SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

SPAIN EXPLAINED

Why so many people in Spain ‘dream’ of becoming civil servants

Why are millions of Spaniards willing to give up their careers and study for years in order to become paper-pushers for the State for the rest of their lives?

Why so many people in Spain 'dream' of becoming civil servants
It’s not that being a funcionario is ‘the dream’, it’s that most other jobs in Spain are disappointing. (Photo by CHRISTOPHE SIMON / AFP)

Call it a willingness to conform, the search for a simpler life, or a lack of entrepreneurial zest; in Spain, many people (some would say ‘too many’) dream of becoming funcionarios (civil servants). 

When 2,000 Spaniards aged 18 to 55 were surveyed in early 2023 on what they thought of being a civil servant in Spain, 74 percent said that becoming one offers a better quality of life.

That same study found that almost seven million Spaniards between those ages had already sat what’s called an oposición, the exam that has to be passed – often with flying colours – to be picked among thousands of other candidates for a civil servant position.

Some oposiciones are harder than others, opositores often spend years studying for them, they may not get chosen but they try for another one, again, and again, often for years, and when they finally get in, they usually put aside their degrees and careers in other fields to join the ranks of Spain’s bureaucratic labyrinth. 

There’s been a figure floating around for some time saying that 75 percent of young people in Spain want to become funcionarios – even Antonio Banderas used it in an interview in 2016 to criticise the lack of entrepreneurship in Spain, arguing that “you can’t form a country like that”. 

READ ALSO: Can foreigners become civil servants in Spain?

Some sources say that figure is incorrect, others that it isn’t. It may be impossible to really determine how many young or adult Spaniards want to work for the State, but what’s undeniable is that for outsiders that analyse Spanish society, there’s certainly a lot more interest in this mundane, average-pay work than in most other countries.

So why is becoming a civil servant ‘the dream’ in Spain?

For starters, job security. It’s practically impossible to be fired. Only 500 funcionarios have been given the boot in Spain since 1996. 

One of them was Spain’s so-called laziest civil servant, who clocked in everyday only to immediately walk out for a decade while being paid €50,000 a year for zero work. 

A law was brought out in 2019 to punish funcionarios whose output is below par, but as so often happens in Spain, there is little evidence that this is being carried out in practice. At worst they’ll be moved to another department. 

Such guarantees of a ‘job for life’ are impossible to offer in any other profession in Spain, particularly given the unstable nature of the country’s economy and its chronically high unemployment.

READ ALSO: Vast majority of new jobs created in Spain are filled by foreigners

Second is the pay. Not fantastic in most cases, but when you combine the impossibility of losing your job with Spain’s relatively low cost of living, earning an average of €2,884 gross a month (2022 figures from Spain’s National Statistics Institute) means many feel they’ll be coasting throughout their working life and into retirement. 

Keep in mind as well that no civil servant will be mileurista, the Spanish word coined to describe the millions of people who scrape by on €1,000 a month.

Thirdly are the job conditions. It may be painfully boring work in many cases but being a funcionario tends to result in having more days of paid holiday leave than average (increasing further as one becomes more senior), the possibility of negotiating flexible hours, clocking out at lunchtime on Fridays, and of course the sacred half an hour coffee break at 11am. 

READ ALSO: What are my rights if I work extra hours in Spain?

In a country known for its employee exploitation in the private sector, where many bosses equate hours behind the desk with productivity, and where extra hours are rarely remunerated, having such rights enshrined – and usually protected by powerful unions – is a huge perk for civil servants.  

Another factor is the abundance of public sector positions. Under the Socialist government of Pedro Sánchez, more posts have been opened and there are now 3.5 million civil servants in the country, representing 17.2 percent of Spain’s workforce in early 2023. Are there not enough jobs advertised on Infojobs for the degree you studied? No problem, sit an oposición, not all of them take years to prepare.

READ ALSO: Spain has fewest job vacancies in EU despite worker shortage

And lastly, there’s the fact that in the eyes of Spanish banks, there’s no one more trustworthy in terms of repayment than a funcionario. Bank managers know civil servants will always have a job and a moderate income with which to pay back loans or mortgages. That’s right, an autónomo (self-employed worker) could be earning twice as much as a Spanish civil servant and have been for several years, but they’ll still be seen as more risky a debtor than the ‘safe as houses’ civil servant. 

