SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

SPANISH LAW

Spain could enforce conscription of ordinary citizens if there is war

With many countries around Europe on edge due to Russia's invasion of Ukraine, many in Spain don't realise that the Spanish Constitution leaves the door open to military conscription of regular citizens if the country went to war.

Spain could enforce conscription of ordinary citizens if there is war
Spanish troops march on Armed Forces Day military parade in Granada. Photo: JORGE GUERRERO/AFP.

In recent years, war has been thrust into European public consciousness for the first time in decades.

With Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022, then followed by the ongoing conflict in Gaza, war is front and centre in the minds of many on the ‘old continent’.

For some countries, this is a more direct threat than others. Finland and Sweden, for example, two countries geographically close to Russia, have joined Nato on the back of the conflict.

READ ALSO: In cellars and minds, Swedes slowly prepare for possibility of war

But many countries and political leaders are talking up defence spending and putting their countries on a war footing.

NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said recently in the German press that we, referring to the West, must “prepare ourselves for a confrontation that could last decades.”

In the UK, the head of the British Army floated the idea of a ‘citizen’s army’ but the idea of military conscription was quickly shot down.

Spain has been a Nato member since 1982 and is home to American military bases. For Spaniards however, and for many Western Europeans, the conflicts of the 2020s can seem far and distant.

READ ALSO: Where are the US’s military bases in Spain and why are they there?

With regards to the conflict in Ukraine, Spain has stood strong with the wider EU position. On the crisis in the Middle East on the other hand, Spain has taken a slightly incongruent position compared to most European countries, being openly critical of Israel and backing formal recognition of a Palestinian state.

But besides public overtures and Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez’s appearances on the world stage, modern day war isn’t something that likely overly concerns many Spaniards. Not directly affecting Spain and Spaniards themselves, at least.

However, a little known quirk of the Spanish Constitution means that military conscription or mobilisation could, theoretically at least, be an option in Spain in wartime.

Compulsory military service was abolished in Spain in March 2001, under then Prime Minister José María Aznar. But Article 30 of the Spanish constitution retains some rather vague wording about defending Spain in times of crisis that potentially leaves the option open, despite Spain having a professional army:

Article 30:

Spaniards have the right and duty to defend Spain.

The law shall establish the military obligations of Spaniards and shall regulate, with due guarantees, conscientious objection, as well as other grounds for exemption from compulsory military service, and may impose, where appropriate, an alternative social service.

A civilian service may be established for the fulfilment of purposes of general interest.

The duties of citizens in cases of grave risk, catastrophe or public calamity may be regulated by law.

The wording in the legal text is broad and open to interpretation. Legally speaking, Spanish citizens have a “right and duty to defend Spain,” and, crucially, “the duties of citizens in cases of grave risk, catastrophe or public calamity may be regulated by law” — in other words, in wartime, laws could be passed to mobilise the public.

What exactly this entails is unclear. Hopefully nobody will ever find out, and it seems unlikely to be active military service, although it could include a mobilisation of some sort. 

Spain’s National Security Law, reformed as recently as 2022, more concretely outlines the Spanish State’s response plans to catastrophes such as pandemics, natural disasters and wars. Although the law does not explicitly state that Spaniards could be actively mobilised in the event of war (this seems unlikely due to the fact Spain has a fully professional army) it does establish a broader strategic approach that would fully involve civil society and the “active participation of citizens and civil society organisations.”

In crises, for example, private resources can essentially be taken by the government, if necessary, such as weapons and medical equipment.

However, for any Spaniards worried about a return of the sorts of military conscription seen in the 20th century, the right to be a conscientious objector is recognised in Article 30.2 of the Constitution, so on this basis, forced conscription for active military service would not be allowed.

For professional soldiers, however, the consequences are a little more severe. Spain’s Military Penal Code imposes sanctions on soldiers who refuse to go to a war.

Disappearances of more than 24 hours are punishable by 3 to 10 years in prison, according to Article 199 of the Military Criminal Code. The crime of desertion, when a soldier does not perform his or her duties or abandons their station, is punishable by up to 15 years in prison.

READ ALSO: Where are Spain’s nuclear bunkers and bomb shelters?

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

WEATHER

Does Spain use cloud seeding?

Some voices online blamed cloud seeding for flash flooding in Dubai recently. Does Spain use this weather modification technique and is it being harnessed as a means of combatting severe drought in the country?

Does Spain use cloud seeding?

