s health system’

Drastic cuts to health-care spending in Spain threaten the fabric of one of the world’s best medical systems, the authors of a new study in the prestigious British Medical Journal argue.

'It's not too late to fix Spain's health system'
Doctors attend a demonstration against spending cuts to heath care in Spain in February 2012 in Valladolid. Photo: Cesar Manso/AFP

Spain’s health and social services budget was cut by nearly 14 percent in 2012 —  part of a drive by Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy's government to squeeze €150 billion out of the country's budget by 2014.

But the savings drive has taken a large toll in Spain, the new study in the British Medical Journal (BMJ) argues.

"I decided to conduct the research about Spain after I came across a study by Martin McKee looking at the situation in Greece," lead study author Dr Helena Legido-Quigley told The Local.

"That study showed that HIV and tuberculous rates were going up because of the crisis there, and I wanted to know what was happening in Spain," the researcher explained.

Legido-Quigley, a lecturer in Global Health at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine said the research process for the British Medical Journal (BMJ) paper had been difficult.

"There was one study about Spain compared depression rates in 2006 and then again in 2010–2011 and found that these had gone up by almost 20 percent."

Another study by police in Catalonia showed  a ten-percent increase in suicides in the same period.

"But almost nobody is doing research in this area," Legido-Quigley told The Local.

"Then there is the fact that the cuts and the crisis came later in Spain (than in Greece), so we have to wait two years or so to get a real picture of what is happening in the country."

As a result, the BMJ study is "quite descriptive. It says what is happening now".

The report looks at three key aspects of health-care changes in Spain including the end of universal coverage in 2012, co-payments for medicines and the impact of privatization of hospitals.

The authors argue that while it is too early to properly assess the impact of the push for private hospitals in Madrid and Catalonia, there is evidence of increases in waiting times, cutbacks in emergency services and fewer surgical procedures.

Meanwhile, so-called co-payments for medicines — where patients contribute towards the costs of drugs — have been introduced across the board, and even been extended to include items such as prosthetics, dietary products and non-urgent ambulance journeys.

Finally, there is the end to universal health care that came in the wake of Royal Decree 16/2012.

That decree saw several hundred thousand undocumented adult migrants shut out from all but emergency and prenatal health care.

"Before this Royal Decree, Spain had universal health care, and it was something we were very proud of," Legido-Quigley told The Local.

"Now it is gone."

As part of their research, the study authors also spoke to health-care professionals in Catalonia.

Many reported feeling "shocked", "numbed" and "disillusioned" about the cuts and expressed fears that "the cuts are going to kill people".

"I was very surprised when I spoke to these people," Legido-Quigley explained.

"They didn’t seem to have any answers for the problem, and I believe that’s because they lack information about the changes."

The study’s chief author has a more pressing question though.

"Spain has a very cheap health care system with one of the best outcomes in terms of health. Public spending on health is only seven percent of GDP against an average of 7.6 percent in the European Union.

Everybody is happy with the system. So why change it during a crisis?"

But the BMJ study author says it is not too late to turn the tide: "Corrective measures can still be introduced in Spain."

The BMJ report has already received criticism from within the Spanish government, with sources within the health ministry saying Spain’s tuberculous rate actually fell by 29 percent in 2012.

Legido-Quigley counters this, however, by saying the BMJ analysis does not argue tuberculous rate have increased.

Instead, the BMJ study simply warns this is one possible consequence of the cuts to health spending in Spain.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

HOSPITALS

Covid-19: How Swiss hospitals are preparing for influx of new patients

As infection rates are skyrocketing in Switzerland, hospitals in various regions are implementing new measures to handle hospitalisations linked to the resurgence of coronavirus.

Covid-19: How Swiss hospitals are preparing for influx of new patients
CHUV in Lausanne is one of Swiss hospitals ready to treat coronavirus patients. Photo by AFP

There has been a sharp increase in the number of cases reported in Switzerland this week, almost quadrupling the highest number of infections recorded previously. 

“The second wave has come earlier and stronger than we thought,” Health Minister Alain Berset said. 

The number of hospitalisations has been soaring as well – in the past 14 days, the number of people admitted to hospital due to coronavirus complications went up  from 177 to 622, according to Federal Office of Public Health (FOPH). 

During the peak of the pandemic in March and April, the Swiss health care sector was not overwhelmed, having had sufficient resources to treat all patients needing coronavirus-related care.

In fact, Swiss hospitals took in 30 coronavirus patients from France, especially from Franche-Comté and Grand Est regions, whose medical facilities were saturated. 

What is the situation now?

The first thing to know is that capacities of intensive care units, where most urgent Covid-19 patients are treated, vary from one canton to another.

The preparedness level may not be the same in cantons which don’t have large university hospitals with extensive resources and capacities.

To get prepared to handle the new onslaught of patients, hospitals must know how they can increase their capacities quickly.

To answer these questions, a team of researchers from the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich (ETHZ) developed a monitoring system which forecasts over seven days the influx of patients, predicts needs, and redirects patients to other medical establishments.

The system focuses on intensive care units, where there are fewer beds but where more staff and equipment is needed.

This is the current situation in some parts of Switzerland:

Geneva

Geneva’s University Hospitals (HUG) estimate that the second wave of Covid-19 will be at least as serious as the spring outbreak. Between October 15th and 20th, the number of coronavirus patients has more than doubled to 169 people, 20 of whom are in intensive and intermediate care. 

“We are very worried,” Geneva’s State Council President Anne Emery-Torracinta said.

The HUG has now been transformed into a hospital dedicated exclusively to Covid-19, as it was in the spring. This means that only urgent surgeries are maintained; non-essential interventions are suspended. Additionally, post-operative facilities will now be used as Covid units.

And as was the case in the spring, private clinics have been mobilised to treat coronavirus patients, relieving the pressure on public hospitals. 

READ MORE: Swiss sound the alarm as coronavirus cases double Swiss sound the alarm as coronavirus cases double

Vaud

The number of patients is increasing rapidly in the intensive care unit of Lausanne’s University Hospital (CHUV), doubling in just one week.

CHUV’s director Philippe Eckert said the hospital had and still has space to accommodate additional patients, including 12 intensive care beds. And it is already preparing additional infrastructure “that may be needed very soon”.

“We will probably have to reduce certain activities from next week to free up employees,” Eckert said.

“We anticipated this wave. We are ready,” he added.

Fribourg

“The number of infected people has increased from 13 to 60 in ten days,” the hospital spokesperson said.

Five Covid patients, including three on respirators, are now in the intensive care unit, against one 10 days ago.

Valais

The canton, which has recorded a significant increase in the number of infections, is also getting prepared for the onslaught of patients.

According to Eric Bonvin, head of the Valais Hospital, “we are experiencing an increase in the number of hospitalisations linked to complications from Covid — 90 people, including six in intensive care”. 

The hospital is not at full capacity at the moment, but in a “critical” situation” nevertheless, Bonvin added. 

SHOW COMMENTS