SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

READER INSIGHTS

‘Told to leave the country’: How foreigners in Germany face xenophobia and racism

In a recent survey, the majority of The Local readers said they felt xenophobia and racism was on the rise in Germany, but personal experiences varied dramatically. Here's what readers said.

xenophobia is no alternative
A protester holds up a sign reading "Xenophobia is not an alternative" during a protest outside an election event of the Alternative for Germany (AfD) party in Berlin after a previous general election. Photo by John MACDOUGALL / AFP

The word xenophobia comes from the Greek words xénos (foreign) and phóbos (fear), and is defined as the dislike of anything foreign or strange. 

It tends to stem from the perception of a conflict between an in-group and an out-group, and often is related to the fear of losing a national, ethnic, or racial identity.

While xenophobia itself refers primarily to the fear experienced by someone, the danger is that xenophobic sentiments lead to racist behaviour–and sometimes violence.

The far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) has promoted xenophobic rhetoric for years.

In an investigation into the party earlier this year, Germany’s Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV) identified numerous statements made by AfD officials that questioned if foreign nationals belonged to the German nation, regardless of their level of integration, or even German citizenship.

Partly due to their propensity for promoting xenophobic ideas, the BfV labelled the AfD as an “suspected extremist” organisation – and in the state of Saxony, the local AfD branch was found to be a “confirmed extremist” organisation.

READ ALSO: Germany labels Saxony branch of far-right AfD as extremist

Given the AfD’s strong showing in the recent state elections in Saxony and Thuringia, some are concerned that xenophobia and related racist acts could be on the rise in Germany. 

In a recent survey, we asked our readers if they have experienced a rise in xenophobia or discrimination towards foreigners in Germany.

Of the readers who immediately responded, 58.3 percent said they had noticed a rise, whereas 41.7 percent said they had not.

xenophobia graph

What does xenophobia look like?

In its most raw and ugly form, xenophobia manifests as grotesque acts of racism.

A 35-year-old from Kenya who chose not to share their name told The Local that they were called a racial slur and “shown the Hitler salute” recently while on a boat ride in Lübbenau.

For the record, demonstrating a Hitler salute (also called a Nazi salute or Hitlergruß) is illegal in Germany, along with hate speech, and is punishable by up to three years in prison.

READ ALSO: FACT CHECK – Are people punished for using Nazi slogans in Germany?

But xenophobia is also often expressed with more subtlety.

Jamey, 45, from the US described a situation while camping in Saxony where the campground hosts talked down to him and those he was with, implying they were stupid because they were not German.

Another reader from India explained that xenophobia doesn’t always lead to direct confrontations, but can lead to a palpable sense that people are avoiding you: “Be it at a grocery store, a bus stop or a walk in the neighbourhood,” they said. 

The reader estimated that in their experience roughly 25 percent of people might avoid them or engage in some form of evasion, but that it was enough to make them feel uncomfortable and unwelcome.

Many respondents who said they felt xenophobia was increasing cited indirect acts like this, or otherwise verbal altercations, as being the primary example of racism they had experienced.

“It is mostly about smaller things so far,” said a 35-year-old from the Balkans, “But I’ve heard people shout hostile things at foreigners in the street a couple of times in the past year, which I personally didn’t experience before.” They added that they’ve lived in Germany for six and half years.

You might not notice it if you ‘look German’

A number of respondents who said they had not observed a rise in xenophobia or racism directly also noted that they might not immediately be perceived as foreigners themselves.

One respondent who told The Local that she had “not experienced any racism myself,” added that she’s a “white American” with German heritage.

For his part Ali, 56, from London said, “Only once or twice have I ever felt negatively treated as a foreigner here. But it’s not obvious I’m foreign until I open my mouth.”

Another respondent from Finland said that “as a white immigrant” that experience xenophobia “far less than people of colour”.

How does xenophobia affect work and day to day life?

Of those who had experienced xenophobia or racist acts in Germany, quite a few cited experiences in the workplace.

