SHARE
COPY LINK

ORGAN TRANSPLANT

‘If I’m not careful, it’ll end badly’: Covid fears haunt Spain’s transplant patients despite vaccines

Wearing a face mask and social distancing were a part of Magdalena Moskal's immunosuppressed life, long before the coronavirus pandemic hit.

'If I'm not careful, it'll end badly': Covid fears haunt Spain's transplant patients despite vaccines
Photo: PIERRE-PHILIPPE MARCOU / AFP

The 36-year-old Madrid resident had a double lung transplant in 2008 to tackle her cystic fibrosis, a genetic disorder in which thick secretions build up in the lungs, making it difficult to breathe.

“Suddenly everyone was living my reality,” she said in a soft voice, looking back on the rush to adopt anti-Covid precautions early last year.

Now, as Covid vaccine rollouts gain momentum, many people are returning to gyms, cinemas and sports venues after more than a year of on-off restrictions.

But for Moskal and thousands like her in Spain, the world leader in organ transplants, a worry-free return to normal life still feels a long way off.

Transplant patients’ immune response is suppressed on purpose with daily medication to prevent the body attacking the new organ.

They also do not respond to vaccines in the same way as other people.

So, warned Moskal, organ donation recipients will only be able to relax when “100 percent of the population is vaccinated”.

“If I am here, it is because I have always taken care of myself. If I am not careful, it will end badly,” Moskal, who trained in the law and has been happy to work at home, told AFP.

‘Not like others’

Twenty-five year-old Andrea López Robles, a student who lives in the Spanish capital too and received a life-saving liver transplant when she was just two, also feels she cannot let down her guard.

“Until everyone is vaccinated, I don’t think I can say ‘goodbye’ to all the precautions,” she said in an interview with AFP.

Andrea López Robles received a life-saving liver transplant when she was just two years old. Photo by OSCAR DEL POZO / AFP

READ ALSO: Pandemic forces Spain’s hospitals to cancel 570,000 surgeries

She has not taken public transport since the start of the pandemic in Spain in March 2020 and avoids large gatherings as much as possible.

“I almost died. I can’t do anything stupid,” Robles added, hand sanitiser attached to her handbag and only lowering her high-filtration FFP2 face mask to drink her fruit juice.

“I am aware that I have to take care of myself, that I am not like others.”

Uncertainty, despite vaccination

For more than three decades, Spain has been carrying out more organ transplants than anywhere else in the world.

It has a highly developed network, with a transplant coordinator present in every hospital.

Over 116,000 transplants have been carried out since 1989, in what is a source of national pride.

There were 48.9 organ donors per million inhabitants in Spain in 2019, its highest number ever.

That compared to 29.4 million in France and 36.1 million in the United States, according to the Spanish health ministry’s National Transplant Organisation.

However, organ transplant patients who have been vaccinated against Covid-19 cannot be certain of their immunity.

A study published in May by the Journal of the American Medical Association found that only 54 percent of 658 transplant patients who received two doses of either the Moderna or Pfizer vaccine produced Covid-19 antibodies.

Moskal was immunised against Covid in May but does not know if her body has produced the antibodies that vaccines are meant to trigger.

“A significant percentage of transplant patients develop absolutely no antibodies or defensive cells after being vaccinated against the coronavirus,” said Estela Paz Artal, head of the immunology department at Madrid’s Hospital 12 de Octubre.

But she said that it was important for a transplant patient to get vaccinated because “however weak” their immune response is, this is “preferable to no vaccination”.

The Covid-19 mortality rate for transplant patients stands at 21 percent, compared to around 2.0 percent for the general population, the National Transplant Organisation says.

‘Monastic life’

Most transplant patients are well aware of the risks.

Retired IT engineer Rafael Garcia (pictured below), 45, said the roughly 100 pills that he must take daily since having a double lung transplant five years ago remind him he has to take care of himself “every day, every hour”.

Photo by OSCAR DEL POZO / AFP

He said he leads a “monastic life” with his wife, living as if he were not vaccinated, although he has been.

He buys groceries online and wears face masks outside even if nobody is nearby.

