SHARE
COPY LINK

DISCRIMINATION

Four out of ten Norwegian Muslims ‘made to feel they do not belong’

Being discriminated against by public institutions, feeling as if they had to hide their religious identity and harassment were some of the experiences Muslims in Norway told a report they had been through in the past year.

Four out of ten Norwegian Muslims 'made to feel they do not belong'
A man in a hooded top looks excluded. Photo: Center for the study of the Holocaust and minorities

A full 43 percent of those questioned for the survey, commissioned by the Directorate of Integration and Diversity (IMDI) and carried out for the Norwegian Center for Holocaust and Minority Studies, said that they had “often” or “sometimes” been given the feeling of not belonging. 

One in five respondents said they had experienced discrimination from public institutions in Norway on the basis of their religious identity, one in four said they had experienced harassment over the past 12 months, and one in three respondents said they hid their religious identity out of fear of negative attitudes. 

Men were more likely than women to hide their religious identity, with 37 per cent of men reporting doing so, compared to 29 percent for women. 

“The experiences described to us clearly show that there is a nationalist dimension to anti-Muslim attitudes,” said Cora Alexa Døving, one of the researchers behind the study, said in a press release. “Many of the experiences are about being defined by a Norwegian community: ‘go back to where you come from’, ‘you Muslims are not like us’, and so on.”

Reda Foad Bader Al-Shemmari, a local Labour party politician in the Grorud district of Oslo told the Aftenposten newspaper that most Muslims in Norway experienced prejudice.  

“I think Islamophobia, subtle racism, discrimination and prejudice are something most Muslims have experienced,” he told the newspaper, remembering the repeated rejections he got when applying for jobs after graduating from upper secondary school, something he blames on his Islamic name. 

 “It is a fundamental problem. I have several friends who have changed to more Norwegian names,” he said. 

Døving said that the report indicated that Muslims’ perception of discrimination had increased in recent years. 

“If we look at the experiences described and previous documentation, we see an increase in Muslims reporting perceived discrimination,” she said.

She said that the survey had adopted a broader concept of discrimination, which included experiences of exclusion, prejudice and stereotyping which would not count as discrimination in the legal sense. 

Respondents to the survey described being passed over for internal promotion, encountering prejudice from customers and clients, being harassed about wearing Islamic headdress, being confronted about Islam, and particularly on the position of women, and being frequently forced to discuss the Islamic ban on drinking alcohol or eating pork.

Many said they were frequently asked in-depth questions related to their Muslim identity that were irrelevant to the work to be carried out. 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

RACISM

‘Subtle, tacit racism’: How welcome do foreigners feel in Norway?

Norway is not particularly racist, according to the readers who replied to our survey, with less than one in six telling us they felt "very unwelcome" in the country. However, several reported occasional experiences of subtle racism.

'Subtle, tacit racism': How welcome do foreigners feel in Norway?

More than two-thirds of respondents to the survey, which was self-selecting, did not see racism as a major problem in Norway, describing themselves as feeling “slightly welcome”, “neutral”, or “slightly unwelcome”.

Only one in six respondents said they felt “very welcome” in the country, suggesting room for improvement.

“I have lived in London, Vienna and am now living in Oslo,” said Sina Sayan, an engineer originally from Turkey. “It is sure that you cannot be a local in the sense that you can in London but you don’t feel unwelcome as much as you do in Vienna. People are friendly and polite, even helpful in normal social circumstances.”

Sayan also said that while racism was more open in Vienna than in Norway, it was easier there when it came to dating and making friends with locals.

George Boateng, a Ghanaian who has been living in Oslo for a decade, said that he did not feel that there was institutional or state-sanctioned racism in the country, although this did not mean that more subtle types of discrimination did not take place.

“Norway doesn’t appear to me to be racist, strictly speaking,” he wrote. “The country doesn’t have any direct law or state-sanctioned practices that qualify for the racist tag. If there are any such laws or practices, they have to be the direct opposite (anti-racist).”

He also said that the only direct racist abuse he had experienced had come from other foreigners.

Others agreed that overt racism was rare in their experience. “I have not encountered any kind of racism for 36 years in my stay in Norway,” said Joseph, who is originally from Sri Lanka. 

READ ALSO: ‘If we can’t admit that racism is a problem in Norway, we’ll never move past it’

Several respondents, however, said that they had experienced less overt forms of racism.

“I have had too many racist encounters, although all of them are minor, tacit racism,” said one person from the UK who chose to remain anonymous. “For example, I walked by a kid who just had his bike stolen, and upon seeing me, the first thing he said to me was, ‘did you steal my bike?’. It appears that, to that kid, a foreign face means a thief.”

“I have had service people ignoring me or treating me more poorly than Norwegian customers,” the person continued. “Their attitudes changed when I switched to English with a British accent.”

Jacques Vosser, an engineer from South Africa, said he had suffered a succession of racist encounters, starting with the Bergen municipality’s decision to place his children in an “integration school” he later came to believe was intended for the children of asylum seekers, something he believed would not have happened to someone coming to Norway on a work permit from another European country.

“I think the moment you say the word ‘South Africa’, all they hear is the word ‘Africa’. They already have this perception of ‘oh, this person walks between tigers and lions and lives in a mud hut’.

“They would look at us funny, and they were like, ‘Aren’t you supposed to be black?'” he added.

When his children moved to a Norwegian school, the situation worsened, with Vosser and his wife called to a police interview, only to find the head teacher had taken their children to a safe house and they were suspected of physically abusing them. Vosser said their teacher had mistaken the remnants of Halloween makeup on one of the children for bruises.

After a long evening in the police station, the children were eventually returned to the couple, and the case was dropped.

“I started speaking to some of the guys at my work about that because I was quite close to them, and they told me straight out, ‘This would not have happened if you were Norwegian’.”

He said that his children were also bullied, with the other children calling them names in Norwegian they did not understand.

Only one respondent reported receiving outright racist abuse.

“I faced some racism, mainly during weekend nights with drunk youngsters. They were calling me a ‘dirty Arab’,” said the person, who lives in Bergen. But he shrugged off the experience. “We find stupid people all over the world, I try to focus on the positive people that are helpful.”

Finally, respondents reported that more subtle forms of discrimination, while perhaps not qualifying as racism, were definitely a reality.

“One may face discrimination in the job hiring process, denial of promotions at the workplace, bullying in school and/or at the workplace, or discrimination in the housing market,” Boateng said. “The most painful thing to note is that many of these are subtle and, in most cases, are only fully appreciated by the victims or people with similar experiences.”

Joseph said that Norwegians would sometimes exclude foreigners. “The subtle judgments, and sharing information among select group is also common,” he said.

Sandeep Karthikeyan, a computer programmer from India, said that he had noticed a difference when he moved from a very international research team to one dominated by Norwegians.

“Since I moved to clinical work, I’m expected to speak Norwegian. I mean, it’s not mandatory, but its challenging because everyone speaks Norwegian.”

But he stressed that he still found Norwegians friendly and welcoming. “They are very careful,” he said. “In my experience. They’re even trying to be super nice to foreigners.”

SHOW COMMENTS