SHARE
COPY LINK

IMMIGRATION

US lecturer in Malmö fined for negligence after university’s work permit error

An American academic at Malmö University has been hit with legal fees and fines worth more than a month's salary after a migration court found her guilty of negligence for relying on information from the university's human resources department about her work permit.

US lecturer in Malmö fined for negligence after university's work permit error
Erin Cory and her daughter Zia. Photo: Private

Erin Cory, a senior lecturer at Malmö University, was still living in Denmark when she started working at the university, and the university’s human resources department mistakenly believed that she did not require a work permit. 

The department managed her salary and tax payments according to the deal between Denmark and Sweden, but did not ask her to apply for a work permit.

According to court documents seen by The Local, university staff said they assumed that Erin was a Danish citizen because she lived in Denmark and was married to a Dane, although she had submitted her US passport during the recruitment process.

While Danes and other EU nationals do not need a work permit to work in Sweden, as a third country national Erin did need one, but when she asked her university if there was anything she needed to do, she says she was told that there wasn’t.

It was only when she gained a permanent position as a senior lecturer, decided to move to Sweden and applied for residency that she discovered that she had been working without the required permit.

Earlier this month, the Court of Migration ruled that she had been negligent in not checking that the university was correct, finding her guilty of a crime under Swedish immigration law. She was ordered to pay fines totalling 20,000 kronor as well as further legal fees.

“Erin Cory could easily have checked whether a work permit was required, by, for example, checking the website of the Swedish Migration Agency,” the judgement read.

“This means that Erin Cory has been negligent. This judgement is not affected by the fact that the university gave reassurances, and also not by the fact that it is the responsibility of an employer to cooperate on work permit applications.”

Cory told The Local that the fines and legal fees would “take me well up over a month’s pay”.

“What’s mystifying to me is that the university is a state institution, so basically, the state is saying, ‘you trusted the state, you shouldn’t have trusted the state, and so now the state is going to punish you’. It’s confusing logic,” she added.

Cory’s friends organised a crowdfunding campaign to cover the fees, which on Wednesday raised 51,918 kronor, well ahead of the 40,000 kronor target, meaning she will at least not be out of pocket. She plans to donate any remainder to a Malmö cultural centre and an organisation supporting foreigners who face work permit issues.

Several of the HR staff and management at Malmö University have already been found negligent, and Cory said that the university had been helpful, even though they have not offered her help with legal fees. 

“To be honest with you, my communication with the Dean and the Vice-Chancellor has been fantastic, they’ve been as supportive as they can be, within the parameters of what they are legally able to do,” she said. 

But she said she now feared that she might face problems when extending her work permit this autumn, because the issue will show up on her file.

“Highly skilled labourers in Sweden get deported all the time for mistakes on the part of their employers,” she said. “I am concerned about what this will mean for my work life and personal life in the long run.”

Cory was living in Denmark and teaching part-time at a Danish university when she was offered a post-doc position in Malmö in Refugee Migration and Media Studies in 2017. When she later received a permanent position and decided to move to Sweden, the problem of her missing permit was discovered. She then had to take leave from her lecturing at Malmö while she tried to get residency in Sweden, which she eventually did in early 2019. 

In 2018 she was called to the police station in Malmö for an interview. The following year, unbeknownst to her, the university was fined for negligence. It was only in November last year when she received a court summons, that she realised that she herself might also risk punishment. 

She is now worried about the consequences if she loses her Swedish residency and is forced to return to the US.

“I would hate to lose my job because I am passionate about my field, and feel I have ended up in exactly the kind of department I would like to work in for the rest of my career,” she told The Local.

“If the verdict affects my ability to work and live in Sweden, I also risk being separated from my daughter, who is almost six. The idea of being forced to live apart from her is absolutely unbearable.”

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

READER QUESTIONS

Do foreigners in Sweden have to carry their residence cards?

Foreign residents in Sweden who are granted residence permits are issued with a residence card or 'uppehållstillstånd'. Who does this apply to and are they obliged to carry the card all the time?

Do foreigners in Sweden have to carry their residence cards?

What is an uppehållstillstånd

Firstly, an uppehållstillstånd or residence permit is required for legal residence in Sweden for non-EU citizens, as well as EU citizens without EU right of residence.

Note that this is not the same as an uppehållskort, which is for non-EU citizens living with a non-Swedish EU citizen, nor is it the same as an intyg om permanent uppehållsrätt for EU citizens or uppehållsstatus for Brits here under the rules of the withdrawal agreement.

Residence permits are granted to those wanting to work, study or live in Sweden, including those who came to the country as family members of other residents or as refugees.

The criteria you must fulfil to be granted a residence permit depend on the reason you are in Sweden and your personal situation.

If you are granted a residence permit for Sweden, you will be issued with a residence card or uppehållstillståndskort, as documentation of your residence rights.

The card itself is a plastic card the size of a credit card and displays your photo. It also includes a chip containing your biometric data. You will be required to attend an appointment to submit biometric details to the Migration Agency, either at one of its offices or at your closest Swedish embassy or consulate, if you’re applying from outside the country, after which the agency will be able to produce your residence card.

So, do I need to carry the card with me at all times? 

Technically, no, but it’s best to always know where it is, as you will need to be able to show it when asked. 

A press officer at Sweden’s Migration Agency told The Local that it’s a good idea to carry it with you at all times, although there’s no specific requirement for residence permit holders to do so.

“We can’t comment exactly on the situations in which other authorities, such as the police or healthcare services would need to see your residence permit card, but our general advice is that it’s a good idea to carry your residence card with you at all times, like any other form of ID, such as a driving licence, for example,” she said.

According to the Migration Agency’s website, you should always have it with you when in contact with Swedish authorities or healthcare, as it proves that you have the right to live in Sweden.

“According to the Aliens Act, foreigners in Sweden must show a passport or other document showing they have the right to live in Sweden, when asked by a police officer,” police press officer Irene Sokolow told The Local.

“[The foreigner] is responsible for proving their right to be in Sweden, as well as their identity and the day and time they arrived in Sweden, if relevant. They are, however, not required to carry their identity card or passport with them.”

One situation where you should have your card with you is when travelling over the Swedish border, where you should always present it to border police along with your passport. This ensures you’ll be registered correctly as a resident when exiting or re-entering the country, rather than as a tourist.

One reason why this is important is that non-EU residents can only visit Schengen for 90 days in every 180-day period without needing a residence permit or other visa, so if you’re falsely registered as entering Sweden as a visitor, this 90-day countdown will start. 

If you’re then discovered living in Sweden past the 90-day deadline, your false registration as a tourist could lead to you being branded an overstayer, which could affect your chances of getting a residence permit in the future, as well as your chances of being allowed to enter other Schengen countries.

Where else might I be asked to show my card?

Sweden’s police are also able to carry out so-called inre utlänningskontroller, special controls to identify people living in Sweden illegally, if they have reason to believe the person in question does not have a permit or visa to live in Sweden.

These can take place anywhere within Sweden, including at workplaces suspected of hiring people without valid residence permits, so at least in theory, you could be stopped by police anywhere in the country and asked to show your residence permit if they have reason to believe you’re living here illegally.

“When an inre utlänningskontroll is carried out and the person in question does not have any such documents with them, the police can check their status with the Migration Agency,” Sokolow told The Local.

Legally, the police have the power to confiscate your passport or other ID document if you can’t prove you have the right to be in Sweden when asked, although this will be returned to you when you provide them with a valid residence permit card or when they receive other proof that you have the right to be in the country.

SHOW COMMENTS