Judges drop probe into French Antilles pesticide scandal

Paris judges have dropped a criminal investigation into the use of a pesticide which sent cancer rates soaring in the French Antilles, saying too much time had passed to secure convictions.

Judges drop probe into French Antilles pesticide scandal
People demonstrate in Martinique, in 2021 against the threat of prescription in the judiciary file of the chlordecone, an insecticide accused of having poisoned the French west indies island. (Photo by Lionel CHAMOISEAU / AFP)

In a rare five-page explanation of their ruling, seen by AFP late Thursday, the investigators acknowledged that the chlordecone pesticide had caused a “health scandal” and inflicted long-term harm on the islands and their people.

But, as 30 years have passed, they said it was impossible to gather the evidence to prosecute anyone involved.

Almost 90 percent of people in Martinique and Guadeloupe, French territories in the Caribbean, have been contaminated with chlordecone, a December report by France’s ANSES health agency found.

Used to protect crops against weevils, the pesticide was banned in the rest of France in 1990 but allowed on the islands’ banana plantations until 1993.

The chemical has been linked to prostate cancer — the rate of which in Martinique and Guadeloupe is among the highest in the world — as well as stomach and pancreatic cancer.

Since the first criminal complaints by Antilleans over chlordecone in 2006, residents and elected officials have feared that statutes of limitations or other legal constraints would prevent anyone being held accountable.

Harry Durimel, mayor of Pointe-a-Pitre in Guadeloupe and a lawyer representing chlordecone victims, said on Friday that he would appeal the decision, taking it to European courts if needed.

“A state with the rule of law cannot say there is no grounds for prosecution faced with such a grave injustice,” he told AFP. 

The president of Martinique’s governing body, Serge Letchimy, said in a statement that he would organise a meeting of elected officials on Friday.

The judges said their investigation had established “antisocial behaviour by some economic actors” as well as “imprudence, negligence and ignorance” by authorities.

Before 1993, “economic productivity took precedence over health and environmental concerns,” they added.

But they could not prove that those involved knew the full risks, based on scientific information available at the time.

Nevertheless, they encouraged plaintiffs to use the links shown between the pesticide and its harms in their ruling to turn to “other authorities” for redress.

Prostate cancer caused by chlordecone has been recognised in the Antilles as a work-related illness since December 2021, opening the possibility of compensation for agricultural labourers.

Protests over the pesticide scandal have been mounting in Martinique again since prosecutors’ November recommendation to drop the criminal case.

In February 2021, thousands of people marched through the island’s capital Fort-de-France to protest against the case running into the statute of limitations.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


French billionaire Bernard Arnault probed over Courchevel money laundering

French billionaire Bernard Arnault and Russian oligarch Nikolai Sarkisov are under investigation for alleged money laundering at a luxury Alpine resort, according to Paris prosecutors.

French billionaire Bernard Arnault probed over Courchevel money laundering

The probe concerns their activities in Courchevel, a ski resort in the French Alps known for being a playground for the ultra-rich, they said late on Thursday.

The French economy ministry’s financial intelligence unit is leading the investigation, but has yet to determine whether any crime had been committed, a source close to the investigation told AFP.

French daily Le Monde, citing the Tracfin financial intelligence unit, reported that the 55-year old Russian billionaire had acquired 14 housing units from a single seller in 2018 for €16 million in a complex deal involving companies based in France, Luxembourg and Cyprus.

Although he is believed to be the buyer, Sarkisov’s name appears nowhere on the books of the company carrying out the purchase.

The company, called La Fleche, is believed to have bought three more real estate units from a second company which, it turns out, also belonged to Sarkisov.

The sale of the real estate to himself allowed the Russian to pocket a capital gain of €1.2 million, according to the paper.

Arnault — who runs luxury empire LVMH and is the world’s second-richest person after Elon Musk according to Forbes — is suspected of lending €18.3 million euros to Sarkisov for the deal.

He is then believed to have acquired La Fleche, effectively becoming the owner of the real estate portfolio.

The ownership change could have been designed “to hide the exact origin of the funds”, Le Monde quoted a Tracfin document as saying, as well as the identity of the “ultimate beneficiary”.

Investigators believe Sarkisov made two million euros from the operation, but they were still in the dark how much he had paid for the loan.

Contacted by AFP, LVMH declined to comment.

Le Monde, however, quoted a spokesman as saying that the operation had been “carried out with the strictest observance of the law”.

The paper also cited people close to Sarkisov as saying that the capital gain was “just a few hundred of thousands of euros”, and that the Russian had not been involved personally.

Le Monde said that according to “family lore”, Arnault has a special connection to Courchevel because he learned to ski there as a child and where he owns a mansion and a luxury hotel.

Hotel prices in the resort can reach several tens of thousands of euros per night, the paper noted.