The internet was awash with images of dramatic flooding in the UAE two weeks ago, in which parts of the country saw more rainfall in a single day than it usually does in an entire year on average.

The UEA government stated that it was the most rainfall the country had seen in 75 years and an incredible 10 inches of rain fell in the city of Al Ain.

Predictably, the freak weather event sparked fierce internet debate about the causes and consequences among climate change activists and climate change sceptics. The cause, in particular, struck a chord with certain subsections of the internet and many were asking the same question: did ‘cloud seeding’ cause this biblical downpour?

But what exactly is cloud seeding? Does Spain use it? And with the country’s ongoing drought conditions, should it be using it?

What is cloud seeding?

According to the Desert Research Institute: “Cloud seeding is a weather modification technique that improves a cloud’s ability to produce rain or snow by introducing tiny ice nuclei into certain types of subfreezing clouds. These nuclei provide a base for snowflakes to form. After cloud seeding takes place, the newly formed snowflakes quickly grow and fall from the clouds back to the surface of the Earth, increasing snowpack and streamflow.”

Cloud seeing is used by countries around the world, not only in the Middle East but in China and the U.S, usually in areas suffering drought concerns. The process can be done from the ground, with generators, or from above with planes.

Does Spain use cloud seeding?

Sort of, but on a far smaller scale and not in the same way other countries do. In places like China and the U.S, where large swathes of the country are at risk of drought, cloud seeding is used to help replenish rivers and reservoirs and implemented on an industrial scale.

In Spain, however, the technique has been for a much more specific (and small scale) reason: to avoid hailstorms that can destroy crops.

This has mostly been used in the regions of Madrid and Aragón historically.

But cloud seeding isn’t something new and innovative, despite how futuristic it might seem. In fact, Spain has a pretty long history when it comes to weather manipulation techniques. Between 1979 and 1981, the first attempts to stimulate rainfall took place in Spain, coordinated by the World Meteorological Organisation.

“In 1979, in Valladolid, different techniques were developed to observe the local clouds but they did not meet any possible conditions for cloud seeding experiments. The project came to a standstill,” José Luis Sánchez, professor of Applied Physics at the University of León, told La Vanguardia.

This sort of cloud seeding, as used abroad, doesn’t really happen in Spain anymore. Rather, when it’s used it’s done to protect crops on a local level. Spain’s Ministry for Ecological Transition and the Demographic Challenge are responsible for authorising cloud seeding, but there are only a handful of current authorisations to combat hail, such as the one granted to the Madrid’s Agricultural Chamber combat hail in the south-east of the region.

As of 2024, it is believed that no regions have requested cloud seeding (whether by generator or plane) to ‘produce’ more rain.

So, cloud seeding isn’t currently used like it is in countries such as the U.S., China, and the UAE. But should it, and could it solve the drought issue in Spain?

An aircraft technician inspects a plane’s wing mounted with burn-in silver iodide (dry ice) flare racks. (Photo by Indranil MUKHERJEE / AFP)

Spain’s drought conditions

Spain has been suffering drought conditions for several years now. Last year the government announced a multi-billion dollar package to combat the drought conditions, and several regions of Spain have brought in water restrictions to try and maintain dwindling reservoir reserves. 

READ ALSO:

At times in Spain in recent years it has felt as though another temperature or minimum rainfall record is broken every other day. The drought conditions are particularly bad in the southern region of Andalusia and Catalonia, where, despite heavy rain over Easter, reservoirs in the region are at just 18 percent capacity, the lowest level in the country.

So, could cloud seeding be used in Spain to help alleviate some of the drought conditions? Yes and no. Seeding is not the only answer to drought, but could theoretically be used as one option among many.

“It’s just another tool in the box,” Mikel Eytel, a water resources specialist with the Colorado River District, told Yale Environment 360 magazine: “It’s not the panacea that some people think it is.”

This is essentially because cloud seeding does not actually produce more rain, rather it stimulates water vapour already present in clouds to condense and fall faster. For there to be a significant amount of rainfall, the air needs significant levels of moisture.

That is to say, using cloud seeing to try and stimulate more rain may help Spain’s drought conditions in a small way, but the difference would be marginal.

“It’s not as simple and may not be as promising as people would like,” respected cloud physicist Professor William R. Cotton, wrote in The Conversation. 

“Experiments that produce snow or rain require the right type of clouds with sufficient moisture and the right temperature and wind conditions. The percentage increases are small and it is difficult to know when the snow or rain fell naturally and when it was triggered by seeding.”

SHOW COMMENTS