SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

FOOD AND DRINK

What we know so far about the sardine-based botulism poisoning in France

One person has died and 12 were hospitalised after an outbreak of sardine-related botulism poisoning in south-west France. Here's what happened and the risks associated with it.

What we know so far about the sardine-based botulism poisoning in France
Photo by JEAN-SEBASTIEN EVRARD / AFP

What happened?

Over the past few days 12 people have been hospitalised after suffering from botulism poisoning and one person – a 32-year-old woman living in the Paris region – has died.

Eight people remain in hospital – five of them in intensive care, including the partner of the woman who died.

Those affected had all visited the Tchin Tchin Wine Bar in Bordeaux, and health authorities have traced the outbreak to home-made preserved sardines that were served in the bar.

Authorities are calling on anyone who visited this wine bar between September 4th and 10th to seek medical help if they are suffering any symptoms.

The bar appears to be popular with tourists – of those affected the majority are either American, Canadian or German. The nationality of the woman who died has not been specified, but another case has been reported in a man who has returned to Spain after visiting Bordeaux.

There may be further cases to come. 

What is botulism?

Botulism is a rare but life-threatening condition caused by toxins produced by Clostridium botulinum bacteria.

These toxins attack the nervous system (nerves, brain and spinal cord) and cause paralysis and muscle weakness.

Food-borne botulism such as the case in Bordeaux is usually caused by imperfectly preserved or canned food. 

Symptoms include vomiting, stomach cramps, diarrhoea or constipation and – if left untreated – muscle paralysis. Signs of this paralysis can include; drooping eyelids, blurred or double vision, facial muscle weakness, difficulty swallowing, slurred speech and breathing difficulties.

Anyone with those symptoms should seek medical treatment immediately, either by going to a hospital emergency department or calling an ambulance (telephone number 15 in France or the European emergency number 112).

Emergency in France: Who to call and what to say

Is it common in France?

No, botulism is very rare in Europe – France usually has between 20 and 30 cases a year, of which around five percent are fatal.

The most common cause is infected wounds, particularly among heroin-users who use dirty needles.

Food-borne botulism – as in this case – is usually caused by imperfectly prepared canned, pickled or preserved food.

Modern factory techniques make this extremely unlikely in commercially-produced tins, pickles or preserves – although you should not eat food that comes from a damaged or bulging can or if the food has a strong, unpleasant smell.

The cause in this case appears to be a home-made sardine preserve that the owner of the wine bar had made to serve with drinks and snacks or planches (platters of bread, meat and cheese).

What happens now?

French health authorities are continuing to investigate the outbreak and say there may be more victims, as food-borne botulism poisoning can take up to 10 days for symptoms to develop.

The owner of the bar is being questioned, and authorities believe they have now identified all but 13 customers who ate the affected sardines between September 4th and September 10th. 

Hospitals continue to treat those seriously ill – in most cases hospital treatment involves keeping the patient’s airways open, and the paralysis gradually recedes after several weeks or months. 

How can I stay safe in France?

This outbreak is an extremely rare event, and there is no higher risk of food-borne botulism in France than in any other western country. 

Tips to stay safe include; not eating canned food if the tin is damaged or bulging; avoiding any preserved or canned food that has a strong, unpleasant smell; avoiding canned or preserved food that is out of date or stored at the incorrect temperature.

If you are undertaking your own pickling, canning or preserving, make sure you carefully follow the hygiene advice (such as sterilising jars before use) in the recipe. 

Member comments

  1. You say avoid “any preserved or canned food that has a strong, unpleasant smell” but, in fact, food contaminated with botulism can smell the same as uncontaminated food. Botulism contamination does not create an ‘off’ smell or appearance and it is important that people know this.

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

HEALTH

‘A load of smoke’: French doctors warn against ‘miracle hangover cure’

Rehydration tablets have become the latest craze in France, with social media users raving about the so-called 'miracle hangover cure'. However, French doctors have issued a warning.

'A load of smoke': French doctors warn against 'miracle hangover cure'

Watermelon, peach and berry are just some of the flavours available for the ‘Hydratis’ tablets that can allegedly help cure a hangover, if you believe the buzz on social media in France.

The idea is that after drinking, you can take two tablets – which contain minerals such as magnesium, potassium, zinc, manganese and more – which dissolve in a glass of water before bed, and again in the morning.

French influencer ‘Monsieur Astuces’ – who has almost three million followers – recently shared a video advertising the tablets, saying that “everyone should have this at home!”

@monsieurastuces #partenariat Des pastilles efferverscentes pour rester bien hydraté 💧 #hydratis ♬ son original – Monsieur Astuces

One of the founders of the French brand Hydatris, Théo Heude, told Le Parisien that his company has seen an “annual average growth of more than 300 percent, and even more than 400 percent this year”.

Hydratis claims that their product “allows water to be absorbed more quickly and efficiently by the body”, but technically they do not allege that their tablets are a ‘hangover miracle’.

READ MORE: ‘No beer pong’: 9 things to know before you go to a French party

Rather, the company clarified to the French press that they “do not actively recommend [using Hydratis] to treat hangovers, even if some people use it in this manner” and that they do not recommend the tablets “to people who eat a varied and balanced diet, while hydrating all day long”.

Still, French doctors and addiction experts have pushed back against the trend, arguing that there has been a misleading message around the Hydratis tablets and that they could be an incentive for people to drink more alcohol.

“I prefer to have young people drinking this than Coca-Cola to hydrate themselves, but let’s be serious, it’s a load of smoke,” Dr. Martine Duclos who heads up the sports medicine department at Clermont-Ferrand University Hospital told Le Parisien.

“The troublesome bit is that [the tablets] contain salt and sugar, and we already consume too much of that.

They also come with sucralose, a sweetener that we doctors are wary of because studies have shown that, in the long term, it can increase the risk of cardiovascular disease,” she pointed out.

As for the vitamin benefits and electrolytes in the tablets, Duclos said this would not be necessary if you have a balanced diet.

Bernard Basset, the head of the Addictions France association, told the French press that “the most effective thing about the product is the water used to dilute the lozenge.

“The danger comes from the messaging, which tells people that the tablets prevent hangovers, so they are encouraged to drink more.”

While drinking water and avoiding binge drinking is still recommended by health experts, researchers have still not found a single cure to hangovers, sadly.

SHOW COMMENTS