SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

POLITICS

EXPLAINED: How a new law gets made in Denmark

Arguably one of the keys to Denmark's success as a nation is the thorough, systematic way that government proposals get turned into laws.

EXPLAINED: How a new law gets made in Denmark
Denmark's 'Folketingssalen' is where new laws are voted on, but what does it take for a new law to be made? Photo;: Mads Claus Rasmussen/Ritzau Scanpix

The process is highly formalised, with the Danish government’s website having a section to the right of each lovforslag or proposed law showing where it is in the lovgivningsproces, or legislative process, the succession of stages each law goes through until it is passed in parliament.  

1. The idea 

The first stage of any new law in Denmark is, of course, the idea.

A proposal might be floated by a government minister in a newspaper, an opposition MP, a business leader, an organisation, at a press conference, in a speech, or in a party manifesto. It may have been debated back and forth for decades, but without any formal steps being taken. 

Until it moves on to the next stage it doesn’t mean very much. 

2. The proposal

The first stage of the actual law-making process in Denmark is the lovforslag or beslutningsforslag, the two types of proposed law or change to be investigated and analysed.

This is when an idea goes beyond talk and the process is in motion. 

The proposal summarises what proposal or idea needs to be analysed, lists the key proposals that should be answered, and sets a date by which the conclusions should be published.  

Proposals take a long time to write with a high level of legal expertise needed. They are usually tabled by the government – opposition parties can also propose laws but they do not have the full weight of the civil service behind them to write the draft bills.

Any law change will also need a parliamentary majority to eventually vote for it – this is naturally easier for the government than the opposition to gather.

In any case, a proposed law is usually the result of long negotiations within ministries, goverment parties and sometimes between the government and opposition or allied parties who are interested in passing the legislation.

There’s a distinction between a lovforslag and a beslutningsforslag: the latter is easier and faster to write, because it involves less detail. It is not a formal proposal to change the law and is usually tabled by the opposition in a bid to demand the government takes action – either by tabling a formal lovforslag or taking an issue onto its agenda.

Many of these beslutningsforslag are rejected because they fail to gain a majority, so their purpose is often to stimulate debate on an issue. This can lead to new laws in the longer term.

3. The hearing stage

Before being tabled in parliament, parliamentary committees can put the bill through a høring or hearing in which experts are invited to provide their knowledge and viewpoints on the matter being legislated.

These hearings take place at the committee rooms in parliament and are normally open to the media and the public.

Another form of høring is the høringssvar, which takes place outside of the committees. Here, the ministry writing the bill can send it out to affected or interested socieites or organisations prior to tabling it in parliament.

The organisations are asked to provide their viewpoints and comments on the bill in writing. These opinions are termed høringssvar, literally “hearing answers”.

4. The three readings

A lovforslag gets three readings in the Danish parliament (two for a beslutningsforslag). This is required by the constitution. The readings take place in parliament itself and in the relevant committee – for example, the defence committee, on which the defence minister and the defence spokespersons from the other parties sit.

Proposals are generally given a minimum time of 30 days for the three readings, to ensure thorough legislation and guard against laws being passed on a whim.

However, parliament can give permission for a hastebehandling or expedited process, which allows laws to be passed in less than 30 days from the bill being tabled, in special circumstances. This requires a large parliamentary majority of 3/4.

5. Final vote

Once the bill has passed the three readings, it can be voted on in parliament. Generally, the outcome of the vote will be known in advance, because the bill will have take a final form which the government or parliamentary majority supports.

In some cases parties may choose to fritstille their MPs, meaning they can decide independently how to vote on the bill (the opposite of “whipping” in British politics).

This can make the outcome of the vote may be more unpredictable, but it usually only happens if the issue is a highly contentious one.

6. Law takes effect

After being passed by parliament, the law is not effective immediately. It may be given a date in the future – January 1st the following year, for example – when it will come into force. It can also have a more immediate effect.

All Danish laws must be signed by the king. This is the final step in creating the new legislation.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

2024 EUROPEAN ELECTIONS

What’s at stake for Denmark’s political parties in the coming EU elections?

With the Moderate Party at risk of losing its only seat and the Liberal Party facing seeing its number of MEPs halved, Denmark's junior government parties have a lot at stake in the coming EU elections.

What's at stake for Denmark's political parties in the coming EU elections?

Campaigning in Denmark ahead of the EU elections on June 9th has yet to really get going, but the most recent polls suggest that the Moderates and Liberals, the two right of centre parties in the country’s three party grand coalition, have the most to lose.   

A poll last week, carried out by Epinion for Denmark’s state broadcaster DR, brought bad news for the Moderate Party led by former prime minister Lars Løkke Rasmussen, with support for the party falling to 4.5 percent from the 7.4 percent the party had in a previous poll from March. This has brought it below the threshold of about 6.5 percent to get a seat in the parliament. 

When the party was founded in 2022, it quickly gained an MEP, after Bergur Løkke Rasmussen, Rasmussen’s son, crossed over from the Liberals. 

But being part of Denmark’s less than popular three-party coalition, together with a series of missteps by the party’s lead European candidate, Stine Bosse, seems to have weighed the upstart party down. Now it’s not only the younger Rasmussen, who is second on the party list, who risks losing his seat, but Bosse as well. 

The Moderates are not the only party to be struggling as a result of taking part in the government, however. 

The Liberals risk seeing the number of MEPs they have in Brussels halved from the four they won in 2019, and if they perform badly when the campaign starts for real, they risk being reduced to a single seat.  

This is the party that came out top in the 2019 European elections, in one of the last triumphs for its then leader Lars Løkke Rasmussen, overtaking the Social Democrats to become the biggest Danish party in Brussels. 

READ ALSO: 

It now looks like the Social Democrats, the only government party which can look relatively optimistically towards June, will take back that position. 

While support for Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen's party is plummeting in national election polling, falling to just 19.2 in the most recent Epinion poll, down 30 percent from the 2022 election result, it is doing better in Europe.

According to last week's Epinion poll, the Social Democrats stand to get 20.1 percent of the vote in June, only a slight decline from the 21.5 the party won in the 2019 European elections.  

With Denmark gaining an extra seat in the European Parliament following the UK's exit, this means the party is set to get four MEPs, up from three in the 2019 election. 

It's not only government parties that have reasons to worry. 

The Social Liberal party (Radikale Venstre), promotes itself as Denmark's most pro-EU party, and its former leader, Margrethe Vestager, has risen to become one of the most powerful figures in Brussels. 

But the party is currently set to win just 7 percent of the vote, down from 10 percent in the 2019 European elections, meaning it is likely to lose one of its two MEPs, and is not too far off losing both. 

The Conservative Party, still reeling from the death of its leader, Søren Pape, from a cerebral haemorrhage in March, is also facing a difficult election.

The Conservatives are the only Danish party in the powerful EPP block in Brussels, giving it a seat at the table with the powerful German Christian Democrats,  France's Republican Party, and Spain's Partido Popular.

They have won one seat or more in every European election since Denmark joined in 1979. While last week's Epinion poll also gave it 7 percent of the vote, it also doesn't have far to fall to lose its only seat.  

SHOW COMMENTS