SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

JOHN LICHFIELD

OPINION: Beauty of the Paris Olympics will be remembered long after the fake Last Supper

The Olympic games traditionally end with a marathon, writes John Lichfield. The Paris Olympics started with two marathons, one of which, it appears, will go on forever.

OPINION: Beauty of the Paris Olympics will be remembered long after the fake Last Supper
Britain's Alex Yee winning the men's individual triathlon at the Paris 2024 Olympic Games in central Paris on July 31, 2024. Photo by Andrej ISAKOVIC / AFP

The first marathon was the four-hour opening ceremony. Did it really have to go for so long? Much of it was wonderful; parts of it were dull; other parts were wilful and ridiculous. The ending was extraordinary.

There I have said it. It is possible to have mixed feelings about the opening ceremony of the Paris Olympics. To turn the whole of the centre of the world’s most beautiful city into a live television set was an act of extreme daring.

Despite the worst rain ever to fall in Paris in late July, the creators and organisers triumphed, up to a point.

But the script needed an editor. It needed to be shorter. It needed to be sown together better. Why did the mystery torch bearer, who seemed to be the main thread of the narrative, simply vanish at the end?

 Some of the set-piece scenes – such as the duet between the band of the Republican Guard and the Franco-Malian singer Aya Nakamura – were a tour de force. Others were limp and obscure.

READ ALSO How many of the French references in the opening ceremony did you get?

The creators wanted a ceremony that was inclusive and represented to the world the many tribes of 21st century France. Much of the ceremony did that well.

At times it spilled into a self-regarding, anti-establishment and Paris-centric vision of France which meant little to people outside the Boulevard Périphérique, let alone the rest of the world.

The second pre-Olympics marathon – the controversy started by one section of the opening ceremony – is still going on five days later. Some Christians, and especially the Performative Political Christians of the United States, were offended by a tableau of the Last Supper which portrayed Christ’s disciples as drag queens and Jesus as a female disc-jockey.

The Catholic church in France objected. The French traditional Right and parts of the Far Right objected. So did Vladimir Putin. So did the Iranian mullahs. The pro-Donald Trump, Christian Right in the United States said that the tableau was not just “woke” but “evil” – an example of devil-worship.

READ ALSO Paris mayor tells Donald Trump ‘you don’t frighten us’

I would say that evangelical Christian support for Donald Trump is a more disturbing act of devil-worship than anything remotely attempted by the Paris Olympics ceremony.

It took two days for the facts to be established. The tableau did NOT represent the last supper. The artistic director of the ceremony Thomas Jolly said that his intention was to show a Bacchanalian orgy, part of the Greek pagan rites from which the original Olympic games emerged.

The facts are on Jolly’s side. There were 13 characters sitting behind the feast table, rather than eleven (ie ten disciples and Jesus). No artistic representation of the Last Supper includes – as the Olympics’ tableau did – a man painted blue and dressed marginally in fruit. He was the singer Philippe Katerine, playing Dionysus, aka Bacchus, the Greek-Roman God of wine-making, fruit, festivity, ritual ecstasy and fun generally.

Two problems remain, however. Firstly, many classic representations of Bacchanalian feasts resemble Leonardo da Vinci’s painting of The Last Supper. It took two days for Thomas Jolly to set the record straight.

By that time, the Olympic organisers had “apologised for any offence caused” without pointing out that the scene did NOT represent Jesus and his disciples. Thomas Jolly insisted that he meant no offence but he must have been aware that the tableau would remind more viewers of the Last Supper than the rites of Dionysus.

How many people in a global audience of billions said: “oh yes, the naked blue man must be Dionysus and the drag queens represent, er, ancient Greek rituals”.

The similarity was, I believe, intended to be part of the joke. The tableau of the Last Supper was NOT the last supper but, in a sense, it was the Last Supper.  

Was that a mistake? Leonardo’s portrait of Jesus and disciples has been parodied a thousand time, including by The Simpsons and by Trump supporters portraying Trump as Jesus.

I see nothing very wrong in the Bacchanalian tableau. But I can understand why some people were offended. It was a clever, or clumsy, attempt to be make a complex joke in a complex world that does not take easily to complexity.  

Real anger abates eventually. Synthetic, political anger lasts forever. American Christian Conservatives – few of whom probably saw the opening ceremony – cherish their fury. They won’t let go easily.

Most of the rest of the world has moved on. The beauty of the Paris Olympics, the first to be held in the centre of a city, has taken gold, silver and bronze.

READ ALSO Are the Paris Olympics doing the unthinkable and making the French happy?

Grinches and naysayers, myself included, doubted whether the concept of a city-stadium could work. The British media mocked the plans to hold the swimming part of the triathlon in the river Seine until the day that it happened.

The images were breath-taking. The memory of swimmers, cyclists and runners – but also volley-ball players, trick-cyclists and basketballers – competing in the heart of the world’s most beautiful capital  will be the lasting legacy of these games, not the faux Last Supper.

How can Los Angeles 2028 compete with that?

Member comments

  1. Excellent synopsis. I loved every minute of this Parisian Olympic Performance. However, I agree a little editing here and there could tighten it up. Perhaps providing the media a script for talking points as the show unfolded would have helped the audience understand what was being conveyed. Still it was magnificent 🇫🇷

  2. The Bible says, “Good sense makes one slow to anger, and it is to his glory to overlook an offence.” Proverbs 19:11, ESV. The self-righteous, having a shorter fuse, are easily offended. Christians are well-advised to rise above the offence, and turn the other cheek.

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

PARIS 2024 OLYMPICS

French cabbies seek payout for lost Olympics revenue

French taxi drivers on Thursday demanded government compensation for lost revenue during the Olympic Games as traffic disruptions and fewer regular clients weigh on demand.

French cabbies seek payout for lost Olympics revenue

In a letter to the transport ministry, taxi unions said that the Games had been “hugely disappointing” for the drivers of licenced taxis of which there are 20,000 in Paris alone.

“Demand is slowing and the entire profession is being prevented from simply doing their job because of these Games,” said the letter, seen by AFP.

The number of additional visitors drawn by the Olympics had failed to make up for “the impact of traffic restrictions, the closure of venues and the impact of usual customers staying away”, it said.

The unions demanded the creation of a “compensation fund” that they said should cover income lost for the seven-month period during which public spaces were being taken over for the Games.

Several venues in and around Paris, but also in Marseille were blocked off for several weeks before the Games started on July 26th.

The government has encouraged French residents to go on holiday or work remotely during the Games, further dampening demand and contributing to a sharp fall in business compared to the same period in 2023, the unions said.

Some drivers had seen their income fall by 40 or 50 percent, they said.

Last month, trade groups said that Paris shops, restaurants, bars and clubs were facing an “unprecedented slump in business and footfall”, blaming in part the “heavy security measures” during the Games.

SHOW COMMENTS