Under Spain’s Covid vaccination programme, transplant patients were given priority and health authorities are mulling giving them booster shots.

“We will have to look for alternatives and increase the effectiveness of the vaccine for this group of patients,” said National Transplant Organisation head, Beatriz Dominguez-Gil.

“For the time being, they must maintain self-protection measures. Like everyone else, but in their case even more,” she added.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

COVID-19: ESSENTIAL INFO

How unvaccinated people can use France’s health passport

A health passport is now required to access a range of venues in France including bars, cafés, tourist sites and long-distance travel. For those who are not yet fully vaccinated, accessing the passport is still possible, but more complicated. Here's how it works.

How unvaccinated people can use France's health passport
Photo: Geoffroy van der Hasselt/AFP

The French government has been clear that part of the intention of the pass sanitaire (health passport) is to push people into being vaccinated and as such daily life in France is now more complicated for those who are not vaccinated.

But for those who either cannot be vaccinated or have not yet completed the full vaccination course, it is still possible to access the passport.

EXPLAINED When and where you need the French health passport

Proof

The health passport requires one of three things; proof of fully vaccinated status, proof of a recent negative Covid test or proof of recent recovery from Covid.

‘Fully vaccinated’ here means having a vaccine approved by the European Medicines Agency (Pfizer, Moderna, AstraZeneca – including Covishield – or Johnson & Johnson) so those who received a Sinopharm or Sputnik vaccine do not count as ‘vaccinated’ under French rules. You also need to be at least seven days post your final dose of the vaccine.

Most people have two doses of the vaccine, but ‘fully vaccinated’ can also mean a single dose of Johnson & Johnson, a single vaccine dose if you have previously had Covid or three doses if you are severely immunosuppressed.

Those vaccinated outside France may need to convert their certificates to make sure they are compatible with the French app – click HERE if you were vaccinated in the UK or HERE if you were vaccinated in the USA.

Covid recovery

If you have recently recovered from Covid you will need a positive Covid test that is no more than six months old. If you did not have a test while you were ill, or had Covid more than six months ago, you cannot use this route.

Recent negative test

If you are going for the testing option, there are some stipulations;

  • The test must be no more than 72 hours old (expanded from 48 hours initially) so if you intend to rely on testing you will need regular tests
  • The test must be taken in France, the app does not recognise foreign test certificates
  • The test can be either a PCR or antigen test. Home-testing kits can be used, but only – the health minister says – if done under the supervision of a pharmacist or medical professional (so it seems that you may as well get the pharmacist to do the test).

How to get a test

Some good news for those travelling from the UK, France’s testing system is much less chaotic and considerably less expensive than the UK’s and tests are relatively easy to access.

You can find tests at either medical testing labs, pharmacies or pop-up testing centres – either a PCR or an antigen test works with the health passport.

Medical labs require advance booking but most pharmacies advertise tests sans rendez-vous (without appointment) and pop-up testing centres (which are often just a gazebo on a street corner) operate on a walk-in basis.

Almost all pharmacies offer tests and even quite small French towns generally have at least one pharmacy, and you can also book tests online either via the medical app Doctolib or at sante.fr.

READ ALSO Vital French vocab to get a Covid test

Results for PCR tests are sent out later via email or SMS (usually within 24 hours) while for antigen tests they are generally given on the spot, although some pharmacies send them via SMS, this should not take more than 30 minutes.

How much?

At present all tests are free for residents of France, but from September ‘convenience tests’ for the unvaccinated will need to be paid for. Tests for any reason for vaccinated residents of France will continue to be free, and tests for those with symptoms or who are contact cases will be free for all residents.

Tourists and visitors to France need to pay for their tests.

Costs are capped by the French government at;

PCR – €49

Antigen – €29

What about children?

Children under the age of 12 are exempt from the health pass requirement.

Those aged between 12 and 18 are required to use it, but have a grace period until September 30th to allow them time to get vaccinated, after that they will need to show a health pass to access relevant venues.

France, along with quite a few other European countries, is currently vaccinating all over 12s, but if you are travelling from October from a country where the vaccine is not available to under 18s, then your children will need a test to access the health pass.

SHOW COMMENTS