SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

GERMANY AND INDIA

Blue Cards and green energy: Why so many German ministers are visiting India

No other country has received as much attention from Germany than India in recent months. Why is the government launching a charm offensive and what does it mean for Indian migrants?

Blue Cards and green energy: Why so many German ministers are visiting India
Economics Minister Robert Habeck opens a children's science lab in Mumbai during his visit to India. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Britta Pedersen

“The focus has clearly shifted in favour of India,” was the summary of Economics Minister Robert Habeck (Greens) as he ended a three-day trip to the developing nation this week.

In many ways, this was an understatement. Habeck’s trip to the subcontinent – with the aim of sealing new green energy deals – marked the the first time a German economics minister has visited the country in eleven years.

And Habeck isn’t the only high-profile German politician to have made the journey recently. 

Just a few days before the Green politician’s visit to India, Labour Minister Hubertus Heil (SPD) had flown out to the country with the aim of convincing young medical professionals to come and work in Germany.

In the preceding months, India had also welcomed Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock, Finance Minister Christian Lindner, Development Minister Svenja Schulze and Defence Minister Boris Pistorius and Chancellor Olaf Scholz for state visits.

The number of cabinet ministers making the journey marks a significant shift in the focus of the German government away from China and towards India. 

So why is the German government so keen to romance the world’s most populous nation – and could this new relationship offer advantages for young migrants looking to start a new life in Germany?

Plea for STEM workers

It’s no secret that Germany is struggling to fill a widening skills gap in its economy at present – and India’s pool of highly qualified software engineers and IT workers is precisely what the country is looking for.

Though the government is desperate to make progress with digitalisation, this shortage of home-grown workers has been standing in the way. Just as swathes of qualified engineers and technical specialists move into retirement, the interest in STEM subjects in universities is sinking dramatically year on year. In fact, according a 2022 report by the German Economic Institute (IW), Germany was missing around 320,000 STEM workers last year. 

A man works in a factory in Dresden.

A man works in a factory in Dresden. Germany is desperate for skilled workers in manufacturing and elsewhere. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Sebastian Kahnert

Over the past ten years, however, a growing number of skilled migrants from India have been helping to plug this gap. This period has seen the number of Indian passport holders working in computer science or engineering in Germany shoot up by more than 550 percent from 3,800 to 25,000. Overall, the number of Indians moving to the country has risen from around 60,000 in 2012 to 210,000 in 2022.

Indians also make up the largest proportion of Blue Card recipients of any other nation, with around 22.5 percent of Blue Cards being handed out to Indians between 2012 and 2017.

READ ALSO: 8 things to know about Germany’s new skilled worker immigration law

Call for qualified nurses

When Labour Minister Hubertus Heil visited the country, however, it wasn’t just to tap into the talent in India’s thriving tech sector. While there, the SPD politician met with a number of qualified nurses at a relocation event held at the Goethe Institute in Thiruvananthapuram in southern India.

“I am thrilled that so many young people want to come to Germany as nurses,” he said at the time. “And they have a realistic image of Germany.”

The backdrop, of course, is that the healthcare sector is another German industry that is struggling with demographic change in the country. The aging population means that more and more people require care. At the same time, fewer doctors and nurses remain in the healthcare system to care for them.

A recent study from the IW’s Competence Center for Securing Skilled Labour (KOFA) found that there were 163,000 positions in nursing, teaching and childcare that couldn’t be filled by workers in 2022. At the same time, a survey by financial advisory firm MLP revealed that 52 percent of doctors in Germany report a shortage staff – and as many as 76 percent in less developed regions such as the former East. 

However, Heil was reticent about relaxing German language requirements for nurses, pointing out that a B2 level is necessary for performing the job well and integrating into German society.

READ ALSO:

Migration deal 

Germany’s desire to become an attractive destination for skilled migrants from India was cemented in an agreement signed by Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock on her trip to the country back in December.

The deal was designed to facilitate what the government described as “fair mobility for students and trainees, cultural professionals, journalists, academics and skilled workers” who want to migrate between India and Germany while also fighting against illegal migration. It was the first specific migration agreement signed between a non-EU country and Germany and has since then been used as a template for thrashing out other migration deals with third countries like Brazil as well.

German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock (Greens) in India

German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock (Greens) visits the founders of a social initiative in Khori, India. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Carsten Koall

“We are setting the course for qualified young Indians to gain professional and practical experience in Germany, to study here, start vocational training, or work in their profession,” Interior Minister Nancy Faeser said at the time. “This is another important step in attracting skilled workers that we urgently need in the German labour market.”

The forthcoming Skilled Worker Immigration Act is also designed to pull in this group of qualified workers and international students – with many likely to come from India. Under the new law, there will be simpler routes for skilled workers to migrate to Germany – including a new points-based jobseeker visa – lower salary requirements for Blue Card holders, attractive perks for international students and easier family reunification rules, among other things.

This should serve to accelerate the trend of year-on-year increases in Indian migrants coming to Germany. 

READ ALSO: Indians in Germany: Who are they and where do they live?

Economy and energy 

The interest in India goes beyond the question of worker shortages and migration, however.

Once dismissed as a developing nation, Germany has now set its sights firmly on India as it seeks to limit its dependence on China.

With around 1.4 billion residents, the country is not only the most populous in the world, but also has a rapidly developing economy that represents an attractive market for German companies as well as a source of skilled labour.

