SHARE
COPY LINK

HEALTH

‘We’re bucking the trend’: Italy eases Covid rules despite experts’ warnings

Italy's health ministry on Friday announced an easing of coronavirus restrictions in many regions, despite warnings from public health experts that rules should be tightened, and concern about the accuracy of some data.

'We're bucking the trend': Italy eases Covid rules despite experts' warnings
Bars and restaurants can reopen until 6pm in Italy's yellow zones. Photo: AFP

Based on the latest regional contagion data reported by the Health Ministry and Higher Health Institute, coronavirus risk levels will be downgraded from Monday in most parts of the country.

All but five of Italy's regions will turn “yellow” under the colour-coded system of yellow, orange and red that indicates  coronavirus risk and the restrictions in place.

Veneto, the region around Venice, is to go from an orange to a yellow zone, which allows the daytime reopening of bars and restaurants and greater freedom to travel within the region.

Calabria in the south and Emilia-Romagna in the north were also downgraded from orange to yellow.

READ ALSO: Have Italy's official Covid-19 figures been massively under-reported?

The Minister of Health, Roberto Speranza, is set to sign a ordinance that comes into effect on Monday Fbruary 1st.

From that date, the regions of Puglia, Sardinia, Sicily, Umbria and the autonomous province of Bolzano will be in the orange zone.
 
All the other regions and autonomous provinces are in the yellow zone.
 
(For more details on rules in each zone and the current restrictions in place until Sunday, click here.)

Changes to the zones under Italy's regional tiered system of restrictions are announced weekly, shortly after a Health Ministry report is published on Friday evenings.

Meanwhile, other countries in Europe are looking at hardening restrictions.

The World Health Organization's European branch warned on Thursday that it was “too early to ease up” due to a “still very high” presence of the virus.

“Yes, Italy is bucking the trend,” said Walter Ricciardi, a public health expert who advises Italy's health minister on the pandemic.

He told AFP lockdown measures adopted in Italy over Christmas and New Year had helped stabilise virus numbers, without lowering them.

Nevertheless, “right now it is extremely difficult to propose stricter measures due to resistance from both politicians and public opinion”, Ricciardi said.

Italy was placed under a series of strict lockdowns over the Christmas holiday period. Photo: AFP

Even if politically unpalatable, Ricciardi said the country would benefit from a “brief stiffening” of virus rules, as well as more centralised decision-making on the pandemic.

The relaxtion comes as a report from Italian intelligence agencies reportedly found problems with Italy's data on infection rates.

A dossier given to outgoing prime minister Giuseppe Conte reportedly stated that a change to the way test results were reported, along with regional inconsistencies in reporting methodology, has created “chaos”.

This means the infection rate since mid-November is thought to be underestimated by as much as 50 percent, reports stated.

Ricciardi also suggested that Italy's largely decentralised response to the pandemic – with regions left in charge of vaccinations, with mixed results – needed fixing.

“We need a clearer chain of command… a decisive step-change in management with a government fully in charge, ready to centralise decisions in its hands,” Ricciardi said.

Politicians are currently preoccupied with the government crisis, deepened by this week's resignation of Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte.

EXPLAINED: Why has Italy's prime minister resigned and what happens now?

His cabinet remains in charge, but only in a caretaker function.

“This is a war … and if we were to compare it to World War II, we are not in 1945, but in 1941,” Ricciardi said, warning that victory was still far off, and that the political crisis needed to be solved quickly.

“If we don't have a government with full powers … it is clear that the situation in Italy risks becoming even more critical,” he added.

According to GIMBE, an independent think tank, Italy had 799 virus cases per 100,000 inhabitants in the January 20-26 period.

Until that number is brought to below 50 cases, it would be impossible to ensure effective virus test and tracing procedures, Ricciardi warned.

Member comments

  1. Expect another lockdown in March due to this hasty and ill-conceived loosening of restrictions. With new variants circulating, the R number rising and people now congregating to eat, drink and be merry, the virus will take hold.

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

BREXIT

‘In the dark’: Why Brits in Italy are still unable to prove rights to free healthcare

Despite UK and Italian authorities confirming that British residents covered by post-Brexit rules are entitled to healthcare in Italy, many still face "significant problems" in accessing it, the British government has said.

