SHARE
COPY LINK

WORKING IN SPAIN

Spain’s Balearics struggle to fill job vacancies due to exorbitant rents

Eye-watering rents are hitting staffing levels in hotels and restaurants on the Balearic Islands as the summer season approaches, with some workers having to stay in caravans and tents as their wages don't cover the price of renting a room.

Spain's Balearics struggle to fill job vacancies due to exorbitant rents
Tourists sit at a restaurant terrace along Palma's Beach in Palma de Mallorca.(Photo by JAIME REINA / AFP)

In 2023, the Balearic Islands welcomed 14.4 million tourists who between them spent €17.2 billion, according to figures from Spain’s National Statistics Institute (INE). The Balearics has long been a popular holiday resort for Spaniards and foreigners alike, particularly among Britons and Germans.

Now the summer season, something that in the Balearics has increased in length over the years, is fast approaching. Yet many hotels, bars and restaurants on the islands are left with thousands of vacancies and struggling to fill jobs, despite the overwhelming tourist demand.

All because rents on the Mediterranean islands are too high for low-paid hospitality workers.

READ ALSO: What will happen to rents in Spain in 2024?

Rental prices in Spain in 2023 were on average 9.4 percent more expensive than the year before, according to data from housing website Idealista. In bigger cities such as Madrid, Barcelona, Valencia and Málaga, that figure is creeping closer to the high-teens and twenties.

In certain parts of the Balearics things are even worse, with the cost of renting an apartment increasing by as much as a fifth year-on-year.

During the high season, two-bedroom flats can cost upwards of €1,600 per month. A double room can cost around €750 from April onwards.

As a result, the army of chefs, bartenders, waiters, cleaners and receptionists needed to power the Balearics through the high tourism season are struggling to find accommodation. There are therefore now thousands of unfilled jobs and hundreds of bars, restaurants and hotels left shorthanded for summer.

The lack of staff in recent years has even caused some restaurants in touristy areas to close their doors for up to two days a week, something that had not happened in previous seasons.

“The situation of the last two years has meant that everyone has learned to get their act together earlier. The housing issue is structural and has no solution today, neither in the short nor in the medium-term. It is an issue that depends on the local government,” María Frontera, president of the Hotel Federation of Mallorca, told El País

Larger hotel chains can soften the impact by giving discounted rooms to their staff, but this isn’t an option for over half (55 percent) of the island’s businesses which have fewer than 100 rooms and can’t afford to give them up.

In Ibiza, where rental prices have skyrocketed in recent years, many job adverts come with offers of accommodation because employers know that it is practically impossible to find workers who can afford a room or apartment in the Balearics for seasonal work, the period when prices increase the most.

Joan Pla, general manager of Blau Hotels, believes that the short-term tourist rental sector has altered the market, resulting in thousands of empty properties that are rented out for only a few months a year during the summer and making it difficult to access long-term rentals, which in turn pushes prices up overall.

“We have a very stable staff, with workers who come from the islands, but there are also rotations and retirements,” Pla told El País.

As a result of the rent increases on the islands, hospitality employers are increasingly looking abroad for staff. “When certain vacancies need to be filled and we have to look for employees abroad, we have gone on missions to Portugal, Holland and Belgium,” Pla added.

Up to 85 percent of new residents settling in the Balearic Islands are foreigners, according to new data from Spain’s National Statistics Institute (INE).

READ ALSO: Nine in ten new residents in Spain’s Balearic Islands are foreign

Local governments on the islands, notably in Palma, have tried to take steps to regulate short-term tourist rentals such as Airbnb. In 2023, the Spanish Supreme Court upheld Palma city council’s policy of banning tourist rentals in apartment buildings in the popular Mallorcan capital.

The increase in short-term accommodation, prices, and foreigners settling on the islands mean that many of the staff needed to support the summer tourist season are unable to find accommodation, which in turn means that employers can’t find employees to fill vacancies.

Faced with the unaffordable prices and the sheer difficulty in finding longer-term accommodation, some staff are taking extreme measures.

