SHARE
COPY LINK

TAXES

German government clashes over Finance Minister’s tax relief plans

Finance Minister Christian Lindner has been slammed over his proposals to cut taxes in Germany, with his coalition partners saying they benefit the wealthy.

cash payment
Photo: Markus Spikse/Unsplash

Lindner, of the pro-business Free Democrats (FDP), said he wants to offset the effects of high inflation and provide taxpayers with relief totalling around €23 billion over the next three years. 

The plan is to adjust wage and income tax in three stages by 2026, Lindner said during a presentation in Berlin on Wednesday. “It is simply a matter of fairness to adjust the tax system to inflation. The state must not be the winner of inflation.”

Lindner wants to gradually increase the tax-free allowance, up to which no tax is paid by earners, to €12,336 by 2026, including a backdated increase of €180 to €11,784 this year.

The next step would come into force from January 2025 when the basic tax-free allowance would rise by a further €300 to €12,084.

READ ALSO: 8 unlikely tax breaks in Germany that international residents need to know

In his plans, Lindner argued that this would provide a saving to taxpayers of €2 million in total – and would be a signal of support to working people after unemployment benefits – or Bürgergeld – were increased due to inflation.

The FDP politician also said he wanted to combat cold progression – a phenomenon where pay increases are eaten up by inflation but taxed at a higher amount – by raising the threshold for paying the top rate of tax to €69,798 per year in 2026.

German Finance Minister Christian Lindner (FDP) at an event in Berlin on June 15th.

German Finance Minister Christian Lindner (FDP) at an event in Berlin on June 15th. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Michael Kappeler

However, it comes as the German government is having to make tough budget choices and savings. And there is currently still a financing gap of around €25 billion in the German government’s budget plans for the coming year.

Despite the high costs of his tax relief plan, the FDP leader does not see the current budget discussions being jeopardised: “If the coalition strengthens economic growth with bold impulses”, sources close to the minister said. 

The FDP’s coalition partners – the Greens and Social Democrats (SPD) – have hit back, arguing the plans will primarily help those who are better off at a time when budgets are tight. 

“You can’t demand drastic savings from other departments…and then demand tens of billions yourself without need,” Green Party finance expert Katharina Beck told Reuters.

“In view of necessary investments in defence, it is dubious to bring tax cuts in the double-digit billion range into play,” Beck said, adding that the rich would benefit most from the reduced tax burden.

Michael Schrodi, financial policy spokesman for the SPD parliamentary group, expressed a similar view, saying that social security should take priority — rather than providing tax relief for top earners. 

In the last months, more cracks have been showing in the coalition government, which is led by the SPD, as junior partner – the Free Democrats – has been pushing for changes to spending and cuts to social security.  

READ ALSO: Why a push for tougher benefit sanctions in Germany is sparking a dispute

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

DRUGS

Is Germany ready for the arrival of cannabis clubs?

The second part of Germany's cannabis legalisation law, which allows for the launch of cannabis clubs comes into effect on July 1st. But a number of questions may leave club founders stalled for months.

Is Germany ready for the arrival of cannabis clubs?

From July 1st, the next phase of the cannabis law will come into force, which allows for the founding of “cannabis clubs” in Germany.

But the law, as it stands, is creating more questions than answers for many cannabis club founders across the country.

Questions around which authorities are responsible for approving clubs or regulating their activities remain.

Investors and club organisers are also unsure how quickly legal approval will be granted, with some speculating that operations may not legally begin until 2025.

Cannabis clubs to open from Monday (in theory)

According to the federal law, cannabis clubs may start their activities as soon as July 1st. 

These regulated associations will be allowed to have up to 500 members each, and will be able to grow and distribute up to 50 grams of cannabis per person per month.

But the reality is that cannabis clubs can submit an application for approval on July 1st, and then must wait for a permit to be granted before they can begin cultivating cannabis.

The health policy spokeswoman for the FDP, Susanne Schneider, criticised what she sees as unnecessary delays to rolling out the new rules. She told the Rheinische Post, “Although applications can be submitted from July 1st, it is completely unclear when permits will be granted and cannabis will actually be available – that could take months,” 

According to the cannabis legalisation law, the regulating authorities have a maximum of three months to approve or deny a club’s application. 

But depending on which region a club is in, there are still open questions about how and to whom applications should be submitted.

Cannabis regulation to be governed regionally

Adding to the confusion is the fact that these kinds of regulations are determined by state government agencies in Germany.

According to the law, district governments, state agencies for nature, environment and consumer protection, and the chambers of agriculture will be responsible for monitoring clubs and enforcing rules for cultivation and distribution of cannabis. 

But it’s not clear in every case where a cannabis club organiser should send an application. 

In Brandenburg, applications will be reviewed by the state’s Office for Occupational Safety, Consumer Protection and Health (LAVG), but according to reporting by Berliner Zeitung, the relevant authority in Berlin is still unknown.

cannabis

Cannabis clubs with up to 500 members may soon cultivate and distribute cannabis in Germany. Photo: picture alliance/dpa/SOPA Images via ZUMA Press Wire | Nathalie Jamois

Sascha Siebenäuger, Chairman of Sieben25 (a cannabis club to-be), suggests that information has been sparse but he doesn’t blame the authorities. 

Speaking to Berliner Zeitung, Siebenäuger noted that there are no existing models for fair and regulated cannabis distribution in Germany. With that in mind he expected some bumps in the road: “The task of the clubs to come to terms flexibly with the authorities,” he said. “The focus is on controlled dispensing whenever it becomes reality.”

Due to uncertainties around the process of registering as a club, Siebenäuger hasn’t opened up membership to the general public yet, despite already having a property lined-up where he intends to cultivate cannabis soon.

But these uncertainties haven’t stopped other clubs from accepting paying members who are eager to sign-up ahead of the expected rush.

Some associations in Munich reportedly received thousands of applicants in April, as legalisation was initially coming into effect in Germany.

What do we know about the coming cannabis clubs?

When exactly cannabis clubs will begin operations is still unclear, but a couple things about them are certain.

Firstly, they can have up to 500 members, and can collect membership fees (collected monthly or annually) to fund club activities. Members need to be German residents who are 18 years or older.

Second, these won’t be smoking clubs – members will not be allowed to smoke weed on the club premises or within 100 metres of their doors. Instead they can be thought of essentially as farming and distribution clubs.

More information about cannabis clubs is compiled and updated by the German Cannabis Social Clubs Association (CSCD).

SHOW COMMENTS