Elvis, who didn’t offer details about his age or location, said that one of his co-workers had referred to him as a “bush man”, and another had reacted with obscenities after seeing him with his wife.

He added that he’s worried rhetoric used by AfD leaders is increasing fear and intolerance of foreigners.

In less severe instances–though still hurtful and problematic–xenophobia in the workplace can come in the form of indirect comments. In some cases people might not even realise that their comments are rooted in xenophobic ideologies.

Carla, 47, from Portugal told The Local that “In the early days at my job, it was common to hear that ‘it was cheaper to hire a southerner than a German for my position’ and ‘I don’t understand why [the company] would hire someone that doesn’t speak German’”.

She added that she has since learned to speak German.

Beyond the workplace, some readers reported experiencing prejudice or racism in other public spaces.

“In the hospital some nurses were behaving in an openly racist manner”, said Hilary, 77, from the UK. Fortunately in her case, others stepped in “to ‘correct’ them”.

Erdi, 35, from Turkey, was also the victim of racist speech recently. He told The Local, “After my two-year-old son had a conflict with a German kid, their parents threatened us, telling us to leave the country if my son would continue to behave like this.”

READ ALSO: ‘I’m worried for my kids’: Foreigners in Germany fearful over rise of far right

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

MONEY

Why Germany will not raise unemployment benefits next year

Bürgergeld allowance - the long-term unemployment benefit - will not be increased next year, the German government says.

Why Germany will not raise unemployment benefits next year

The coalition government usually raises the Bürgergeld allowance – which those who are long-term unemployed receive – at the turn of the year.

But according to Labour Minister Hubertus Heil, of the Social Democrats (SPD), the falling inflation rate means there will be no increase in 2025.

Inflation fell to 1.9 percent in August – the lowest level in more than three years. “And that’s why the figures and the legal mechanism mean that, as predicted, there will be no increase in ‘citizens’ benefits’ on January 1st,” Heil said. “And that is the right thing to do.”

Heil said people in Germany who are not in work must be supported. “But it is also clear that this is the minimum subsistence level, no more, no less,” he added.

When the first tier of unemployment insurance runs out in Germany – typically after one year of not working – Bürgergeld (known as Unemployment II) kicks in at a fixed amount. 

At the moment, Bürgergeld recipients can expect €563 per month along with the payment of other living expenses and housing. The monthly payment was increased by 12 percent at the start of this year. 

However, that was controversial to the SPD’s coalition partners, the Free Democrats (FDP). Justice Minister Marco Buschmann (FDP) had recently even brought a reduction of the payment into play – but this was swiftly rejected by the Labour Ministry. 

The FDP has also been pushing for tougher sanctions on benefit recipients, which the coalition has put together a plan for. 

READ ALSO: How the German government wants to toughen up rules on unemployment benefits

This comes amid budgetary pressures. The coalition is debating how to make savings in the coming year’s budgets. 

What’s the reaction?

The move has been met with some opposition. The German Parity Welfare Association (Paritätische Wohlfahrtsverband) said the decision was a “step backwards”.

Bürgergeld is still far too low, prices are continuing to rise and not increasing it would be a step backwards in terms of social policy,” Chief Executive Joachim Rock told Redaktionsnetzwerk Deutschland.

“Just because the inflation rate is falling does not mean that the burden is also falling.”

READ ALSO: How generous is Germany’s unemployment benefit system?

Rock also criticised the methods used by the government to calculate the rate and called for inflation to be compensated for. According to the association, the standard rate of €563 for a single adult means “a healthy diet, adequate mobility and social participation regularly are not possible”. 

Rock repeated the association’s previous demand for an amount of €813 per month to be given to Bürgergeld recipients. 

The welfare association also rejected the FDP’s criticism that the last increase of Bürgergeld was too high and a reduction was necessary.

“People who receive the ‘citizen’s allowance’ have no savings or savings accounts with which they can bridge emergencies,” Rock said. 

Around 5.5 million residents in Germany receive the Bürgergeld benefit.

READ ALSO: Can I get unemployment benefits in Germany if I quit my job?

SHOW COMMENTS