'In the dark': Why Brits in Italy are still unable to prove rights to free healthcare

Cancer patients are among those in need of treatment but unable to access the Italian national health service amid confusion over post-Brexit rules, campaigners say, after clarifications from the UK and Italian governments have so far failed to resolve bureaucratic deadlocks at local authority level.

Since the end of the Brexit transition period in 2021, many British nationals resident in Italy covered by the Withdrawal Agreement (WA) have reported difficulties in proving their right to free healthcare under the Italian public system.

The problem was exacerbated this year after the Italian government in January hiked the minimum annual fee for ‘voluntary’ healthcare registration from €387 to €2,000, which many said they were unable to pay.

The British government in February stepped in to clarify that UK nationals covered by the WA should not be subject to charges for healthcare, and on its Living in Italy website it advised those affected to show their local health authority office (Azienda Sanitaria Locale, or ASL) an official note published by the Italian health ministry on February 15th which sets out their rights (find it here, in Italian.)

WA beneficiaries “can compulsorily enrol (iscrizione obbligatoria) with the Italian National Health System,” states the final section, pointing out that the deal, “in Article 23, provides for equal treatment with domestic nationals.”

But for some local health officials, even this written confirmation does not appear to be enough to clear up the confusion.

READ ALSO: ‘Life or death situation’: Brits facing high Italian healthcare costs amid rule change uncertainty

The UK government on Friday, May 17th, updated its guidance to say it had become aware that “some beneficiaries of the Withdrawal Agreement are facing significant problems accessing health services and renewing their healthcare cards,” despite its advice to show local health authorities the official note.

British nationals continue to report that local health authorities around Italy remain unwilling to issue them with a health card, while campaigners say the situation is further complicated for some by the fact that Italian authorities have also refused to issue proof of their permanent residency status, which entitles them to free healthcare.

This was the case for Graham Beresford, a British citizen living in Abruzzo who has been diagnosed with a rare cancer and remains unable to access the free healthcare he is entitled to, as he says local authorities don’t understand the post-Brexit rules.

Graham told The Local in April that the government’s clarifications on the issue had made little difference – his ASL continues to demand he pay the 2,000-euro charge.

READ ALSO: Can I get a refund after wrongly paying Italy’s €2,000 healthcare fee?

“Every time I go to my ASL office, I always feel like I’m dismissed,” Graham said. “I told the ASL worker I need medication for my cancer and she replied lots of people come in here with sob stories.

“There genuinely seems to be no compassion whatsoever.”

Graham’s story was reported in The Guardian on May 12th ahead of UK foreign secretary David Cameron’s first major meeting with European commission vice-president Maroš Šefčovič to discuss post-Brexit relations.

Campaigners also wrote to Cameron in April to appeal for help with the “desperate” situation faced by those unable to access care in Italy.

In its update to the Living in Italy website on Friday, the British government stated: “Since [the health ministry’s note] was published, and particularly in recent days and weeks, it has become clear to us that not all Italian authorities are consistently following this guidance.”

“We are urgently speaking to all relevant parts of the Italian government to clarify the situation so that we can give clear advice to those affected as soon as possible. 

“We also know that this problem is linked to the many difficulties some are experiencing with obtaining an attestazione di soggiorno permanente and/or the Carta di Soggiorno permanente. We are working to help with these issues too.

“We will update this page as soon as we have further news.”

READ ALSO: ‘We are desperate’: Why the UK must help Britons with Italian healthcare charges

Clarissa Killwick from Beyond Brexit, a group for UK citizens in Italy, said the situation “should never have been allowed to happen” and that there had been “a series of communication failures and inconsistencies.”

“We’re not far short of five months after the introduction of the €2,000 new minimum for voluntary contributions and there is still no clarity,” she added.

“There are fraught exchanges in public offices because people on both sides of the counter are in the dark or with conflicting information.

“People need information they can rely on, unequivocally. What do you say to someone who is waiting for an operation but has no idea what is going on?”

SHOW COMMENTS