SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

HEALTH

EXPLAINED: Which Swiss health insurance deductible makes most sense?

If you are a foreigner, understanding Switzerland’s health insurance system may not be easy. And figuring out which ‘out of pocket’ option you should choose can be a real brain twister.

EXPLAINED: Which Swiss health insurance deductible makes most sense?
You can determine your deductible by how frequently you need medical help. Photo: Pixabay

If you come from a European, or any other country with a nationalised health care service, then you will find Switzerland’s scheme vastly different.

The same applies to the United States as well. 

Even if you do understand the basics of the Swiss system, including the difference between the obligatory insurance — KVG in German, and LaMal in French and Italian — and the complementary policies, you may still have trouble wrapping your head around the out-of-pocket expenses (the so-called franchise) that you will have to pay yourself.

The deductible

It is not unusual for various policies, such as car or home insurance, to include a deductible — the amount you will have to pay yourself before the insurance starts covering incurred costs. But it is usually a fixed amount, determined by the insurance company.

Not so with the Swiss health insurance.

When you take out a policy, you will have to choose the amount of your annual franchise — ranging from the lowest, 300 francs, to the highest, which is 2,500 francs. (There are various other amounts in between as well, but these two are the most common).

Whichever amount you choose, you will have to pay it yourself before you can claim benefits from the insurance provider.

Highest versus lowest

At first glimpse, the 300-franc deductible is a more attractive option, because it means you will reach the franchise threshold quicker.

However, opting for this amount means that your monthly premiums will be quite a bit higher than if you choose the highest deductible, that is, 2,500 francs.

As an example, if you select the latter option, your monthly premium may be 300 francs or even less. With the former one, it could go up to 450 francs or more. (Keep in mind, though, that this is only a rough estimate of costs; the actual amount depends on your age and your canton of residence).

READ ALSO: Why do Swiss healthcare premiums vary so much per canton?

These amounts, by the way, apply to adults only. For children up to the age of 18, they go from 100 to 600 francs a month.

So which amount should you choose?

The rule is: the higher the deductible, the cheaper the premiums, and vice-versa.

However, before you base your decision on this statement alone, there are two important things to take into account: your health and finances.

People who are young and healthy, and who never or rarely get sick, visit doctors, take medications, or need medical treatments in general, most commonly choose the highest franchise, which means they will be paying lower premiums.

On the other hand, if you are older (which implies, statistically, that you are more likely to seek medical help), or if you have chronic health problems requiring medications and frequent doctor visits, then you are better off with the lower franchise.

That’s the health factor. In terms of finances, having the high deductible means that if all of a sudden you need medical help, you will have to pay 2,500 francs out of your own pocket before insurance steps in.

Which deductible you choose will depend on health and money. Photo: Claudio Schwarz on Unsplash

But that is not all.

Before you do the math to calculate which deductible makes most sense to you, also consider the cost of co-insurance.

What exactly is this?

It is the money you pay out of pocket towards health insurance costs — 10 percent in total.

In other words, after you use up your franchise, you still have to pay 10 percent of the cost for medical treatment (though different rules apply to children, accidents, and maternity).

The co-insurance cost is capped at 700 francs a year, meaning that even if you have frequent, and costly, medical procedures, you will not be charged the 10-percent co-pay after you reach the 700-franc mark.

So when you sit down to figure out which franchise makes most financial sense for you, this is the thing to remember:

If you choose the highest, that is, the 2,500-franc deductible, add to it the 700-franc co-insurance cost. This means that on top of your monthly premiums, you should put aside 3,200 francs a year per adult, to be used toward health costs.

Conversely, if you have a 300-franc deductible, and add the 700-franc co-pay, then you should have 1,000 francs available each year to pay for out-of-pocket medical expenses.

When can you change your deductible — if you decide to do so?

You can switch to a lower deductible at the beginning of the calendar year.

However, you must inform your health insurer of the change in writing by November 30th of the previous year.

The same applies to a higher deductible — it will take effect at the beginning of the calendar year. Here, the deadline for informing the insurance provider is December 31st.

If you don’t notify the insurers of either change by those dates, it will be assumed that your current deductible remains as is.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

SHOPPING

REVEALED : Are ‘discount’ supermarkets in Switzerland really cheaper?

Lidl, Aldi and Denner claim their prices beat those of large Swiss retailers. But is this really the case?

REVEALED : Are ‘discount’ supermarkets in Switzerland really cheaper?

Common consumer goods (except one) are typically more expensive in Switzerland than in neighbour countries — sometimes by much.

This includes food.

READ ALSO: Why Switzerland is the most expensive country in Europe

That is especially the case of largest Swiss chains, Migros and Coop, while Denner, Lidl, and Aldi say their food prices are significantly lower.

To find out whether this claim is actually true, journalists from RTS public broadcaster’s consumer programme went shopping in each of these supermarkets. 

They purchased the same 30 products in each of the five supermarkets on the same day, to ensure that the price comparison is as accurate as possible.

Not what you’d expect

In each of the stores, the investigators purchased only the lowest priced items from the supermarkets’ budget lines.

It turned out that most money was spent at Denner, widely considered to be one of the lowest-priced supermarkets.

The total for the 30 items came to 181.67 francs — more than was spent at the country’s more expensive stores, Migros and Coop, where identical basket of goods cost 170.37 and 167.82 francs, respectively.

(That, in itself, is surprising as well, because Migros typically has lower prices than Coop).

As for the other two supermarkets, these purchases cost 166.59 francs at Aldi and 162.05 at Lidl.

So the difference in price between Migros and Coop versus Aldi and Lidl is minimal. But what is even more surprising is that the cost of groceries at ‘cheap’ Denner is actually highest of the lot, by between 11 and nearly 20 francs.

Migros and Coop performed quite well in the comparison survey because most of the items purchased in those stores came from their budget lines, M-Budget and Prix-Garantie, respectively, both of which were introduced to compete with Aldi and Lidl.

But how important is price? Patrick Krauskopf, a professor of anti-trust law, told RTS: “German, French, English, Spanish and American consumers pay a lot of attention to price. In Switzerland, consumers place more emphasis on quality of service. Price is almost secondary.

“Distributors have realised this and have stopped competing fiercely on price.”

Big versus small

While this particular analysis focused on supermarket chains, another survey, conducted at the end of 2023, looked at prices in small grocery shops. 

Common logic has it that it is cheaper to shop in supermarkets than a local corner store, because big retailers purchase products in large quantities, which means lower prices for consumers.

However, prices in some local shops were found to be “up to 30 percent cheaper than Migros and Coop.” 

The reason is that in order to cut costs, small grocers may buy their products from the most cost-effective suppliers, a tactic which includes importing some items.

Another reason for lower prices is that unlike major supermarkets, which ‘pretty up’ their stores for better presentation of products, these small retailers are ‘no-frill’ shops. This means little money is invested in décor, so there are no extra costs to pass on to consumers.

 READ ALSO: Why it might be cheaper to avoid the big supermarkets in Switzerland
 

SHOW COMMENTS