SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

SPANISH LAW

Why Spain’s law to ban spam calls has failed

A year after legislation was passed to prevent companies making unwanted spam calls to people (including steep fines for offenders) many in Spain are still receiving them.

Why Spain's law to ban spam calls has failed
People are still receiving cold calls in Spain despite a law that banned them. Photo: Alex Green/Pexels

A year has passed since the Spanish government brought in legislation to try and stop spam calls, but for many in Spain these infuriating marketing and advertising cold calls continue.

“The reality is that calls are just as if not more intense than before this regulation,” Samuel Parra, a technology law specialist, said recently in the Spanish press.

Data from Spain’s main consumer watchdog, Organización de Consumidores y Usuarios (OCU), backs this up. It reports that nine out of ten consumers in Spain continue to receive these spam calls despite the change in the law.

READ ALSO: Spain’s ban on spam calls to come into force on June 29th

Facua, another consumer group, reports that 4.1 percent of people still receive more than five calls a month, 8.2 percent receive four, 12.5 percent receive three, and 9.7 percent receive at least two.

The main objective of the Telecommunications Law, passed in June 2023, was to stop the abundance of spam calls, which in Spain are particularly bad and are usually commercial sales calls trying to sell you something. However, the reality is that, after being in force for a year, many Spaniards are still receiving these sorts of spam calls.

Almudena Velázquez, a consumer affairs lawyer, told Spanish state broadcaster TVE that companies bypass (and at times break) the law by using a so-called ‘legitimate interest’ that allows companies to offer similar products to those the consumer already has.

For example, if you’ve recently taken out a loan, they could reasonably try and sell you a credit card via a cold call.

Experts say this due to companies exploiting data protection rules. Specifically, Article 6 of Spain’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) allows for the use of personal data, such as telephone numbers, when there is a justifiable ‘legitimate interest’ of the company.

Ileana Izvernicveanu, spokesperson for the OCU, described this concept as a “no man’s land”. In other words, spam phone call companies are exploiting a legal grey area in order to continue with their sales calls.

Another possible explanation, the OCU warns, is that consumers themselves have unwillingly or unknowingly consented to receive these spam calls by giving away their personal data through other means, whether online or when purchasing products.

You can remove your consent by registering on the Robinson List, a free advertising exclusion system in Spain.

Spain’s Telecommunications Law also pledged to open legal proceedings against any company which makes spam calls, regardless of whether the call centre is based in Spain or overseas. It’s unclear if this has happened yet.

Other legislation introduced in 2022 also prohibited cold calling before 9am and after 9m, as well as at weekends or on public holidays. Spain’s main phone and internet providers also committed to not calling phone users between 3pm and 4pm, ‘siesta time’ in Spain.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

TECH

Spanish prosecutors investigate Meta over data use for AI

Spanish prosecutors said Thursday that they were investigating Facebook owner Meta over suspicions it breached data-protection laws by using users' data to train its AI programme.

Spanish prosecutors investigate Meta over data use for AI

Meta had already said last month it was suspending the use of such data for training its generative artificial intelligence service in the European Union, following complaints in 11 countries.

State prosecutors at Spain’s main national court said in a statement they had received “massive” numbers of complaints over the issue from users of Facebook and Instagram, another popular social media platform owned by Meta.

The users complained “that information shared in its products and services… is going to be used by Meta to develop and improve its AI”, the statement said.

It added that prosecutors were seeking to protect users’ “personal data” and would consult the Spanish data-protection authority about possible measures.

SHOW COMMENTS