SHARE
COPY LINK

MUSIC

‘A huge, huge mistake’: star German tenor makes emotional plea to bring back live music

German tenor Jonas Kaufmann says not being able to perform in front of a live audience for months has been hugely detrimental for musicians who thrive on connecting with real people.

'A huge, huge mistake': star German tenor makes emotional plea to bring back live music
Kaufmann performs in Vienna in summer 2020. Photo: DPA

“What we miss is this connection and it doesn't matter if they wear masks or whatever,” the 51-year-old told AFP on Thursday after performing at Madrid's Teatro Real opera house.

“I would probably feel them, sense them even if they were behind a curtain.

But they are there. This is what really matters,” added the tenor, whose last performance before an audience was in November in Denmark.

While many of the world's major venues are shut, Spain's main opera house has remained open — although with smaller audiences and safety measures such as the mandatory use of face masks — since July.

SEE ALSO: Could opera houses reopen in Germany at full capacity?

“For me, being on tour all year round, it feels like it has  been forever since I had the experience of an audience in front of me,” said Kaufmann, adding he was “extremely excited and thrilled” to perform in Madrid.

Some opera houses have staged full operas to empty theatres for television or online broadcast but Kaufmann said it was no substitute for a live audience.

“Usually there is the applause and then you relax and start smiling at you take a bow, but if there is just this eternal silence what can you do? It's embarrassing really,” he said earlier during a press conference.

“So my apologies. Audience we need you and we need you now more than ever,” he added.

“People needed distraction, people needed something to at least forget for a couple of hours all their sorrows. If you take that away and at the same time, when you take away pretty much everything else, I think it's a huge, huge mistake.”

'High rate of suicides'

Kaufmann warned that the devastating economic impact on musicians, many of whom are struggling to make ends meets as shows are cancelled, is taking a psychological toll.

 

“I know about a quite high rate of suicides in our family of musicians because they don't see any future and it is really, really terrible,” he said,

Some are “vulnerable souls” who unfortunately “don't see any other exit, which is very sad,” Kauffmann said.

Kaufmann, who the New York Times once called the “most important, versatile tenor of his generation”, said he feels “very privileged” to still be able to perform.

“There are maybe two dozen singers worldwide who are in this privileged position,” he said.

Kaufmann urged the authorities to reopen concert halls and other cultural institutions and be inventive to revive the arts.

“We are not the politicians… we are only voices and we need others to help” so that after the pandemic “we find a cultural landscape that is similar to what we have left when this whole crisis started,” he said.

“This is the first time that music is been silenced in a time of crisis,” he added.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

FACE MASKS

When will Spain scrap face masks in hospitals and pharmacies?

Despite other Covid-19 restrictions being lifted long ago, it is still mandatory to wear a face mask in Spanish hospitals, pharmacies and other health centres. So is this rule set to change anytime soon? Many health experts think it should.

When will Spain scrap face masks in hospitals and pharmacies?

Spanish society has taken mask wearing quite seriously during the Covid-19 pandemic, but face coverings haven’t been compulsory in most indoor public settings since April 20th 2022.

Mandatory mask wearing on public transport, at opticians and in hearing centers also ended in February 2023.

However, wearing a mask is still necessary in medical settings – specifically in hospitals, other health-related centres and pharmacies.

This is the last Covid measure still in place in Spain more than three yars since the pandemic began.

Admittedly, while mask wearing in hospital settings is still strictly enforced, in many pharmacies around Spain this rule has become a little more lax.

But how much longer will this Covid rule continue?

READ ALSO: Spain announces end of public transport face mask rule

Ministry of Health

The government are remaining tightlipped. Spain’s Ministry of Health, when asked by El Mundo newspaper how long masks will be mandatory in medical settings, gave a vague non-comital response: “In Spain, the position is that we should try to use masks in healthcare centres and services as a general rule, regardless of whether there is Covid or not, and from there exceptions can be made or particular situations can be assessed.”

It’s hardly a definitive answer. According to the official government BOE that eliminated masks on public transport (as well as opticians) in February, which you can find here, the justification for keeping them in medical settings was: “The mandatory use of masks is maintained in healthcare centres and services, and pharmacies, since these are areas where there may be a greater concentration of vulnerable people and where the risk of serious illness is greater and, what is more, where the probability of transmission is higher, since they are places where there may be a greater number of people with transmissible respiratory infections, in addition to the COVID-19.”

Expert opinion

Many medical experts are now calling for the lifting of this last pandemic measure and a return to pre-pandemic normality.

The Spanish Society of Immunology certainly believes so. “We have been wearing masks when there has been a lot of circulation of viruses, and now that it has stopped circulating, I think the removal of the masks could be considered,” Marcos López Hoyos, the society’s president, said in an interview with Spanish news outlet Antena3.

Hoyos pointed to the fact that society now has vaccine immunity and medicines that we did not have at the beginning of the pandemic. That said, he also insisted that we must “be aware that at a given moment you can go back, at a time of an important resurgence.”

The Spanish Society of Immunology now believes that Covid-19 should be managed like any other respiratory virus “because the health situation is no longer so emergency,” and recommends that mask use goes back to the pre-pandemic norm, that is, wearing them only in very specific situations.

Experts believe mask wearing should still be mandatory in ICUs and during surgery, but not in all hospital settings necessarily, Photo: ANDER GILLENEA/AFP
 

“Everyone puts on a mask when they enter an ICU, or when they enter a premature unit, or when they are in an operating room, or in a surgical area,” virologist Raúl Ortiz de Lejarazu explained. 

“Masks have played an important role when the incidence of the virus was very high; but when it is very low, the use of masks has practically no importance because it is something that is not worn continuously and throughout the day we will have the opportunity, at home or elsewhere, to get infected,” he added.

The experts are not in complete consensus, however, and some suggest caution and waiting for direction from global bodies before removing medical mask mandates. Amós García, an epidemiologist and member of the Permanent Group for Europe of the World Health Organization (WHO), told Antena3 that “it would be appropriate to be cautious and wait for the WHO to rule on the matter.”

Óscar Zurriaga, president of the Spanish Society of Epidemiology (SEE), has defended maintaining the mask measures on the grounds of protecting vulnerable patients: “Regardless of Covid, the maintenance of masks is an additional measure against this virus and other respiratory viruses, which means that for vulnerable people this measure can be favourable, especially considering that it is an area in which people with all kinds of vulnerability go and in which different pathogens flourish,” he told El Mundo.

Mask order

Despite many experts calling for the end of mask use in hospitals and pharmacies, the vague statements of the Health Ministry, and the lifting off mask mandates in other settings if Spain’s Ministry of Finance is anything to go by, we might be wearing masks for a while longer.

The Ministry recently spent around €50,000 to buy 2 million surgical masks for its staff, despite them not being mandatory anymore, which would suggest the government is erring on the side of caution and unlikely to lift mask requirements in medical centres.

Spain was the last country in the EU to lift the indoor mask requirement, and in some European countries, most recently Portugal, masks have also been dropped in health centres.

According to recent figures from the Health Ministry, the percentage of ICU beds in Spain occupied by patients with Covid-19 is less than 2 percent (1.31 percent), and general hospital beds 1.73 percent. The cumulative incidence for the last 14 days in people over 60 years of age was 70.45.

SHOW COMMENTS