SHARE
COPY LINK

STATISTICS

Pope calls couples who choose pets over having children ‘selfish’

Pope Francis risked the ire of the world's childless dog and cat owners Wednesday, suggesting people who substitute pets for kids exhibit "a certain selfishness".

Pope Francis blesses a child during his general audience at the Paul VI Hall at the Vatican on January 5, 2022 (Photo by Filippo MONTEFORTE / AFP)
Pope Francis criticises couples who have pets and children for being selfish. (Photo by Filippo MONTEFORTE / AFP)

Speaking on parenthood during a general audience at the Vatican, Francis lamented that pets “sometimes take the place of children” in society.

“Today… we see a form of selfishness,” said the pope. “We see that some people do not want to have a child.

“Sometimes they have one, and that’s it, but they have dogs and cats that take the place of children. This may make people laugh but it is a reality.”

READ ALSO:

The practice, said the head of the world’s 1.3 billion Catholics, “is a denial of fatherhood and motherhood and diminishes us, takes away our humanity”.

Thus, “civilisation grows old without humanity because we lose the richness of fatherhood and motherhood, and it is the country that suffers”, the pontiff said at the Paul VI Hall.

Francis has been photographed petting dogs, allowed a baby lamb to be draped over his shoulders during Epiphany in 2014 and even petted a tiger and a baby panther.

But while his predecessor, Benedict XVI, was a cat lover, Francis is not known to have a pet at his Vatican residence.

In 2014, Francis told Il Messaggero daily that having pets instead of children was “another phenomenon of cultural degradation”, and that emotional relationships with pets was “easier” than the “complex” relationship between parents and children.

On Wednesday, while inviting couples who are unable to have children for biological reasons to consider adoption, he urged potential parents “not to be afraid” in embarking on parenthood.

“Having a child is always a risk, but there is more risk in not having a child, in denying paternity,” he said.

The Argentine pontiff has in the past denounced the “demographic winter”, or falling birth rates in the developed world.

READ ALSO: Italy heading for demographic ‘crisis’ as population set to shrink by a fifth

Earlier this year, he criticised modern society, in which career and money-making trumps building a family for many, calling such mentality “gangrene for society”.

But a study by the Istat national statistics agency revealed that most Italians do want to have at least two children.

Experts pointed out that Italy’s high levels of unemployment, the broadly badly-paid, short-term work contracts, and a lack of affordable housing and childcare mean many young people put off starting a family as they think it’s unaffordable to do so in Italy.

Italy has for years recorded one of Europe’s lowest birth rates and is set to lose a fifth of its population in 50 years, further official data from Istat suggests.

The agency stated that the data marked “a potential picture of crisis”.

Italy’s population is expected to decrease from 59.6 million people in January 2020 to 47.6 million in 2070, it predicted, representing a drop of 20 percent.

In 2012, Italy saw births fall to the lowest level since it became a nation state in 1861, to around 534,000. Since then, new record lows have been established every year.

In 2020, the Italian population shrank by almost 400,000 due to the effects of the pandemic.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

MONEY

KEY POINTS: What is Italy’s government doing to help families?

As new statistics show the birth rate continues to fall in Italy, what additional support has been introduced for families in 2024 - and how much difference will it make?

KEY POINTS: What is Italy’s government doing to help families?

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni presents herself as a “Christian mother” defending traditional family values. But after a year and a half in power, what concrete financial measures has her government taken to support families in Italy?

The 2024 budget approved at the end of December was the Meloni administration’s first real opportunity to follow through with its pledges of support for families.

Amid the cost of living crisis, more financial support for working parents in particular was something many voters were hoping to see.

While the government did allocate more funds to policies supporting families this year, the final draft of the budget turned out to be a mixed bag.

Main budget changes affecting families in 2024:

  • The 2024 budget slightly increased the minimum amounts payable under the universal allowance (assegno unico e universale, a single, monthly means-tested payment that increases with each child.) See more details here.
  • For 2024 only, it also extended a deduction of pension contributions for women who have at least three children to mothers of two children, up until the month that their youngest child turns ten.
  • The maximum amount claimable towards nursery fees under the bonus asilo nido, or ‘nursery school bonus’, was increased for families with two children, one of whom must be born after the start of 2024.
  • A second month of parental leave in 2024 can be taken at 80 percent of the parent’s usual income, instead of the former 30 percent; this will drop to 60 percent in 2025.
  • VAT increased from 5 percent to 10 percent on formula milk and baby food, and from 5 percent to 22 percent on nappies and child car seats.

See a full breakdown of the maternity benefits available in Italy in 2024 and how to apply for them here.

The steep hike in VAT applied to nappies and baby formula has unsurprisingly been controversial, while some of the other measures fell short of what was initially reported based on earlier drafts of the budget law.

With most of the funding allocated to measures aimed at supporting larger families, media reports noted that it was hard to see how the government intended to encourage more young Italians to consider starting a family in the first place.

READ ALSO: The real reasons young Italians aren’t having kids

This has been a hot-button topic in Italian politics for years as the birth rate continues its steady descent. The latest figures from national statistics bureau Istat showed last week that the birth rate was near the lowest on record in 2023, with the number of births per Italian woman dropping further to 1.20, down from 1.24 in 2022. 

Against this backdrop, successive governments over the years have promised to make starting a family more financially viable for young Italians. But while there have been improvements – Italy had no form of child benefit at all until 2020, for instance – the support available to new parents is often deemed inadequate.

While surveys show that a large proportion of young Italian adults would like to start a family, they don’t see it as realistic: the rising cost of living, low and stagnant wages, and widespread workplace discrimination during pregnancy have long been cited as just some of the reasons why people put off having children or have fewer than they would like.

Economists say Italy’s shrinking population – on course to fall by one fifth by 2050 – will soon mean the country must implement either huge tax increases or severe pension cuts.

SHOW COMMENTS