SHARE
COPY LINK

READER QUESTIONS

Reader question: How can people who cannot be vaccinated use France’s vaccine pass?

With a vaccine pass required for a range of everyday activities in France including visiting bars, cinemas or going on long-distance train trips, what is the situation for those who cannot be vaccinated for medical reasons?

A doctor fills a syring with an anti-Covid vaccine.
A doctor fills a syring with an anti-Covid vaccine. In France, some people can obtain a medical exemption to vaccination and continue using the health pass. (Photo: Fred Tanneau/AFP)

Question: I have a serious medical problem that means I cannot be vaccinated, does that mean I have to accept having a severely restricted lifestyle in France for the foreseeable future?

The French government has been clear since it introduced the health passport that one of the goals is to push people into getting the vaccine, by making life more complicated for the unvaccinated.

This will become stricter when France’s health pass becomes a vaccine pass, with no option for the unvaccinated to get tested instead.

The general principle is that activities like working (with the exception of certain professions), commuting or visiting shops do not need a health or vaccine pass, but for anything fun like getting dinner and drinks with friends, going to the theatre or cinema or getting a train to another part of France, the pass is required. 

But what about those who might want to be vaccinated but cannot for medical reasons?

The Decree that enshrined the health passport into law back in the summer does contain provision for those who cannot be vaccinated.

It is possible to obtain a certificate from your doctor declaring your status as unvaccinated for medical reasons – but only if you fit one of the conditions outlined in the decree.

Those who fit these criteria can obtain an attestation de contre-indication from their doctor.

The decree introducing the vaccine pass adds some detail to this.

Individual doctors can issue an attestation de contre-indication if the patient fits one of the listed criteria below. The patient then sends the attestation to Assurance Maladie, who check the conditions and then issue a QR code that can be scanned into the Tous Anti Covid app and uses as a vaccine pass in order the access bars, cafés etc. 

The conditions outlined by the decree to qualify for this are;

  • A documented history of allergy to one of the components of the vaccines
  • Anaphylaxis of at least grade 2 after the first dose injection
  • A documented history of capillary leakage problems
  • History of pediatric multi-systemic inflammatory syndrome after suffering from Covid
  • A recommendation following a multi-disciplinary medical consultation not to administer a second dose following a severe reaction to the first dose eg myocarditis, Guillan-Barré syndrome

There are also some conditions that have a temporary medical contra-indication

  • Treatment with anti-SARS-CoV-2 monoclonal antibodies
  • Myocarditis or pericarditis that occurred prior to vaccination and is still evolving

For people with severely compromised immune systems, such as cancer patients, the general advice is to get vaccinated, and many have been given an extra dose of the vaccine – in addition to the booster – to ensure adequate protection.

Pregnant women are advised to get the vaccination since there is increasing evidence that pregnant women are more likely to develop the most severe forms of the virus – pregnant cabinet minister Olivia Gregoire was  vaccinated live on TV by her colleague Olivier Véran in order to highlight the need for mothers-to-be to get vaccinated.

This article is not intended as a substitute for medical advice – if you are in any doubt about whether you should get vaccinated, or have concerns about side effects, you should of course consult your doctor.

Member comments

  1. Hi — I’m in the US, traveling to Paris in early September. On Aug. 10, I emailed the signed form, passport, CDC vaccination certification, etc. to the email address provided in your article and by my hotel in Paris in order to get uploaded into the health pass system. I immediately received a computer generated response saying my email and attachments had been received, but nothing since. Anyone with anything to share on them actually getting back with the health pass QR code and all that? Thanks. Jeff

    1. I don’t believe they’re processing health pass QR codes via email anymore. Your best bet is to visit a pharmacy upon arrival, and have them convert your CDC-issued vaccine card into a QR code, which you can then upload into the TousAntiCovid app. The entire process took less than five minutes for us at our local pharmacy in Nice, FR.

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

WORK PERMITS

Reader question: How long will it take to renew my Swiss permit?

The answer to this question, which is, naturally, of concern to foreign nationals living in Switzerland, depends on several factors.

Reader question: How long will it take to renew my Swiss permit?

The first thing to consider is what kind of work/residency permit you have, as different rules apply.

Let’s look at the long-term B permits and permanent residency C permits that most foreign nationals living in Switzerland are likely to have.

Typically in both of these cases, you will receive a letter from local authorities approximately six weeks before the deadline reminding you to renew.

There will also be an application form that you will need to fill out, which must be submitted to your commune of residence no earlier than three months and no later than two weeks prior to the expiration date.

READ ALSO: When and how should you renew your Swiss residence permit?

Some cantons also impose additional rules for certain categories of foreigners. 

In Geneva, for instance, non-EU/EFTA spouses of B or C permit holders must include a French language certificate if it had not yet been done previously.

Further, for nationals of a non-EU/EFTA state who depend on social assistance for an amount equal to or greater than 50,000 francs for a single person or 80,000 francs for a household of several people, a letter indicating the reasons for the dependence on government aid and the steps taken to get out of it must be submitted.

In Vaud, “your situation and your degree of integration are examined, in particular your financial autonomy”.

Your canton may have other special rules in place as well, so it’s good to find them out beforehand, allowing you to submit all the necessary paperwork with your renewal application.

How long does the renewal process take?

The extension of your current permit may depend on various factors set by your canton which, in turn, may determine how long the renewal process will take.

In straightforward cases, you will receive the renewal within two to four weeks. However, this timeline is not set in stone.

It may happen that the new permit is not immediately issued, because the volumes of applications to be processed are very large, especially in cantons with a sizeable foreign population like Geneva, Zurich, Basel, and Vaud.

And the stricter the regulations (as mentioned above), the longer the process is likely to take.

Can authorities refuse to extend your permit?

Yes, that can happen under certain circumstances.

For instance, short-term L or B permits that are tied to a particular job, which ends within the specified time period (usually up to a year), will expire when the contract is over.

As non-EU / EFTA nationals are subject to a quota system, their work permits are not automatically renewed either.

Other reasons include lack of integration or dependence on welfare, as mentioned above. Also, if you’ve committed serious crimes or other infractions, you can kiss your permit goodbye.

And if you forgot to apply for renewal in the first place, then you forfeit your right to the permit.

The authorities could take special circumstances, such as serious illness, a debilitating accident, or another extreme situation into consideration and make an exception, but you shouldn’t count on that.

READ ALSO: Can Swiss authorities refuse to renew work permits — and for what reasons?

What if you applied on time and provided all the required documentation, but your permit expired before a new one was issued?

The good news is that, if you are a holder of either a long-term B or settlement C permit, your rights are protected while you wait for the renewal.

You can continue to work and live in Switzerland as before.

Under the Foreign Nationals and Integration Act, “when the person concerned has submitted an application to extend a permit, he or she is authorised to stay in Switzerland during the procedure, provided that no other decision has been taken”.

SHOW COMMENTS