SHARE
COPY LINK

MAN

MAN hoovers market for Scania shares

German industrial conglomerate MAN turned up the heat on Scania on Thursday by buying shares in the Swedish truck maker amid press reports that Volkswagen supports the German group in pursuing a hostile takeover bid.

MAN said in a statement that it had acquired shares representing five percent of Scania’s voting capital after trading had closed on Wednesday, giving it a total voting stake of 10.2 percent.

The shares were acquired at a price of 475 kronor each. And according to Swedish takeover rules, that would mean that MAN would have to revise upwards its overall takeover bid, which is currently hostile, to reflect that higher price, the German group said.

MAN had so far been offering 442 kronor per Scania share. On the basis of the new price, MAN would have to shell out €10.2 billion for all of Scania.

Auto giant Volkswagen, which has truck interests in Brazil, is Scania’s biggest shareholder with a voting stake of 34 percent, but also holds just over 15 percent of MAN.

The off-market purchases by MAN angered Scania, which has so far turned down the German company’s advances.

“According to reports in the market MAN has, in parallel to proposing friendly talks between the two companies, entered the market as an aggressive buyer of high-voting A-shares in Scania,” the Swedish group said in a statement published on its website.

“The board of Scania reiterates its rejection of MAN’s offer as it substantially undervalues Scania.”

On Thursday, Scania reported a 55.0-percent rise in third-quarter net profit to 1.28 billion kronor.

MAN has long been trying to get its hands on Scania, but would prefer to do so via a friendly deal.

In a statement on Monday, the German group said it was prepared to withdraw its hostile bid for Scania under certain conditions, which it did not elaborate on.

But both Scania and its second-biggest shareholder, Investor AB, insist that MAN’s bidding price is too low.

“Having consulted with our financial advisers, we believe that the offer substantially undervalues Scania in two principal respects,” Scania said.

“The earnings outlook for the standalone company is significantly above current market consensus. And MAN’s announced synergies materially underestimate the true synergy potential of a combination of Scania and MAN.”

Investor said that “while there are industrial merits to a combination of the two companies, the initial bid did not at all reflect the long-term value and potential of Scania”.

Investor estimated that “potential synergies in a combination of Scania and MAN are substantially higher than the 500 million euros per year indicated by MAN”.

Scania was “a strong company and well positioned to take advantage of anticipated high growth over the coming years in new markets”, Investor continued.

Volkswagen, also favours a friendly tie-up.

On Monday, VW urged both Scania and MAN to reach a rapid agreement on a tie-up that would create a new leader in Europe’s heavy trucks sector.

VW chief executive Bernd Pischetsrieder gave the two parties four weeks to reach an amicable deal.

But the Financial Times reported Thursday said that VW was losing patience with Scania and Investor over their refusal to talk.

And VW was prepared to back an attempt by MAN to buy up to 16 percent of Scania in a move that would give VW and MAN a combined majority stake, the newspaper said.

On the Frankfurt stock exchange, MAN shares were showing a gain of €1.09 or 1.62 percent at €68.43, making it the biggest gainer of the morning.

VW

Five things to know about Germany’s ‘dieselgate’ scandal

The emissions cheating scandal, which on Tuesday saw three Volkswagen chiefs charged and its rival Daimler heavily fined, has had major repercussions for the car industry since it broke four years ago.

Five things to know about Germany's 'dieselgate' scandal

Exposed in 2015

On September 18th, 2015, the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) reported that VW had installed illegal “defeat devices” in hundreds of thousands of engines in the United States since 2009.

The software — used in the Volkswagen, Porsche, Audi, Seat and Skoda brands — helped the cars meet exhaust pollution standards when monitored in tests even though their emissions actually exceeded the limits.

It meant that some cars spewed out up to 40 times more harmful nitrogen oxide — linked to respiratory and cardiovascular diseases — than legally allowed.

The company later admitted that 11 million diesel vehicles worldwide, including 8.5 million in Europe and 600,000 in the United States, had been fitted with the software, most of them in the VW brand.

SEE ALSO: 'Dieselgate': German prosecutors charge former Audi boss with fraud

Legal fall-out

VW chief executive Martin Winterkorn, who stepped down five days after the scandal broke, was in April 2019 charged with serious fraud, unfair competition and breach of trust.

Eight former and current executives and an Audi official have been charged in the United States, including Winterkorn.

Audi chief executive Rupert Stadler was charged in July 2019 with fraud, falsifying certifications and illegal advertising in connection with the “defeat devices”.

Former Audi head Rupert Stadler at a press briefing in 2018.

VW's guilty plea to a US criminal case in March 2017 settled its legal entanglements there, bringing to around $22 billion the amount it agreed to pay in fines and compensation to owners and dealers and for environmental clean-up.

The group still faces investigations and lawsuits around the world, in Europe the countries include Britain, France, Germany, Italy and Poland.

Costs for VW

The scandal has so far cost VW around 30 billion in fines, compensation and buybacks, mainly in the United States.

The company announced a net loss of nearly €1.6 billion in 2015, its first in 20 years, after setting aside billions to cover the costs of the dieselgate.

In June 2018 it agreed to pay a 1 billion fine in Germany, admitting its responsibility for the diesel crisis.

Audi agreed in October 2018 to pay an 800 million fine and Porsche was in May 2019 ordered to pay a fine of 535 million.

Other carmakers?

Tests in the wake of the scandal found that diesel engines by other carmakers were also more polluting on the road than during testing.

But none have so far admitted to mass cheating.

However Mercedes-Benz maker Daimler was in June 2018 ordered to recall 774,000 diesel vehicles across Europe because they too were fitted with illegal “defeat devices”.

Fiat Chrysler agreed in January 2019 to a pay $515 million to settle claims it installed the software.

And in February 2019 German prosecutors fined high-end carmaker BMW 8.5 million euros over diesel cars with higher harmful emissions than allowed, though they found no criminal wrong-doing.

Opel is also being investigated.


A worker holds up a Volkswagen badge at the VW plant in Wolfsburg. Image: DPA

Market reaction

A study released in March 2017 said that pollution from 2.6 million rigged VW cars sold in Germany would likely cause 1,200 premature deaths in Europe because of the excess emissions.

In Germany more than 410,000 customers are demanding compensation, as are
investors.

More generally, European drivers appear to have largely shrugged off the controversy while VW sales have fallen in the United States.

VW said in July 2019 it expects “slightly higher” unit sales for the year than in 2018.

SEE ALSO: VW sees steady profits in 2018 results

SHOW COMMENTS