In addition, India has been funnelling its resources heavily into renewable energy and is seen by Germany as an important supplier of green hydrogen. With some technological advancement, it is hoped that India can also assist Germany in building up a corresponding industry, with solar parks and electrolysers to produce the hydrogen.

So far, however, there have been frictions over India’s perceived commitment to fighting climate change. The country has so far only pledged to becoming climate neutral by 2070 – 25 years after Germany wants to phase out emissions – and has also taken issue with the EU’s strict definition of green hydrogen.

Another political difficulty in the burgeoning relationship between the two nations is the Indian administration’s closeness to Russia and Vladimir Putin.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has so far refused to condemn Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and has opted out of sanctions imposed on the post-Soviet nation.

In fact, the country has even increased its business dealings with Russia in the wake of the war, largely in order to benefit from cheap fossil fuels. There are also suspicions that India may be selling sanctioned Russian goods onto third-party nations – an act that would breach the West’s existing sanctions. 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

IMMIGRATION

‘Germany needs you’: Labour Minister’s plea to skilled workers from India

Germany is launching a skilled labour strategy with India in an effort to plug the worker shortage. At a recent meeting with Indian students in Berlin, the Labour Minister highlighted how valued immigrants from abroad are.

'Germany needs you': Labour Minister's plea to skilled workers from India

As Germany faces an ever-growing worker shortage, politicians are trying to pull out all the stops. 

They are looking abroad in a bid to get more people into the labour market and social security system.

In the last few years, Labour Minister Hubertus Heil has been focusing on a handful of countries including India and Brazil to increase immigration. And last week, Heil announced that a new ‘skilled labour strategy’ is to be presented at the Indian-German consultations in autumn.

The aim is to smooth out the visa process to allow the recruitment of skilled worker immigrants on a large scale.

The Social Democrat politician made the announcement following a meeting with a small group of Indian students at the Free University in Berlin.

“This skilled labour strategy will be developed together with the Foreign Office and the Ministry of Labour, with German industry, and with the states and with other ministries,” said Heil. The aim is to send a “clear signal to India that bright minds and helping hands are welcome in Germany”.

Heil, who also visited India a year ago, said the strategy would look at “how we deal with the acceleration of visa issuance, how we deal with the issue of recruitment in various areas, what tasks the economy has, what initiatives the various federal states also have”.

READ ALSO: Indians in Germany – Who are they and where do they live?

Germany ‘dependent on more immigration’

During the exchange with Indian students in Berlin last Thursday, Heil said the German labour market is facing major challenges due to the country’s demographic structure. Germany will need seven million skilled workers by 2035 to meet demand, said the SPD politician, citing a study by the Institute for Employment Research (IAB).

“Due to demographic changes, Germany is dependent on more immigration,” said Heil, as reported by German newspaper Welt. He said it was great that German universities are becoming increasingly popular with students from abroad, but added: “people also need to stay.” 

It’s no surprise that Heil is singling out this this group. Figures from the Federal Statistical Office and the German Economic Institute (IW) show that in 2023 alone, the number of Indians in Germany increased by 36,391.

The Indian population in Germany is also well qualified – 56 percent of employees from India work in ‘expert’ jobs, which typically require a degree or special training, data from the IW shows. That’s compared to 17.7 percent among other immigrant populations, and 30.5 percent among Germans.

There are nearly 43,000 Indian students throughout Germany, with almost 300 of them at Freie Universität Berlin.

But as many countries grapple with a labour shortage, Indians are in demand around the world – especially in English-speaking countries where they can find jobs more easily.

Labour Minister Hubertus Heil meets Indian students in Berlin.

Labour Minister Hubertus Heil meets Indian students in Berlin. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Soeren Stache

‘Please stay’

Students cited the German healthcare system, opportunities for a better salary and the quality of life as advantages of Germany.

But there were plenty of concerns raised with Heil, including bureaucracy, the level of digitalisation and concerns about scientific research prospects. 

Others reported practical issues. Some students said they had been searching for accommodation for months in Germany, whereas in India, universities would offer accommodation.

Heil listened carefully and admitted that Germany needs “an update”.

Germany has brought in a number of sweeping changes to immigration laws recently.

In November 2023, the government introduced the first phase of its new skilled worker law, with lower salary thresholds for Blue Card applicants and more flexibility for skilled workers to work in a range of professions.

In March this year, Germany brought in more big changes to immigration rules, including quicker routes to permanent residence, amendments to make it easier for healthcare workers from outside the EU to move to Germany and relaxed family reunification rules. This was a controversial move because the new family rules only apply to workers coming to Germany after March and not those already here. 

And in June Germany launched the ‘opportunity card’ visa, known as the Chancenkarte. 

This is a ‘jobseekers’ visa’ allowing eligible skilled workers from outside the EU to move to Germany for up to a year to look for a job. They are also able to work up to 20 hours a week while they do so. 

READ ALSO: How Germany’s opportunity card will allow easier entries for foreign workers from June

But there is still some way to go to convince foreign nationals – including students from India – that Germany should be their top choice for settling down abroad.

At the end of the conversation, Heil issued a plea to the group, spelling out what he hoped for. “Please stay. Germany needs you,” he said. 

READ ALSO: ‘Won’t give up my passport’ – Why Indians in Germany face hurdles to citizenship

SHOW COMMENTS