SHARE
COPY LINK

WAR

Armistice Day: How France chose its Unknown Soldier

Exactly 100 years ago on Wednesday, the bodies of two nameless soldiers taken from the quagmire of the Western Front - one French and one British - were honoured simultaneously at the Arc de Triomphe in Paris and in London's Westminster Abbey.

Armistice Day: How France chose its Unknown Soldier
Activists lay flowers on the tomb of the Unknown Soldier during a gathering to mark the 50th anniversary of the first demonstration of French feminist movement Mouvement de Liberation des Femmes (MLF

The tomb of the unknown warrior became a powerful and evocative symbol of the shocking loss of life in World War I.

But where did the idea of anonymous commemoration come from? And out of the some 1.4 million fallen French troops, and 900,000 British, how were the two soldiers chosen?

Kipling's grief

The idea of commemorating an unknown soldier emerged when the war was still at it height.

In 1916 English clergyman David Railton came across a grave marked “An Unknown British Soldier” in the back garden of a house when he was on the Western Front.

So many troops had been blown to bits or mutilated beyond recognition that they were impossible to identify.

Four years later Railton won the support of the Dean of Westminster, Herbert Ryle, who threw his energy into pushing through the idea of a memorial.

Another key supporter was the grief-striken author of The Jungle Book, Rudyard Kipling. His only son John – for whom he wrote the poem If – had been reported missing during his first charge in 1915 and was never found.

Kipling also came up with the line, “Known unto God”, which is used on the tombstones of hundreds of thousands of unknown soldiers.

British general

Britain's unknown soldier was randomly chosen from six unidentified bodies exhumed from the battlefields of Flanders, Artois and Picardy in 1920.

Brigadier General L J Wyatt made the final choice from a group of stretchers covered with the Union Jack flag after apparently being blindfolded.

At the same time in France the remains of eight unnamed French soldiers were exhumed from eight battlefields across the country and collected in Verdun, where one of the war's bloodiest battles was fought.

French private

The choice was made by a 21-year-old private, the youngest survivor of his regiment, the 132nd, who had fought at Verdun, and who had also lost his father in combat.

Not knowing what to do, he added the numbers of his regiment together and chose the sixth coffin.

The British unknown soldier was buried in Westminster Abbey at 11am on November 11th, 1920.

“Beneath this stone rests the body of a British warrior unknown by name or rank…” begins the engraving on the marble tombstone.

At the same time, the French soldier was taken to the Arc de Triomphe for a similar ceremony. But his remains were not actually buried there until January 28th, 1921.

An eternal flame burns by the tomb and its marble slab bears the inscription: “Here lies a French soldier who died for the homeland 1914-1918”.

Other countries later adopted the idea, with memorials for the unknown soldier of WWI being built in the United States in 1921, Belgium (1922), Romania (1923), Poland (1925), Australia (1993) and Canada (2000).

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

WAR

French forces tortured and murdered Algerian freedom fighter in 1950s, admits Macron

French forces "tortured and murdered" Algerian freedom fighter Ali Boumendjel during his country's war for independence, President Emmanuel Macron admitted on Tuesday, officially reappraising a death that was covered up as a suicide.

French forces tortured and murdered Algerian freedom fighter in 1950s, admits Macron
Malika, the widow of Ali Boumendjel, pictured in 2001. Photo: Stefan Fferberg/AFP

Macron made the admission “in the name of France” during a meeting with Boumendjel’s grandchildren.

The move comes after Macron in January refused to issue an official apology for abuses committed during the occupation of Algeria – instead, he agreed to form a “truth commission” as recommended by a report commissioned by the government to shed light on France’s colonial past.

Atrocities committed by both sides during the 1954-1962 Algerian war of independence continue to strain relations between the countries.

Boumendjel, a nationalist and lawyer, was arrested during the battle of Algiers by the French army, “placed incommunicado, tortured, and then killed on 23 March 1957,” the Elysee Palace said in a statement.

“Ali Boumendjel did not commit suicide. He was tortured and then killed,” Macron told Boumendjel’s grandchildren, according to the statement.

It is not the first time the real cause of death was acknowledged.

In 2000, the former head of French intelligence in Algiers Paul Aussaresses confessed to ordering Boumendjel’s death and disguising the murder as a suicide, according to the statement.

It added that Macron on Tuesday had also reiterated his desire to give families the opportunity to find out the truth about this chapter of history.

Last month, Boumendjel’s niece Fadela Boumendjel-Chitour denounced what she called the “devastating” lie the French state had told about her uncle.

French historian Benjamin Stora, who wrote the government-commissioned report, has said there is a “never-ending memory war” between the two countries.

The report has been described by the Algerian government as “not objective” and falling “below expectations.”

During his 2017 election campaign, Macron – the first president born after the colonial period – declared that the occupation of Algeria was a “crime against humanity”.

He has since said there was “no question of showing repentance” or of “presenting an apology” for abuses committed in the North African country.

SHOW COMMENTS