READ ALSO: Long hours and little pay – What it’s like to be self-employed in Spain

So all these factors add up to explain why, as mentioned earlier, many Spaniards see a job for the State as equalling a better quality of life. 

After all, many people in Spain work to live, and not the other way around. 

It’s part of the Spanish psyche, perhaps a trait that’s developed from realising that whatever career ambitions they had initially – whether it be moving up in a company or setting up their own business – have been dashed by low pay, exploitation, complicated bureaucracy, high self-employed taxes and a general sense that meritocracy and entrepreneurship aren’t rewarded in Spanish work spheres. 

It’s not that being a funcionario is ‘the dream’, it’s that most other jobs in Spain are disappointing.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

WORKING IN SPAIN

How Spain will allow workers to keep claiming unemployment benefits

Following an agreement with trade unions the Spanish government is seeking to reform unemployment benefits, including paying unemployed people more and allowing some workers who find a job to keep claiming benefits.

How Spain will allow workers to keep claiming unemployment benefits

Spain’s Ministry of Labour signed an agreement with trade union leaders on Wednesday to reform unemployment benefits, known as el paro in Spain.

This comes amid ongoing government attempts to reform unemployment protections in the country. The first proposal was voted down in January in Spain’s Congress of Deputies by right-wing opposition parties the Partido Popular and Vox, as well as far-left, former government coalition member Podemos.

Political pundits in the Spanish press believe this second attempt, especially with the new reforms agreed with unions, will be enough to get Podemos on board and therefore through Congress.

The agreement was made without the input of employers’ groups, however. Among many new measures the deal increases the amount of unemployment payment available, broadens the groups that benefit it and even makes it possible to claim unemployment benefits while in work for a short period.

“This is not a little payment, this is a right,” said Spain’s Labour Minister, Yolanda Díaz, at the signing ceremony together with the general secretaries of Spain’s two major trade unions, the CCOO and UGT. The reform, Díaz stated, is intended to help “the lives of those who are having the hardest time” in Spanish society. The reforms were a requirement for Spain to receive its next tranche of European funds.

The key reforms

Benefit increase

Unemployment benefits are being increased. Like with other types of state aid, it is calculated as a percentage of the public indicator of multiple effects income (IPREM).

The draft bill raises the amount to 95 percent of the IPREM in the first six months (around €570 per month) and to 90 percent (€540 per month) in the following six months and, finally, maintains the current 80 percent (€480 per month) or the period thereafter.

Another important change is that the benefit will be the same whether the applicant was previously in part-time or full-time work, something intended to benefit women because the majority in part-time work in Spain are women.

Benefits become compatible with employment

Perhaps the most eye-catching aspect of the draft reform is that it is now technically possible to be both claiming el paro and be employed if you earn less than €1,350 gross per month.

By making the two compatible, it will be possible to receive a salary and unemployment benefit for a maximum of 180 days (6 months), regardless of whether the employment is full-time or part-time. In practice, this will be only available to those who have previously worked and paid taxes for three and half years.

The aim of the work and benefits compatibility, sources from the Labour Ministry say, is to encourage workers’ reintroduction into the labour market.

The amount of unemployment aid will depend on the length of the working day and also on how long the benefit has been received, so that the longer you have been receiving it, the lower the amount, which is also calculated as a percentage of the IPREM. It will range from €480 a month to €180.

Though some details still need to be confirmed, according to the reform, it will not be possible to combine work and unemployment benefits before April 2025.

The benefit will be lost if the gross monthly salary is higher than 225 percent of the IPREM, €16,200 gross per year in 12 payments, or €1,350 per month.

Speeding up processes

The reforms also try to speed up the procedures when claiming unemployment benefits.

The Ministry wants to get rid of the one-month waiting period after unemployment benefits run out, but will also tighten up the deadlines: if you apply for benefit six months after the benefit has run out, your application will now be rejected.

Widening the scope

The reform proposal also extends the groups of people who can access unemployment benefits. It will also now be paid to those without dependents who have paid social security contributions for less than six months, and to temporary workers in the agricultural sector.

Equally, whereas before it was necessary to prove a lack of income in order to be eligible, this required evidence of both personal and family unit income, with this reform only one will be required.

Workers over 52

The agreement also maintains the retirement contribution for recipients over 52 years of age at 125 percent of the minimum base in force at any given time.

SHOW COMMENTS