SHARE
COPY LINK

HEALTH

How Germany plans to revamp emergency healthcare services

Germany’s emergency rooms are often overcrowded, especially on nights and weekends. How does the government plan to reform the system - and what should you do in an emergency?

central emergency department sign
Sign reads “Central Emergency Department” on the floor near the entrance of Marienkrankenhaus in Hamburg. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Christian Charisius

The federal cabinet adopted a draft law presented by Health Minister Karl Lauterbach on Wednesday, which is designed to change the way emergency services are accessed by patients.

The plan – which is intended to reduce overloads for doctors, emergency rooms and rescue services – involves the creation of localised control centres and significantly beefing up telephone response services.

Here’s how emergency services are due to be changed.

How will patients’ experience change?

In future, emergency call services are to be expanded with so-called “acute control centres”.

At these centres doctors would advise patients by telephone or video when possible, and refer more urgent cases to emergency facilities. 

Medical emergency calls to 112 or 116117 would be patched through to these acute control centres when applicable. This is intended to reduce the number of emergency responses that are dispatched for minor injuries.

According to the plan, patients referred to a call centre should be able to expect an initial assessment after three minutes in 75 percent of cases.

“Those who can be treated on an outpatient basis with telephone or video-based counselling do not have to go to hospital,” Lauterbach told Tagesschau.

READ ALSO: How could Germany solve its worsening GP crisis?

For cases that turn out not to be urgent, patients may be able to be issued an electronic prescription or sick note.

Additionally, patients with urgent issues should be directed to more specific treatment centres, rather than going straight to the hospital.

The draft law calls for “integrated emergency centres”, many of which may be added to existing medical clinics or hospitals. 

These localised centres would work to offer an initial diagnosis and refer patients, depending on urgency, to the emergency room or other medical facilities services.

This is intended to cut down on wait times in emergency rooms by more quickly redirecting patients to the specific care services they need.

The minister stressed: “In the future, acute care should take place where it makes medical sense.” 

Emergency services are due for a reform

Emergency rooms and services are often running at high-capacity in many parts of Germany.

According to the Ministry of Health, one in three people in an emergency room would be better treated in a specified practice. 

But often patients don’t know what to do when urgent medical issues arise at night or on weekends, so many end up in emergency rooms and hospitals.

However, making a plan for a comprehensive reform and pulling it off are two different things. 

As with so many bold plans in Germany, a serious challenge will be the country’s growing shortage of workers – in this case healthcare workers.

The General Practitioners’ Association has warned that a lack of the necessary staff, and parallel structures between services could lead to the reform’s failure.

The National Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians (KBV) praised the initiative, but also expressed doubts due to a lack of personnel.

Other proposals adopted on Wednesday

Along with the emergency health services reform, several other health ministry proposals have been adopted today. 

Kidney donations between a couple will be possible going forward. 

READ ALSO: The different types of extended leave you can take in Germany

Also a new authority focused on disease prevention – the Federal Institute for Prevention and Education in Medicine (BIPAM) – is to be launched on January 1st, 2025. Parts of the Robert Koch Institute and the Federal Centre for Health Education are to be absorbed into it. 

Finally, gematik, which is Germany’s central platform for digital applications in the healthcare system, is to be expanded into a digital agency.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

HEALTH

Germany considers legalising egg donation

A commission on reproductive rights has said the ban on egg donation should be lifted in Germany, with a draft likely to come before the next election.

Germany considers legalising egg donation

Speaking to DPA on Tuesday, Justice Minister Marco Buschmann (FDP) said he believed a proposal for legalising egg donation would enter the Bundestag next year before Germany’s next federal elections in autumn of 2025.

Donated eggs are used in fertility treatments for women who are otherwise unable to conceive.  

Though the coalition agreement between the Social Democrats (SPD), Greens and Free Democrats (FDP) did not commit to lifting the ban on egg donation specifically, the parties did say they planned to consider the issue.

“We are setting up a commission on reproductive self-determination and reproductive medicine, which will examine regulations for abortion outside of the Criminal Code as well as options for legalising egg donation and altruistic surrogacy,” the 2021 agreement stated. 

READ ALSO: Germany debates legalizing egg donations and surrogacy

In April this year, the commission issued its recommendations, stating that there were “no overriding medical or psychological risks that speak against legalisation”.

The expert panel also recommending following the example of other European countries where this type of fertility treatment was legal.

Germany is one of only four countries in central and western Europe where donating eggs is illegal.

“From my personal point of view, there are good reasons to lift the categorical ban on egg donation in Germany,” Buschmann explained.

Abortion debate

Despite the progress in fertility treatments, the FDP politician does not expect a quick agreement on the reform of the abortion paragraph 218 in the penal code, which effectively criminalises abortion. 

“Abortion raises particularly difficult constitutional issues,” Buschmann told DPA, adding that the topic was a divisive one.

“I see much more consensus on egg donation. Authorising egg donation would be compatible with the Basic Law.”

Abortion remains an illegal act in Germany, though it is exempt from punishment if it carried out in the first three months of pregnancy and after counselling.

Justice Minister Marco Buschmann (FDP)

Justice Minister Marco Buschmann (FDP) gives an interview to DPA on February 3rd. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Michael Kappeler

Pro-choice activists have been campaigning for this to be overturned for years, but face stiff opposition from religious figures and conservative politicians.

After entering government back in 2021, the traffic-light coalition swiftly scrapped paragraph 219a in the Criminal Code, which banned doctors from publicly providing information on abortion.  

The expert commission has since suggested that abortions in the early stages of pregnancy should no longer be criminalised and questioned the obligation for women to undergo counselling.

READ ALSO: Will abortion in Germany soon become legal?

If a bill on egg donation comes to the Bundestag this year or next, it will likely follow the panel’s recommendations of forbidding the trade of egg cells for financial gain, as well as a regulation ensuring that children retain the right to know their parentage. 

It is also likely to follow the Bundestag’s tradition of tackling questions of legal ethics in a non-partisan way, with parliament putting forward proposals rather than the government.

SHOW COMMENTS