Many waiters, barmen and chefs around the islands have been forced to share rooms in shared flats or, in some cases, even live in tents or caravans during the high season.

Some people in Ibiza have even tried to capitalise on the situation by renting out tents for as much as €26 a night

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

DIGITAL NOMADS IN SPAIN

Cafés in Spain on war footing against remote workers dominating space

Bars and cafés in Valencia, Santiago and Barcelona have started to take action against lingering remote workers and digital nomads by cutting off the Wi-Fi during peak hours, with some even banning remote working on their premises.

Cafés in Spain on war footing against remote workers dominating space

Increasingly in recent years, a trend has emerged: someone arrives in a café, orders a coffee, opens his or her laptop and then spends the whole day working without buying anything else.

For many digital nomads and remote workers, it seems spending a couple of euros on a coffee is a fair price for occupying a table for an entire morning or afternoon.

Some might say they are contributing to the local economy and supporting local businesses, but clearly, for a small business owner this isn’t a profitable arrangement, and many are now fighting back.

In Valencia, posters have appeared at some cafés banning remote working during peak hours: 8.30 to 12.30.

One Valencia café owner told La Vanguardia: “Our place is small and between 10 and 11.30 in the morning it’s impossible, we need all the tables.”

Raquel Llanes, boss at the Departure Café in the Raval area of Barcelona, explained to Barcelona Secreta that the situation has gotten out of control: “We’ve had customers who have ordered an espresso and sat for eight hours, people who have asked us to turn the music down so they could have meetings, customers who took out their Tupperware to eat… At first we adapted the space with sockets and to work, but after two years we realised that the numbers weren’t working out.”

Some have opted for less friendly, but equally effective methods: turning off the Wi-Fi network of the premises during peak hours.

“The owner has got rid of the Wi-Fi to avoid precisely these situations. People sat down and didn’t leave,” one waitress told La Vanguardia.

Similar sentiments have arisen in the Galician city of Santiago, where one café owner told La Voz de Galicia: “We prefer them not to come. If someone comes in and opens a laptop we don’t tell them anything, but if they’ve been there for a long time and we need space for a group, we ask them to please move”. 

When a remote worker in Valencia posted a negative comment about a café where the owner had asked him to leave, their reply went viral, as they stated “we can’t lose regular customers so that you can work”. 

Remote working (teletrabajo in Spanish) has exploded in popularity in Spain in recent years, particularly in the post-pandemic period, and often the people taking advantage of this flexibility are foreign digital nomads and remote workers. Many of them choose to work from local bars and cafés.

It should be said that not all people working remotely in Spain are foreigners. Many Spaniards also have flexible or remote working arrangements and will no doubt occasionally work in a local bar or café. Equally, many digital nomads take advantage of the abundance of ‘co-working’ spaces popping up around Spain, which are exactly for this purpose.

There are even café owners who promote the ‘work friendly’ environment as a means of establishing a loyal customer base.

Other hospitality businesses have preferred to allocate an area for remote working while keeping the bar area and certain tables for regular customers who stop by for a quick bite or coffee. 

READ ALSO: The best co-working spaces for digital nomads in Spain

The row over remote working in traditional Spanish bars and cafés is yet another chapter in the current debate over the influence mass tourism and gentrification is having on Spaniards’ standard of living. 

In the increasingly online, post-pandemic world, the change has been stark in some parts of Spain. Take a stroll through the Raval or L’Eixample neighbourhoods of Barcelona, or the Ruzafa and El Cabanyal areas of Valencia in 2024, and you’re likely to see buildings plastered in Airbnb lockboxes and possibly even hear more fluent, non-native English than you do Spanish in certain parts.

Tourists and wealthy remote workers, the logic goes, visit or move to a trendy city they’ve seen on an international ranking, say Málaga or Valencia, which causes rents to rise because landlords in the area convert their properties into short-term tourist rental accommodation to meet the growing demand, which in turn turfs out locals or shuts down local businesses. 

READ ALSO: 

SHOW COMMENTS